<p>Doctrinal Interpretation would be a good translation. For these types of translation, it's important to localize and keep the original meaning as much as possible. </p>

<p><a href="http://thefederalistpapers.org/principles-of-constitutional-interpretation" rel="nofollow">http://thefederalistpapers.org/principles-of-constitutional-interpretation</a><br>
The above link presents us with six main methods of interpretation when looking at law: textual, historical, functional, doctrinal, prudential, equitable, and natural. </p>

<p>Out of the six, doctrinal is presented as : <strong><em>Decision based on prevailing practices or opinions of legal professionals</em></strong>, mainly legislative, executive, or judicial precedents, according to the meta-doctrine of stare decisis, which treats the principles according to which court decisions have been made as not merely advisory but as normative.</p>

<p><a href="http://www.twwiki.com/wiki/%E5%AD%B8%E7%90%86%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B" rel="nofollow">http://www.twwiki.com/wiki/%E5%AD%B8%E7%90%86%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B</a><br>
This link explains that doctrinal interpretation, 學理解釋是專家學者從法律理論/各家學說的角度對法律所作出的解釋，沒有法律強制力，不是法官審判案件的依據，不具法律約束力，但是從法律的淵源及將來的發展來看，學理解釋是一個很重要的法學發展的推動力量。<br>
A rough translation would be: The doctrinal interpretation of the law from a "philosophical (法律理論)" and "professional (專家學者)" standpoint, is not legally enforced, does not present itself as the basis for a judge to judge a case, and is not legally binding, but is rather viewed from the "original legislature (法律的淵源)" and its' future interpretation. Doctrinal interpretation is an important driving force for the development of laws. </p>

<p>You can kind of see that doctrinal interpretation has more of a philosophical/theory type of definition and is more often used for discussing laws.  </p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-10-03T09:38:54.403Z
Disclaimer: I'm not a lawyer myself, but I translate hospital documents for accreditation.
辛祐賦 hsinyofu
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-10-03T09:37:11.540Z
2016-10-03T09:37:11.540Z
辛祐賦 hsinyofu
<p>is it a term in civil law only? cause i searched in these four:</p>

<p><a href="http://www.legislation.gov.hk/eng/glossary/homeglos.htm" rel="nofollow">English-Chinese Glossary of Legal Terms</a></p>

<p><a href="http://www.hklii.hk/eng/" rel="nofollow">Hong Kong Legal Information Institute</a></p>

<p><a href="http://www.worldlii.org" rel="nofollow">World Legal Information Institute</a></p>

<p><a href="http://terms.naer.edu.tw" rel="nofollow">雙語詞彙資料庫, of taiwan</a></p>

<p>non of them has the term "doctrinal intepretation".</p>

<p>so, the finding you had, is the "only" translation in chinese now; which means "better than nothing".</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-08-02T06:41:23.430Z
Did you find anything else? Any other terms
Mou某
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-08-02T06:47:18.927Z
in japanese, it's "合理的解釈" http://ejje.weblio.jp/content/doctrinal+interpretation. term "doctrine", "interpretation" are translated seperately in the above mentioned 4 sites. and, i've impression that "doctrinal" triggers more results related to religion :)  in summary, it does not help to a proper legal term. :(
水巷孑蠻
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-08-02T07:35:24.720Z
Can you find anything that might constitute a proper legal term in English?
Mou某
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-08-02T08:34:35.427Z
if started from 學理解釋, i would suggest ( theoretical | academic ) x ( interpretation | explanation ). the fact of no findings in the world legal info institute, i think it implies something :)
水巷孑蠻
CC BY-SA 3.0
2016-08-02T05:50:59.443Z
2016-08-02T05:50:59.443Z
水巷孑蠻
<p>The most common translation I've seen online for <a href="http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=cojtL7sC08vIYwgZYPsCBWseYtQRylaRunZIPaorKLjsgW_2VU2iCJOmIZkLQa9meR8dGV-2NzKHL9t0HDwiiq" rel="nofollow">学理解释</a> is:</p>

<blockquote>
  <p>academic interpretation</p>
</blockquote>

<p>but looking up information in English about <a href="https://www.google.com.hk/?gws_rd=cr,ssl#newwindow=1&amp;safe=strict&amp;q=academic%20interpretation" rel="nofollow">academic interpretation</a> kind of only gives results from the original translation or stuff that means something completely different.</p>

<p><a href="http://dict.cnki.net/dict_result.aspx?searchword=doctrinal%20interpretation&amp;tjType=sentence&amp;style=&amp;t=%E5%AD%A6%E7%90%86%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8A" rel="nofollow">CNKI</a> has a completely different, and consistent translation, though:</p>

<blockquote>
  <p>Criminal Treatment of the Juvenile Crime:<strong>Doctrinal Interpretation</strong> from the Perspective of Criminal Policy
      未成年人犯罪的刑法处遇——刑事政策视域下的<strong>学理解释</strong></p>
</blockquote>

