Alguns tuitaires han considerat erroni el vídeo, ja que, a banda del fet que Garcia és avui en dia el cognom més estès a Catalunya, segons les estadístiques, el seu origen seria català i no castellà.
The video, which makes the claim that the government of an independent Catalonia would mandate Catalans of Spanish origin to change their last names, marks an attempt by the PPC to drive the debate on secession in an ethnic direction — garnering harsh criticism from political rivals and their supporters, who have employed inclusive rhetoric , deliberately trying to frame the debate along ethnic and more generally cultural lines.