<p>That's why alchemists study so long, and National Alchemist even more. There are lots of books explaining how to do It properly, how to calculate the amounts, the type of materials, the decomjposition of things and so on.</p>

<p>They aim to use exactly what they need, not more, not less, so they work to fine-tune, to <em>understand</em> how things are made, how things work, and then replicate them as they wish.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-11T23:45:46.123Z
2012-12-11T23:45:46.123Z
Ikzer
<p>Alchemy has three stages: <em>Understanding</em>, <em>Break down</em>, <em>Rebuild</em>.</p>

<p>Different alchemists have different specializations because of the <em>Understanding</em> part, learning chemistry in general isn't easy, and digging into a specific subject (For instance, the study of the atmosphere and oxygen in Roy Mustang's case), is even harder, hence specialization.</p>

<p>Matter of "equal value" means of equal "type" (Mineral to mineral, organism to organism, you can't turn stone into a flower), and of equal <strong>Mass</strong>.</p>

<p>This works well in accordance to the physical laws of matter and energy conservation. You cannot make matter <em>disappear</em>, nor you can make it <em>appear out of nothing</em>. You can't input more matter to be on the safe side, that matter won't be used for the alchemic transmutation (at best), or result in a rebound (at worse).</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-05-07T16:35:02.603Z
@ArturiaPendragon if the reaction were endothermic the required (thermic) energy could be pulled from the surroundings, thus "decreasing" the temperature. keep in mind that physics states you can equivalently exchange mass and energy (as long as you got enough), you could sacrifice a few atoms to "generate" the required energy. keep in mind that later on a different form of energy appears (hope not too much of a spoiler...)
Vogel612
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-05-07T20:48:37.250Z
@Vogel612: Energy for alchemic reactions in Fullmetal Alchemist is drawn from the movement of tectonic plates under the earth's crust.
Madara's Ghost
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-05-08T10:28:56.723Z
@MadaraUchiha mark as spoiler ;) i was just talking about theoretical answers in the borders of "modern" "earth" physics
Vogel612
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-11T23:48:30.823Z
How about non-material to material type of alchemy (or the other way around)? For example, when Edward and Alphonse try to bring their mother back using alchemy. It is hard but it seems to be possible (although not in that situation)
Veger
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-11T23:52:51.870Z
@Veger: A soul is priceless in alchemy standard. That's why you cannot create one from nothing (A passed soul is considered "lost", it cannot be "retrieved"). They thought that by gathering the materials required to construct a human body, plus giving "Soul Information" in the form of a drop of blood, it would be enough. In reality, Alphonse's soul was placed in the created vessal, and because they didn't have the required knowledge to perfectly construct a human body (no one has), the process failed entirely. Also, as an unrelated note, it's considered a Taboo, and Truth doesn't like it.
Madara's Ghost
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-11T23:57:44.057Z
It was an example that does not spoil anything, as it is about the first thing that happened, but there are other examples where non-materials are involved that did (somehow) work... Or is it not explained and left in the dark how those work?
Veger
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T00:00:11.800Z
@Veger: Like what? I already gave Roy's example, which amplifies the oxygen levels in the air, and igniting with his gloves (Which is why he's useless on rainy days). What other example is there? Edit your question with a >!Spoiler block if you'd like.
Madara's Ghost
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T00:08:04.840Z
I did, good idea
Veger
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T02:30:32.467Z
@MadaraUchiha Technically, he's manipulating both the hydrogen (which is extremely explosive) and the Oxygen (which is extremely flammable).  And he's only useless on rainy days because his gloves are rendered incapable of sparking.  He is actually much, MUCH stronger near alot of atmosphereic water, being able to pull much larger quantities of hydrogen and oxygen than he normally could.
acolyte
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T05:17:47.553Z
@acolyte: Correct, you explained it better than I could. As for your spoiler addition, I'll edit my answer further today.
Madara's Ghost
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T09:45:50.713Z
@MadaraUchiha spoiler addition?  o.O
acolyte
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-12T13:23:10.923Z
I don't think the real physical laws of Conservation should be mentioned... Turning one substance into another requires breaking chemical bonds and forming others, and bonds can store different amounts of energy. If the reaction were [endothermic](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endothermic), it would require additional energy input into the substance, but the alchemist apparently doesn't contribute that... (and to split hairs, bond energies contribute slightly to the mass of an object, so actually Conservation of Mass doesn't really make sense, even in real life)
Arturia Pendragon
CC BY-SA 3.0
2012-12-11T23:44:55.883Z
2012-12-11T23:44:55.883Z
Madara's Ghost
<p>Alchemy, in Full Metal Alchemist, is based on the concept of 'one needs to provide materials of equal value compared to the thing one want to create' (equivalent exchange).</p>
<p>But, how does it exactly work.
Can this amount of required materials be calculated by the alchemist? If so, how? Are there some sort of lookup-tables?</p>
<p>Or does one need to guess and provides something of more value to be on the safe side? If so, can one become a more skilled alchemist by experience of successful guesses?</p>
<p>Also, different alchemists might have different specialized skills. How does that work? For the guessing part, I can imagine that one have a preference for certain kinds of alchemy and thus gain experience with a specialized skill.</p>
<p><strong>Edit</strong>: <a href="https://anime.stackexchange.com/a/106/51">Madara Uchiha</a>'s answer suggests that there are always materials required. I was also wondering about the situation where this is not the case and the alchemist was successful none the less.</p>
<p>For example:</p>
<blockquote class="spoiler">
<p> In the end Edward trades his alchemy skill in exchange for returning Alphonse's body to him.</p>
</blockquote>

<fullmetal-alchemist-series>
How does the equivalent exchange of alchemy work?
# How does the equivalent exchange of alchemy work?
Posted by: username_0 on 2012-12-11
Alchemy, in Full Metal Alchemist, is based on the concept of 'one needs to provide materials of equal value compared to the thing one want to create' (equivalent exchange).

