<p>愛人跟人走<br>
my love has gone with someone else</p>

<pre><code>離開已經三年後  
It's already 3 years since you left me;
你煞有去無回頭
you gone away without turning back
真是乎人想抹到
[This] really is unexpected.
心肝親像磅心的菜頭
My heart is like a broken radish

想抹到想抹到
I couldn't imagine, I couldn't imagine
你會去跟人走
You would go away with someone else.
無彩我無彩我
You didn't care for me, you didn't care for me,
感情用這厚
Who had so deep feelings [for you].
外表漂泊無捨效
Looking handsome, natural and unrestrained was of no effect.
誤人青春上可惱
wasting people's youth is the most annoying.

啊無情的人
Ah… cruel person,
恨你是恨到老
hate you forever(until I'm old, or until death).
永遠來甲你
With you I will never…
田無溝水無流
across the line to each other (have a relationship)
</code></pre>

<p>word meanings and notes:</p>

<p>無彩:</p>

<pre><code>無彩: means "in vain", "uselessly",  
the translation above is **meaning translation**,  
because he don't care about me, so whatever I do, is useless
the **direct translation** is:
無彩我無彩我
waste my, waste my
感情用這厚
so deep feelings [for you].
</code></pre>

<p>煞:</p>

<pre><code>煞 also means "surprisingly"
你煞有去無回頭
you gone away surprisingly without turning back
</code></pre>

<blockquote>
  <p>田無溝水無流：</p>
  
  <blockquote>
    <p>direct translation ( or literal translation )is:  </p>
    
    <blockquote>
      <p>If the field has no ditch, the water won't flow. </p>
    </blockquote>
    
    <p>metaphor explaining:  </p>
    
    <blockquote>
      <p>"the field" is like " I ", "the water" is like " you (or he, the one who left her)".<br>
      ditch, in OALD8, the english meaning is:<br>
      a long channel dug at the side of a field or road, to hold or take away water<br>
      so, "the ditch" is like "the way to contact me"<br>
      "flow" is like "talk to me or touch me"<br>
      so, the whole sentence is:<br>
      if I don't allow you to contact me, you won't have any chance to talk to me or touch me.  </p>
    </blockquote>
  </blockquote>
</blockquote>

<p>useful online dictionary:</p>

<p><a href="http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/index.html" rel="nofollow">http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/index.html</a></p>

<p><a href="http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/result_detail.jsp?n_no=9721&amp;curpage=1&amp;sample=%E7%85%9E&amp;radiobutton=1&amp;querytarget=1&amp;limit=20&amp;pagenum=1&amp;rowcount=13" rel="nofollow">http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/result_detail.jsp?n_no=9721&amp;curpage=1&amp;sample=%E7%85%9E&amp;radiobutton=1&amp;querytarget=1&amp;limit=20&amp;pagenum=1&amp;rowcount=13</a></p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-14T08:21:36.763Z
OK. But doesn't `bô-tshái` mean `kěxì` or `in vain`? And isn't `suah-ū` the same as `哪有`, which means `how did you…?`? Also, `until` has one l. `till` has two.
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-14T13:32:43.833Z
I have edited the anwser again.  And thank you for correcting my english.
papapasan
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-14T13:42:39.337Z
You are welcome. I'd suggest block quotes rather than preformatted text for the notes on the words. What does `田無溝水無流` mean exactly? I mean, it's used in some metaphorical way, since the literal meaning is (isn't it?) the one I stated in the question. So what does it mean in this "metaphorical" sense?
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-14T15:01:54.733Z
I have edited the anwser again.  your literal meaning is right. and I've added metaphor explaining. and I've learned something new about "stackexchange" from you.
papapasan
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-14T03:47:45.440Z
2014-09-14T14:59:23.387Z
2014-09-14T14:59:23.387Z
papapasan
<p>I have come across the song <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vV3u83PldY" rel="nofollow">爱人跟人走</a> (<a href="http://mojim.com/twy100106x2x8.htm" rel="nofollow">lyrics here</a>). I'll give a complete translation attempt of this Hokkien song:</p>

<pre><code>It's already 3 years since you left me;
Have you gone away without [ever] turning back?
[This] really is unexpected.
My heart is like a hollow turnip.

I couldn't imagine, I couldn't imagine
You would go away with someone else.
You didn't care for me, you didn't care for me,
Who had so deep feelings [for you].

