<p>No, there is no spherical volume of space within which objects all tend to approach us and thereby show blue-shift. The fact that the Andromeda galaxy is blue-shifted is because at these relatively small distances the cosmological red-shift is much smaller than further away. Andromeda's own (non-cosmological speed) is larger then the cosmological speed away from us and it happens to move towards us and is therefore blue-shifted. It could also have been moving away from us, and be red-shifted as a result, but that red-shift would not be cosmological. </p>

<p>I'd expect that the chance that a nearby (Local Group) galaxy is either moving away from us or moving towards us is 50%. </p>

<p>Furthermore, the Andromeda galaxy, and all other galaxies belonging to the Local Group, are gravitationally bound and would therefore not show any cosmological red-shift anyhow.</p>

<p>NB. The Andromeda Galaxy is actually 2.5 million light years away from us.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-07-09T13:35:37.757Z
2014-07-09T13:35:37.757Z
Dieudonné
<p>The Andromeda galaxy is about 600,000 light years away and is doppler blue-shifted.  Are there objects closer to us than Andromeda which are red-shifted?  Are there objects farther than Andromeda that are blue-shifted?</p>

<p>I'm curious as to whether there is a more or less uniform radius from earth outside of which objects are generally all moving away from us, and inside of which objects are generally all moving towards us.</p>

<gravity><light><redshift>
Is there a radius inside of which objects are (doppler) blue shifted?
Valent
# Is there a radius inside of which objects are (doppler) blue shifted?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2014-07-09)

The Andromeda galaxy is about 600,000 light years away and is doppler blue-shifted. Are there objects closer to us than Andromeda which are red-shifted? Are there objects farther than Andromeda that are blue-shifted?

I'm curious as to whether there is a more or less uniform radius from earth outside of which objects are generally all moving away from us, and inside of which objects are generally all moving towards us.

**Tags:** gravity, light, redshift


---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2014-07-09. Score: 3

No, there is no spherical volume of space within which objects all tend to approach us and thereby show blue-shift. The fact that the Andromeda galaxy is blue-shifted is because at these relatively small distances the cosmological red-shift is much smaller than further away. Andromeda's own (non-cosmological speed) is larger then the cosmological speed away from us and it happens to move towards us and is therefore blue-shifted. It could also have been moving away from us, and be red-shifted as a result, but that red-shift would not be cosmological.

I'd expect that the chance that a nearby (Local Group) galaxy is either moving away from us or moving towards us is 50%.

Furthermore, the Andromeda galaxy, and all other galaxies belonging to the Local Group, are gravitationally bound and would therefore not show any cosmological red-shift anyhow.

NB. The Andromeda Galaxy is actually 2.5 million light years away from us.


---