But, how does it exactly work.
Can this amount of required materials be calculated by the alchemist? If so, how? Are there some sort of lookup-tables?

Or does one need to guess and provides something of more value to be on the safe side? If so, can one become a more skilled alchemist by experience of successful guesses?

Also, different alchemists might have different specialized skills. How does that work? For the guessing part, I can imagine that one have a preference for certain kinds of alchemy and thus gain experience with a specialized skill.

**Edit**: [Madara Uchiha](https://anime.stackexchange.com/a/106/51)'s answer suggests that there are always materials required. I was also wondering about the situation where this is not the case and the alchemist was successful none the less.

For example:

> In the end Edward trades his alchemy skill in exchange for returning Alphonse's body to him.
**Tags:** fullmetal-alchemist-series
---
## 2 answers
### Answer by username_2 on 2012-12-11. Score: 11 | Accepted answer
Alchemy has three stages: *Understanding*, *Break down*, *Rebuild*.

Different alchemists have different specializations because of the *Understanding* part, learning chemistry in general isn't easy, and digging into a specific subject (For instance, the study of the atmosphere and oxygen in Roy Mustang's case), is even harder, hence specialization.

Matter of "equal value" means of equal "type" (Mineral to mineral, organism to organism, you can't turn stone into a flower), and of equal **Mass**.

This works well in accordance to the physical laws of matter and energy conservation. You cannot make matter *disappear*, nor you can make it *appear out of nothing*. You can't input more matter to be on the safe side, that matter won't be used for the alchemic transmutation (at best), or result in a rebound (at worse).
> **Comments:**
> **username_0** (2012-12-11): How about non-material to material type of alchemy (or the other way around)? For example, when Edward and Alphonse try to bring their mother back using alchemy. It is hard but it seems to be possible (although not in that situation)  
> **username_2** (2012-12-11): @Veger: A soul is priceless in alchemy standard. That's why you cannot create one from nothing (A passed soul is considered "lost", it cannot be "retrieved"). They thought that by gathering the materials required to construct a human body, plus giving "Soul Information" in the form of a drop of blood, it would be enough. In reality, Alphonse's soul was placed in the created vessal, and because they didn't have the required knowledge to perfectly construct a human body (no one has), the process failed entirely. Also, as an unrelated note, it's considered a Taboo, and Truth doesn't like it.  
> **username_0** (2012-12-11): It was an example that does not spoil anything, as it is about the first thing that happened, but there are other examples where non-materials are involved that did (somehow) work... Or is it not explained and left in the dark how those work?  
> **username_2** (2012-12-12): @Veger: Like what? I already gave Roy's example, which amplifies the oxygen levels in the air, and igniting with his gloves (Which is why he's useless on rainy days). What other example is there? Edit your question with a >!Spoiler block if you'd like.  
> **username_0** (2012-12-12): I did, good idea  
> **username_4** (2012-12-12): @MadaraUchiha Technically, he's manipulating both the hydrogen (which is extremely explosive) and the Oxygen (which is extremely flammable).  And he's only useless on rainy days because his gloves are rendered incapable of sparking.  He is actually much, MUCH stronger near alot of atmosphereic water, being able to pull much larger quantities of hydrogen and oxygen than he normally could.  
> **username_2** (2012-12-12): @acolyte: Correct, you explained it better than I could. As for your spoiler addition, I'll edit my answer further today.  
> **username_4** (2012-12-12): @MadaraUchiha spoiler addition?  o.O  
> **username_5** (2012-12-12): I don't think the real physical laws of Conservation should be mentioned... Turning one substance into another requires breaking chemical bonds and forming others, and bonds can store different amounts of energy. If the reaction were [endothermic](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Endothermic), it would require additional energy input into the substance, but the alchemist apparently doesn't contribute that... (and to split hairs, bond energies contribute slightly to the mass of an object, so actually Conservation of Mass doesn't really make sense, even in real life)  
> **username_3** (2013-05-07): @ArturiaPendragon if the reaction were endothermic the required (thermic) energy could be pulled from the surroundings, thus "decreasing" the temperature. keep in mind that physics states you can equivalently exchange mass and energy (as long as you got enough), you could sacrifice a few atoms to "generate" the required energy. keep in mind that later on a different form of energy appears (hope not too much of a spoiler...)  
> **username_2** (2013-05-07): @Vogel612: Energy for alchemic reactions in Fullmetal Alchemist is drawn from the movement of tectonic plates under the earth's crust.  
> **username_3** (2013-05-08): @MadaraUchiha mark as spoiler ;) i was just talking about theoretical answers in the borders of "modern" "earth" physics  
---
### Answer by username_1 on 2012-12-11. Score: 1
That's why alchemists study so long, and National Alchemist even more. There are lots of books explaining how to do It properly, how to calculate the amounts, the type of materials, the decomjposition of things and so on.

They aim to use exactly what they need, not more, not less, so they work to fine-tune, to *understand* how things are made, how things work, and then replicate them as they wish.
---