<p><br></p>

<blockquote>
  <p>In fact, the interpretation of criminal law is a organism, whose whole function is determined directly by three elements, namely legislative interpretation, judicial interpretation, <strong>doctrinal interpretation</strong>, and their interrelation ship as well.
      刑法解释体制是一个有机系统 ,立法解释、司法解释、<strong>学理解释</strong>三部分的自身状况及相互关系决定刑法解释体制整体性能的良性发挥。</p>
</blockquote>

<p><br></p>

<blockquote>
  <p><strong>Doctrinal interpretation</strong> initiates application and interpretation of penal code 17th section and second paragraph,it would persevere definition way of the theory of conduct plus the theory of accusation;
      其中<strong>学理解释</strong>在弘扬该刑事政策的基础上,在未成年人犯罪的刑法处遇上倡导:对刑法典第17条第2款的解释和适用,应坚守行为说+罪名说的限定方式;</p>
</blockquote>

<p>I'm more willing to trust CNKI than Baidu, but I'm no lawyer - I'm not sure if Doctrinal interpretation means anything at all.</p>

<p><a href="http://lawyer.get.com.tw/Dic/DictionaryDetail.aspx?iDT=48033" rel="nofollow">lawyer.get.com.tw</a> also has the following:</p>

<blockquote>
  <p><strong>詞條</strong></p>
  
  <p>doctrinal interpretation</p>
  
  <p><strong>中文</strong></p>
  
  <p>學理解釋</p>
  
  <p><strong>解釋</strong></p>
  
  <p>與法定解釋〔legal interpretation〕相對，其依法律本身內在的合理性進行解釋。按其解釋方法不同，又可分為語法解釋〔grammatical interpretation〕和邏輯解釋〔logical interpretation〕。
  → interpretation ( 撰)</p>
</blockquote>

<p><a href="http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/interpretation" rel="nofollow">The Free Dictionary</a> has some info:</p>

<blockquote>
  <ol start="4">
  <li>According to the civilians there are three sorts of interpretations, the authentic, the usual, and the doctrinal. </li>
  </ol>
</blockquote>

<p><br></p>

<blockquote>
  <p>7.-3. It is doctrinal when it is made agreeably to rules of science. The Commentaries of learned lawyers in this case furnish the greatest assistance. This last kind of interpretation is itself divided into, three distinct classes. Doctrinal interpretation is extensive, restrictive, or declaratory. 1st. It is extensive whenever the reason of the law has a more enlarged sense than its terms, and it is consequently applied to a case which had not been explained. 2d. On the contrary, it is restrictive when the expressions of the law have a greater latitude than its reasons, so that by a restricted interpretation, an exception is made in a case which the law does not seem to have embraced. 3d. When the reason of the law and the terms in which it is conceived agree, and it is only necessary to explain them to have the sense complete, the interpretation is declaratory. 8. The term interpretation is used by foreign jurists in nearly the same sense that we use the word construction. (q. v.)</p>
</blockquote>

<p>but, again, I'm no law expert.</p>

<p>Is doctrinal interpretation a proper translation of 学理解释?</p>

<translation>
Translation: 学理解释
# Translation: 学理解释

(Asked by: username_0 on 2016-08-01)

The most common translation I've seen online for [学理解释](http://baike.baidu.com/link?url=cojtL7sC08vIYwgZYPsCBWseYtQRylaRunZIPaorKLjsgW_2VU2iCJOmIZkLQa9meR8dGV-2NzKHL9t0HDwiiq) is:

> academic interpretation

but looking up information in English about [academic interpretation](https://www.google.com.hk/?gws_rd=cr,ssl#newwindow=1&safe=strict&q=academic%20interpretation) kind of only gives results from the original translation or stuff that means something completely different.

[CNKI](http://dict.cnki.net/dict_result.aspx?searchword=doctrinal%20interpretation&tjType=sentence&style=&t=%E5%AD%A6%E7%90%86%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8A) has a completely different, and consistent translation, though:

> Criminal Treatment of the Juvenile Crime:**Doctrinal Interpretation** from the Perspective of Criminal Policy
> 未成年人犯罪的刑法处遇——刑事政策视域下的**学理解释**

> In fact, the interpretation of criminal law is a organism, whose whole function is determined directly by three elements, namely legislative interpretation, judicial interpretation, **doctrinal interpretation**, and their interrelation ship as well.
> 刑法解释体制是一个有机系统 ,立法解释、司法解释、**学理解释**三部分的自身状况及相互关系决定刑法解释体制整体性能的良性发挥。

> **Doctrinal interpretation** initiates application and interpretation of penal code 17th section and second paragraph,it would persevere definition way of the theory of conduct plus the theory of accusation;
> 其中**学理解释**在弘扬该刑事政策的基础上,在未成年人犯罪的刑法处遇上倡导:对刑法典第17条第2款的解释和适用,应坚守行为说+罪名说的限定方式;

I'm more willing to trust CNKI than Baidu, but I'm no lawyer - I'm not sure if Doctrinal interpretation means anything at all.

