<p>Idioms are mostly elegant, memorable and meaningful phrases. Each character in an idiom has a part to play in depicting a vivid image or retold a historical story. </p>

<p>It is difficult to swap any character in an idiom without making it sound forced. The phrase "萬綠叢中一點紅" depicts an image of a single eye- catching red flower among a field of green grass, that seem natural enough.  On the other hand, the image of "萬紅叢中一點綠" just does not seem natural. </p>

<blockquote>
  <p>Is swapping words within an idiom often done in chinese language?</p>
</blockquote>

<p>The answer to your question is-- "<strong>rarely</strong>"</p>

<p>I can only come up with one decent example:</p>

<p>"鋤強扶弱" (beat down the powerful to support the helpless) is an idiom describes 'just and heroic deeds'. Quite a romantic notion. But this kind of hero in real life is very hard to find. In fact, you would see people bully the helpless to support the powerful more often. "鋤弱扶強" describe this behavior perfectly. </p>

<p>Edit: Another one that would work</p>

<p>直言不諱- speak honestly, not avoiding taboo subjects</p>

<p>諱不直言- avoid taboo subjects, not speaking honestly</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-07-21T23:11:13.433Z
2017-07-22T23:26:42.480Z
2017-07-22T23:26:42.480Z
Tang Ho
<p>No, it is not a common case.</p>

<p>Idiom have fixed form, if you swap the character intentionally, you can make special effect to give a strong impression. Like your example. other example:</p>

<p>鹤立鸡群 -> 鸡立鹤群</p>

<p>But some Idiom have different variation,  so this will not give that effect.</p>

<p>不亢不卑 &lt;-> 不卑不亢
不闻不问 &lt;-> 不问不闻</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-07-22T03:06:52.630Z
2017-07-22T03:06:52.630Z
sfy
<p>For example:</p>

<p>"万绿丛中一点红" : a single red among ten thousand of green/a single red flower in the midst of thick foliage</p>

<p>I've found some people wrote "万红丛中一点绿" (a single green among ten thousand of red).</p>

<ol>
<li><p>Is swapping words like that often used in mandarin? Does it have any special purpose?</p></li>
<li><p>Do the two idioms I mentioned above act as metaphor? Would you mind explaining them to me?</p></li>
</ol>

<translation><grammar><usage><difference><idioms>
Is swapping words within an idiom often done in chinese language? (example: "万绿丛中一点红" to "万红丛中一点绿")
# Is swapping words within an idiom often done in chinese language? (example: "万绿丛中一点红" to "万红丛中一点绿")

(Asked by: username_0 on 2017-07-21)

For example:

"万绿丛中一点红" : a single red among ten thousand of green/a single red flower in the midst of thick foliage

I've found some people wrote "万红丛中一点绿" (a single green among ten thousand of red).

1. Is swapping words like that often used in mandarin? Does it have any special purpose?
2. Do the two idioms I mentioned above act as metaphor? Would you mind explaining them to me?

**Tags:** translation, grammar, usage, difference, idioms


---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2017-07-21. Score: 3

Idioms are mostly elegant, memorable and meaningful phrases. Each character in an idiom has a part to play in depicting a vivid image or retold a historical story.

It is difficult to swap any character in an idiom without making it sound forced. The phrase "萬綠叢中一點紅" depicts an image of a single eye- catching red flower among a field of green grass, that seem natural enough. On the other hand, the image of "萬紅叢中一點綠" just does not seem natural.

> Is swapping words within an idiom often done in chinese language?

The answer to your question is-- "**rarely**"

I can only come up with one decent example:

"鋤強扶弱" (beat down the powerful to support the helpless) is an idiom describes 'just and heroic deeds'. Quite a romantic notion. But this kind of hero in real life is very hard to find. In fact, you would see people bully the helpless to support the powerful more often. "鋤弱扶強" describe this behavior perfectly.

Edit: Another one that would work

直言不諱- speak honestly, not avoiding taboo subjects

諱不直言- avoid taboo subjects, not speaking honestly


---

### Answer by username_2 on 2017-07-22. Score: 2

No, it is not a common case.

Idiom have fixed form, if you swap the character intentionally, you can make special effect to give a strong impression. Like your example. other example:

鹤立鸡群 -> 鸡立鹤群

But some Idiom have different variation, so this will not give that effect.

不亢不卑 <-> 不卑不亢
不闻不问 <-> 不问不闻


---