Looking unrestrained was of no effect.
Someone's youth was very irritating.
Ah… cruel person,
I hate that you hate old people.
With you I will always…
If the field has no ditch, the water won't flow.
</code></pre>

<p>As you can guess, the problematic part is:</p>

<pre><code>外表漂泊無捨效
誤人青春上可惱
啊…無情的人
恨你是恨到老
永遠來甲你
田無溝水無流
</code></pre>

<p>First of all, from searching <a href="http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/" rel="nofollow">my reference</a> I have guessed <code>漂泊</code> should be in fact <code>飄撇 (飘撇)</code>, which the reference "translates" to <code>潇洒，帅气，洒脱</code>, and says is often used to describe young males; also, since the subtitles in the video have <code>BO LANG</code> and the characters suggest <code>gōo lâng</code>, I found <code>某人</code> is pronounced <code>bóo-lâng</code>. I also know, from the reference, that <code>上</code> is often used as <code>最…地</code>, and since the subtitles <a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gT6MWqmnxWM" rel="nofollow">here</a> spell it as <code>尚</code>, which I have seen for this usage of the word, I guessed it might be the right translation. Otherwise it may be translated to <code>Someone in their youth was irritating</code>. Anyway I think this refers to the <code>rén</code> with which <code>nǐ</code> (the <code>àirén</code>) has gone away. Finally, <code>甲</code> is often used to spell <code>kā</code>, a word which the reference spells <code>共</code> and says means <code>bǎ</code> (object particle) or <code>gēn</code>, <code>hé</code>, or maybe other meanings I don't remember. With these observations, I came up with the above translation. Now any advice on the other part of the translation is very welcome, as is a transliteration of this with the reference's system. The questions anyway are:</p>

<ol>
<li>Are the spelling corrections correct?</li>
<li>Is the translation of the reported part correct?</li>
<li>How does the final proverb-like phrase fit into the song, and connect to the line above which is incomplete as it lacks a verb?</li>
</ol>

<p><strong>Update:</strong>
The following points sum up what @GeorgeChen said in the comments:</p>

<ol>
<li><code>恨你是很到老</code> is «I'll hate you till I'm old» or, more literally, «My hating you is hating till I get old»;</li>
<li><code>误</code> in Mandarin is <code>waste</code>; so the phrase in Mandarin would mean <code>Wasting someone's youth is very annoying</code>; my reference, however, only lists <code>差错</code>, which is a noun use and therefore not the right one here, and <code>妨害、耽擱、拖累</code> as translations; <code>tuolei</code> is <code>dragging like ball and chain</code>, therefore decidedly not right here; <code>fanghai</code> means <code>to harm</code>, and could be right here; or <code>dange</code>, <code>to delay</code>; so we shall wait someone who knows Hokkien to tell us which is right; on my side, I'll take <code>waste</code>, though it's not listed in my reference;</li>
<li><code>永远来甲你</code> makes no sense in Mandarin, but probably does in HOkkien; indeed, <code>kah</code> or <code>ka</code> are prepositions in Hokkien meaning <code>把、跟</code> and <code>到，既然，哪会</code> in reverse order; so would <code>永远来跟你</code> make sense?</li>
<li>The proverb is translated right, but how does it fit in the song?</li>
</ol>

<p>So I'm left with the following questions:</p>

<ol>
<li>WHich translation is correct for <code>误</code>?</li>
<li>How do I fit the proverb in the song?</li>
<li>How do I translate (and possibly complete) that apparently nonsensical phrase of point 3 above?</li>
<li>Are the spelling changes I suggested "right", meaning that I correctly recognized the words used in the song?</li>
</ol>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T09:20:31.427Z
I guess we _can_ consider this song as a form of poetry, which is why I tagged this question `poetry`.
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T09:32:03.973Z
For those who are willing to finish the translation, the reference spells `乎` as `予`, `抹` as `袂`, `磅心` as `蓬心`, `跟` as `綴` (or rather, the word in the song which is distinct from `gēn` but has the same meaning), the word spelt `這` as `遮`. Also, `無彩` means `kěxì` or `徒然` or `浪費`, so that line should translate to `In vain did I, in vain did I / Have such deep feelings`.
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T14:35:52.247Z
Not  correct. 恨你是恨到老 is wrong. It means "hate you forever(untill I'm old)."  誤人青春上可惱 definitely missed the mark, it roughly means "wasting people's youth is annoying." 永遠來甲你 makes no sense. The last proverb is fine.
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T15:29:23.960Z
Uh-huh OK. So `誤` = `to waste`, and `人青春` is implying a `de` between `rén` and `qīngchūn`, right? As for the other phrase I guess there is Hokkien at work. Looking `甲` up gives meanings `jìrán`, `dào` and `zěnme huì` / `nǎhuì`. Do you speak Hokkien?
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T15:35:48.957Z
Sorry, I don't speak Hokkien. Disregard my comment.
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T16:27:19.563Z
According to the reference dict in the question, `誤` can translate to `tuolei` from Min. So maybe that phrase is "Being a burden on people's youth is very (the `shàng` character meaning `zuì`, cf question) annoying". What do you think?
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T16:41:31.837Z
Wasting is more likely. As the lyric refers to wasting her or his flowering youth on someone who ran away from commitment. If im not mistaken, the singer is listing her or his lovers crimes.
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T16:56:41.590Z
Tuolei is dragging around like ball and chain. The lover ran away, which is definitely not dragging around.
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-12T17:09:16.567Z
Yeah, I guess so. It's just that the reference doesn't give `waste` as a translation for `誤` from Min. It does give `妨害`, `damage`, though. How about that? If `waste` is still better, we'll just have to wait for a Hokkien speaker to see this and enlighten us :).
MickG
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-13T02:31:26.563Z
误：耽误。waste time, delay. http://baike.baidu.com/subview/66533/6253785.htm?fr=aladdin
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-13T02:32:27.033Z
(1) 耽误 [miss due to delay]　http://baike.baidu.com/view/324335.htm?fr=aladdin
George Chen
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-09-13T09:28:53.343Z
@GeorgeChen I've summed up the comments in the update.
MickG
<translation><topolect><poetry>
Help translating 爱人跟人走
# Help translating 爱人跟人走

