<p>I've noticed that while playing rhythm games--games where I must press buttons precisely in step with a musical accompaniment--I can either play or I can talk. If start talking, I'll almost immediately lose the beat, or I'll talk between the gaps in the beat in a very odd but unintentional manner; it's like I simply can't focus on both at the same time.</p>

<p>I (and many others, judging from Twitch.tv) can still input precise button processes at exact times while talking, so it's not my sense of timing that's off. And it's not that my talking covers the music; I can turn the music up while talking and still falter, and I can mute the music after I get going and keep up the beat. It seems to be specifically my rhythmic timing that's off when I speak.</p>

<p>What would cause speech to interrupt one's sense of rhythm like this when it doesn't interrupt other types of precise timing? I was unfortunately quite unable to find anything about this while searching, just a bunch of articles on impaired speech.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-03-23T01:13:09.487Z
Serious question: does this still happen if you talk at the same BPM as the music (or happen as strongly)?  My suspicion would be that we only have one processing region for decoding rhythm (I doubt that's correct, but...) - which would be crucial for speech and other sound-related tasks, mostly because rhythm can carry a great deal of the semantics of auditory information.
BenCole
CC BY-SA 3.0
2013-03-25T00:00:23.737Z
An additional observation: In order to sing and play an instrument at the same time I needed to ensure that I both understood the rhythm of the melody and the rhythm of the music and that I was able to align the two to a common beat.
Jeromy Anglim
<motor>
Why does speaking disrupt rhythm?
Zelda
# Why does speaking disrupt rhythm?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2013-03-22)

I've noticed that while playing rhythm games--games where I must press buttons precisely in step with a musical accompaniment--I can either play or I can talk. If start talking, I'll almost immediately lose the beat, or I'll talk between the gaps in the beat in a very odd but unintentional manner; it's like I simply can't focus on both at the same time.

I (and many others, judging from Twitch.tv) can still input precise button processes at exact times while talking, so it's not my sense of timing that's off. And it's not that my talking covers the music; I can turn the music up while talking and still falter, and I can mute the music after I get going and keep up the beat. It seems to be specifically my rhythmic timing that's off when I speak.

What would cause speech to interrupt one's sense of rhythm like this when it doesn't interrupt other types of precise timing? I was unfortunately quite unable to find anything about this while searching, just a bunch of articles on impaired speech.

**Tags:** motor

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Serious question: does this still happen if you talk at the same BPM as the music (or happen as strongly)?  My suspicion would be that we only have one processing region for decoding rhythm (I doubt that's correct, but...) - which would be crucial for speech and other sound-related tasks, mostly because rhythm can carry a great deal of the semantics of auditory information.  
> **username_2**: An additional observation: In order to sing and play an instrument at the same time I needed to ensure that I both understood the rhythm of the melody and the rhythm of the music and that I was able to align the two to a common beat.  

---

## 0 answers

