<p>While not absolutely impossible this is not a likely situation. The reason is that for a planet to be a "giant", then it will have enough gravity to hold on to its hydrogen and helium. Conversely, if you remove the H an He from a planet, it won't be "giant". There are only two gasses that are common enough in the universe to form a massive gas mantle, and those are Hydrogen and Helium.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-11-01T22:02:41.323Z
Based on surface temperature escape velocity, it might be possible.    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_escape#/media/File:Solar_system_escape_velocity_vs_surface_temperature.svg    about 2000 K for loss of hydrogen and helium.   4000 K for loss of most gasses other than CO2.  Give or take.   I'd say it's still highly unlikely, but not impossible under the right circumstances.
userLTK
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-11-01T23:44:34.807Z
That sounds right, but it still leaves the second objection: If you heat a gas giant to 3000K, and remove the H and He, what remains is not a gas giant made of CO2, it is a terrestrial planet.
James K
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-11-01T23:53:24.083Z
Fair enough.  :-)   Or, another possibility, It could form outside the frost line to obtain lots of frozen gases/ices, then migrate inwards and it would need to be maybe 10 Jupiter masses initially to retain about 1 Jupiter mass after losing hydrogen and helium.   A difference between objects like Ceres/Ganymede and Mercury, Ceres and Ganymede have retained much of their ices from formation.  Mercury never had any.   Then, add heat, the ices melt, the planet loses it's lighter gases and you have a CO2 atmosphere, potentially a massive one.    That said, the improbabilities make my brain hurt.
userLTK
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-11-01T23:59:23.747Z
And (sorry), looks like he took your check away.   I think your answer is still correct - hence my comment, not a new answer.  I was just throwing long shot ideas out there.
userLTK
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-11-01T08:23:05.383Z
2016-11-01T08:23:05.383Z
James K
<p>Is it possible that a planet originally full of water, and the solar winds decompose the water and hydrogen escapes out, then the oxygen combines with carbon at crust, just like Venus but the whole planets are mostly carbon dioxide and hence become a gas giant?</p>

<gas-giants>
Is carbon dioxide gas giants possible?
Gstestso
# Is carbon dioxide gas giants possible?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2016-11-01)

Is it possible that a planet originally full of water, and the solar winds decompose the water and hydrogen escapes out, then the oxygen combines with carbon at crust, just like Venus but the whole planets are mostly carbon dioxide and hence become a gas giant?

**Tags:** gas-giants


---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2016-11-01. Score: 6 | Accepted answer

While not absolutely impossible this is not a likely situation. The reason is that for a planet to be a "giant", then it will have enough gravity to hold on to its hydrogen and helium. Conversely, if you remove the H an He from a planet, it won't be "giant". There are only two gasses that are common enough in the universe to form a massive gas mantle, and those are Hydrogen and Helium.

> **Comments:**
> **username_2**: Based on surface temperature escape velocity, it might be possible.    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_escape#/media/File:Solar_system_escape_velocity_vs_surface_temperature.svg    about 2000 K for loss of hydrogen and helium.   4000 K for loss of most gasses other than CO2.  Give or take.   I'd say it's still highly unlikely, but not impossible under the right circumstances.  
> **username_1**: That sounds right, but it still leaves the second objection: If you heat a gas giant to 3000K, and remove the H and He, what remains is not a gas giant made of CO2, it is a terrestrial planet.  
> **username_2**: Fair enough.  :-)   Or, another possibility, It could form outside the frost line to obtain lots of frozen gases/ices, then migrate inwards and it would need to be maybe 10 Jupiter masses initially to retain about 1 Jupiter mass after losing hydrogen and helium.   A difference between objects like Ceres/Ganymede and Mercury, Ceres and Ganymede have retained much of their ices from formation.  Mercury never had any.   Then, add heat, the ices melt, the planet loses it's lighter gases and you have a CO2 atmosphere, potentially a massive one.    That said, the improbabilities make my brain hurt.  
> **username_2**: And (sorry), looks like he took your check away.   I think your answer is still correct - hence my comment, not a new answer.  I was just throwing long shot ideas out there.  

---

