<p>ConnorGarcia's answer is great. The point about refraction is particularly interesting. I just wanted to describe the mechanism a bit. If you look at the sky on cloudless day, it appears blue and is brighter than the blackness of space. Where does this light come from? It is sunlight scattered by the atmosphere. So, ignoring refraction, if you look directly at the sun (hypothetically—don't do it in real life and ruin your eyes), it is a bit less bright than it would be if there were no atmosphere. <strong>Some of the light coming directly from the sun is scattered, which makes the whole sky light up (with a preference for blue).</strong></p>
<p>The same would be true for the Earth as viewed from the Moon. With a sufficiently thick atmosphere, the sky on the Moon during lunar night would no longer be as black as it is now. <strong>Some of the Earthshine would be scattered by the atmosphere, lighting the whole sky and reducing the intensity of the direct light from the Earth.</strong></p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-02-10T01:48:03.940Z
2021-02-10T01:48:03.940Z
WaterMolecule
<p>The lack of a lunar atmosphere doesn't affect Earth's albedo at all, since albedo is only a measure of the diffuse reflection of a body.</p>
<p>However, the apparent brightness of the Earth as viewed from the surface of the Moon would be affected if the Moon had an atmosphere.  This, of course, would depend on the atmospheric composition of the Moon.</p>
<p>If the atmospheric composition of the Moon was such that it absorbed visible light, then the Earth would appear dimmer, or perhaps not even be directly visible (similar to how we can't directly see the Moon when the weather is cloudy here on Earth).</p>
<p>If the atmospheric composition of the Moon absorbed almost no visible light, and was highly refractive, the Earth-Shine might be overall brighter than if the Moon had no atmosphere at all. The refraction would bend some of the Earth-Shine into the surface of the Moon which otherwise would have passed by. This picture shows the analogous situation for Earth and the Sun:</p>
<p><a href="https://i.sstatic.net/pMik2.png" rel="noreferrer"><img src="https://i.sstatic.net/pMik2.png" alt="enter image description here" /></a></p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2021-02-09T17:45:56.467Z
2021-02-09T17:57:10.607Z
2021-02-09T17:57:10.607Z
Connor Garcia
<p>The earth acts like a light-globe in the sky for half of the moon, the side that is facing the earth. In what way does lack of moon atmosphere influence earth-shine. Does it make earth-albedo brighter, or dimmer? Either way, do we know with how much? Put differently; would an atmosphere make it easier, or more difficult, to read a newspaper on the earth facing lunar surface, after sunset?</p>

<the-moon><albedo>
Does lack of atmosphere on the moon make earth-shine more, or less, bright?
Constantthin
# Does lack of atmosphere on the moon make earth-shine more, or less, bright?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2021-02-09)

The earth acts like a light-globe in the sky for half of the moon, the side that is facing the earth. In what way does lack of moon atmosphere influence earth-shine. Does it make earth-albedo brighter, or dimmer? Either way, do we know with how much? Put differently; would an atmosphere make it easier, or more difficult, to read a newspaper on the earth facing lunar surface, after sunset?

**Tags:** the-moon, albedo


---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2021-02-10. Score: 4 | Accepted answer

username_2's answer is great. The point about refraction is particularly interesting. I just wanted to describe the mechanism a bit. If you look at the sky on cloudless day, it appears blue and is brighter than the blackness of space. Where does this light come from? It is sunlight scattered by the atmosphere. So, ignoring refraction, if you look directly at the sun (hypothetically—don't do it in real life and ruin your eyes), it is a bit less bright than it would be if there were no atmosphere. **Some of the light coming directly from the sun is scattered, which makes the whole sky light up (with a preference for blue).**

The same would be true for the Earth as viewed from the Moon. With a sufficiently thick atmosphere, the sky on the Moon during lunar night would no longer be as black as it is now. **Some of the Earthshine would be scattered by the atmosphere, lighting the whole sky and reducing the intensity of the direct light from the Earth.**


---

### Answer by username_2 on 2021-02-09. Score: 11

The lack of a lunar atmosphere doesn't affect Earth's albedo at all, since albedo is only a measure of the diffuse reflection of a body.

However, the apparent brightness of the Earth as viewed from the surface of the Moon would be affected if the Moon had an atmosphere. This, of course, would depend on the atmospheric composition of the Moon.

If the atmospheric composition of the Moon was such that it absorbed visible light, then the Earth would appear dimmer, or perhaps not even be directly visible (similar to how we can't directly see the Moon when the weather is cloudy here on Earth).

If the atmospheric composition of the Moon absorbed almost no visible light, and was highly refractive, the Earth-Shine might be overall brighter than if the Moon had no atmosphere at all. The refraction would bend some of the Earth-Shine into the surface of the Moon which otherwise would have passed by. This picture shows the analogous situation for Earth and the Sun:

[![enter image description here](https://i.sstatic.net/pMik2.png)](https://i.sstatic.net/pMik2.png)


---

