<p>According to the two-vowel analysis of Standard Mandarin phonology, the statement that:</p>
<blockquote>
<p>An allophone of the middle vowel /ə/ is described as [o]</p>
</blockquote>
<p>... still 'holds' for closed syllables ending in /-ŋ/, not just for open syllables. The medial can be either /w/ or /ɥ/.</p>
<p>For closed syllables ending in /-n/, the same /ə/ nucleus corresponds to <em>wen</em> / <em>-un</em> (as in 文、敦) and <em>yun</em> / <em>-un</em> (允、群) in Pinyin.</p>
<p>This is actually the 'literal' interpretation of the 注音符號 (aka bopomofo) renditions for Standard Mandarin phonology. See how 征 is ㄓㄥ (<em>zhēng</em> = <em>zh + eng</em>), whereas 中 is ㄓㄨㄥ (<em>zhōng</em>, literally <em>zh + wu + eng</em>) with a kind of 'compound final'. This also applies to the endings in -n (ㄨㄣ for <em>wen</em> = <em>wu</em> + <em>en</em> and ㄩㄣ for <em>yun</em> = <em>yü</em> + <em>en</em>).</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2023-12-10T01:38:00.423Z
wonder why this source would omit such a common detail, given the depth it goes into about all the other allophones...
Senjougahara Hitagi
CC BY-SA 4.0
2023-11-20T19:53:03.820Z
2023-11-20T19:53:03.820Z
Michaelyus
<p>start quote &lt;&lt; The precise realization of each vowel depends on its phonetic environment. In particular, the vowel /ə/ has two broad allophones [e] and [o] (corresponding respectively to pinyin e and o in most cases). These sounds can be treated as a single underlying phoneme because they are in complementary distribution. The mid vowel phoneme may also be treated as an underspecified vowel, attracting features either from the adjacent sounds or from default rules resulting in /ə/. (Apparent counterexamples are provided by certain interjections, such as [ɔ], [ɛ], [jɔ], and [lɔ], but these are normally treated as special cases operating outside the normal phonemic system.[b]  &gt;&gt; end quote</p>
<p>So yes, it is considered a midvowel, but is also underspecified with multiple features/ forms apparent.  This is why not everything matches a single format/ IPA value/ whatever you want to call it.</p>
<hr />
<p>Direct quote from the wikipedia of standard chinese phonology.  See the chart of the sounds including o on the original page as well as more info:</p>
<p><a href="https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Chinese_phonology" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Chinese_phonology</a></p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2023-11-20T08:36:52.540Z
2023-11-20T08:36:52.540Z
zagrycha
<p>So I've been looking at San Duanmu's <em>The Phonology of Standard Chinese</em>, and in the vowel section, the pinyin /o/ from 中 is not mentioned. An allophone of the middle vowel is described as [o], which is said to appear &quot;in open syllables after labials&quot;. The examples given are 我 and 波, so fine we could understand the liprounding in 卓 as being a &quot;bilabial&quot; and so it's realized as [zh<sup>w</sup>o]. That however doesn't explain 中 which is clearly not an open syllable. What gives?</p>

<pronunciation><phonology>
Where does the "o" sound fit into Chinese phonology? Is it a mid vowel?
# Where does the "o" sound fit into Chinese phonology? Is it a mid vowel?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2023-11-20)

So I've been looking at San Duanmu's *The Phonology of Standard Chinese*, and in the vowel section, the pinyin /o/ from 中 is not mentioned. An allophone of the middle vowel is described as [o], which is said to appear "in open syllables after labials". The examples given are 我 and 波, so fine we could understand the liprounding in 卓 as being a "bilabial" and so it's realized as [zhwo]. That however doesn't explain 中 which is clearly not an open syllable. What gives?

**Tags:** pronunciation, phonology


---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2023-11-20. Score: 3

According to the two-vowel analysis of Standard Mandarin phonology, the statement that:

> An allophone of the middle vowel /ə/ is described as [o]

... still 'holds' for closed syllables ending in /-ŋ/, not just for open syllables. The medial can be either /w/ or /ɥ/.

For closed syllables ending in /-n/, the same /ə/ nucleus corresponds to *wen* / *-un* (as in 文、敦) and *yun* / *-un* (允、群) in Pinyin.

This is actually the 'literal' interpretation of the 注音符號 (aka bopomofo) renditions for Standard Mandarin phonology. See how 征 is ㄓㄥ (*zhēng* = *zh + eng*), whereas 中 is ㄓㄨㄥ (*zhōng*, literally *zh + wu + eng*) with a kind of 'compound final'. This also applies to the endings in -n (ㄨㄣ for *wen* = *wu* + *en* and ㄩㄣ for *yun* = *yü* + *en*).

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: wonder why this source would omit such a common detail, given the depth it goes into about all the other allophones...  

---

### Answer by username_2 on 2023-11-20. Score: 0

start quote << The precise realization of each vowel depends on its phonetic environment. In particular, the vowel /ə/ has two broad allophones [e] and [o] (corresponding respectively to pinyin e and o in most cases). These sounds can be treated as a single underlying phoneme because they are in complementary distribution. The mid vowel phoneme may also be treated as an underspecified vowel, attracting features either from the adjacent sounds or from default rules resulting in /ə/. (Apparent counterexamples are provided by certain interjections, such as [ɔ], [ɛ], [jɔ], and [lɔ], but these are normally treated as special cases operating outside the normal phonemic system.[b] >> end quote

So yes, it is considered a midvowel, but is also underspecified with multiple features/ forms apparent. This is why not everything matches a single format/ IPA value/ whatever you want to call it.

---

Direct quote from the wikipedia of standard chinese phonology. See the chart of the sounds including o on the original page as well as more info:

<https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Chinese_phonology>


---