[lawyer.get.com.tw](http://lawyer.get.com.tw/Dic/DictionaryDetail.aspx?iDT=48033) also has the following:

> **詞條**
>
> doctrinal interpretation
>
> **中文**
>
> 學理解釋
>
> **解釋**
>
> 與法定解釋〔legal interpretation〕相對，其依法律本身內在的合理性進行解釋。按其解釋方法不同，又可分為語法解釋〔grammatical interpretation〕和邏輯解釋〔logical interpretation〕。
> → interpretation ( 撰)

[The Free Dictionary](http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/interpretation) has some info:

> 4. According to the civilians there are three sorts of interpretations, the authentic, the usual, and the doctrinal.

> 7.-3. It is doctrinal when it is made agreeably to rules of science. The Commentaries of learned lawyers in this case furnish the greatest assistance. This last kind of interpretation is itself divided into, three distinct classes. Doctrinal interpretation is extensive, restrictive, or declaratory. 1st. It is extensive whenever the reason of the law has a more enlarged sense than its terms, and it is consequently applied to a case which had not been explained. 2d. On the contrary, it is restrictive when the expressions of the law have a greater latitude than its reasons, so that by a restricted interpretation, an exception is made in a case which the law does not seem to have embraced. 3d. When the reason of the law and the terms in which it is conceived agree, and it is only necessary to explain them to have the sense complete, the interpretation is declaratory. 8. The term interpretation is used by foreign jurists in nearly the same sense that we use the word construction. (q. v.)

but, again, I'm no law expert.

Is doctrinal interpretation a proper translation of 学理解释?

**Tags:** translation


---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2016-10-03. Score: 2 | Accepted answer

Doctrinal Interpretation would be a good translation. For these types of translation, it's important to localize and keep the original meaning as much as possible.

<http://thefederalistpapers.org/principles-of-constitutional-interpretation>  
The above link presents us with six main methods of interpretation when looking at law: textual, historical, functional, doctrinal, prudential, equitable, and natural.

Out of the six, doctrinal is presented as : ***Decision based on prevailing practices or opinions of legal professionals***, mainly legislative, executive, or judicial precedents, according to the meta-doctrine of stare decisis, which treats the principles according to which court decisions have been made as not merely advisory but as normative.

<http://www.twwiki.com/wiki/%E5%AD%B8%E7%90%86%E8%A7%A3%E9%87%8B>  
This link explains that doctrinal interpretation, 學理解釋是專家學者從法律理論/各家學說的角度對法律所作出的解釋，沒有法律強制力，不是法官審判案件的依據，不具法律約束力，但是從法律的淵源及將來的發展來看，學理解釋是一個很重要的法學發展的推動力量。  
A rough translation would be: The doctrinal interpretation of the law from a "philosophical (法律理論)" and "professional (專家學者)" standpoint, is not legally enforced, does not present itself as the basis for a judge to judge a case, and is not legally binding, but is rather viewed from the "original legislature (法律的淵源)" and its' future interpretation. Doctrinal interpretation is an important driving force for the development of laws.

You can kind of see that doctrinal interpretation has more of a philosophical/theory type of definition and is more often used for discussing laws.

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Disclaimer: I'm not a lawyer myself, but I translate hospital documents for accreditation.  

---

### Answer by username_2 on 2016-08-02. Score: 0

is it a term in civil law only? cause i searched in these four:

[English-Chinese Glossary of Legal Terms](http://www.legislation.gov.hk/eng/glossary/homeglos.htm)

[Hong Kong Legal Information Institute](http://www.hklii.hk/eng/)

[World Legal Information Institute](http://www.worldlii.org)

[雙語詞彙資料庫, of taiwan](http://terms.naer.edu.tw)

non of them has the term "doctrinal intepretation".

so, the finding you had, is the "only" translation in chinese now; which means "better than nothing".

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: Did you find anything else? Any other terms  
> **username_2**: in japanese, it's "合理的解釈" http://ejje.weblio.jp/content/doctrinal+interpretation. term "doctrine", "interpretation" are translated seperately in the above mentioned 4 sites. and, i've impression that "doctrinal" triggers more results related to religion :)  in summary, it does not help to a proper legal term. :(  
> **username_0**: Can you find anything that might constitute a proper legal term in English?  
> **username_2**: if started from 學理解釋, i would suggest ( theoretical | academic ) x ( interpretation | explanation ). the fact of no findings in the world legal info institute, i think it implies something :)  

---