(Asked by: username_0 on 2014-09-12)

I have come across the song [爱人跟人走](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9vV3u83PldY) ([lyrics here](http://mojim.com/twy100106x2x8.htm)). I'll give a complete translation attempt of this Hokkien song:

```
It's already 3 years since you left me;
Have you gone away without [ever] turning back?
[This] really is unexpected.
My heart is like a hollow turnip.

I couldn't imagine, I couldn't imagine
You would go away with someone else.
You didn't care for me, you didn't care for me,
Who had so deep feelings [for you].

Looking unrestrained was of no effect.
Someone's youth was very irritating.
Ah… cruel person,
I hate that you hate old people.
With you I will always…
If the field has no ditch, the water won't flow.

```

As you can guess, the problematic part is:

```
外表漂泊無捨效
誤人青春上可惱
啊…無情的人
恨你是恨到老
永遠來甲你
田無溝水無流

```

First of all, from searching [my reference](http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/) I have guessed `漂泊` should be in fact `飄撇 (飘撇)`, which the reference "translates" to `潇洒，帅气，洒脱`, and says is often used to describe young males; also, since the subtitles in the video have `BO LANG` and the characters suggest `gōo lâng`, I found `某人` is pronounced `bóo-lâng`. I also know, from the reference, that `上` is often used as `最…地`, and since the subtitles [here](http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gT6MWqmnxWM) spell it as `尚`, which I have seen for this usage of the word, I guessed it might be the right translation. Otherwise it may be translated to `Someone in their youth was irritating`. Anyway I think this refers to the `rén` with which `nǐ` (the `àirén`) has gone away. Finally, `甲` is often used to spell `kā`, a word which the reference spells `共` and says means `bǎ` (object particle) or `gēn`, `hé`, or maybe other meanings I don't remember. With these observations, I came up with the above translation. Now any advice on the other part of the translation is very welcome, as is a transliteration of this with the reference's system. The questions anyway are:

1. Are the spelling corrections correct?
2. Is the translation of the reported part correct?
3. How does the final proverb-like phrase fit into the song, and connect to the line above which is incomplete as it lacks a verb?

**Update:**
The following points sum up what @username_1 said in the comments:

1. `恨你是很到老` is «I'll hate you till I'm old» or, more literally, «My hating you is hating till I get old»;
2. `误` in Mandarin is `waste`; so the phrase in Mandarin would mean `Wasting someone's youth is very annoying`; my reference, however, only lists `差错`, which is a noun use and therefore not the right one here, and `妨害、耽擱、拖累` as translations; `tuolei` is `dragging like ball and chain`, therefore decidedly not right here; `fanghai` means `to harm`, and could be right here; or `dange`, `to delay`; so we shall wait someone who knows Hokkien to tell us which is right; on my side, I'll take `waste`, though it's not listed in my reference;
3. `永远来甲你` makes no sense in Mandarin, but probably does in HOkkien; indeed, `kah` or `ka` are prepositions in Hokkien meaning `把、跟` and `到，既然，哪会` in reverse order; so would `永远来跟你` make sense?
4. The proverb is translated right, but how does it fit in the song?

So I'm left with the following questions:

1. WHich translation is correct for `误`?
2. How do I fit the proverb in the song?
3. How do I translate (and possibly complete) that apparently nonsensical phrase of point 3 above?
4. Are the spelling changes I suggested "right", meaning that I correctly recognized the words used in the song?

**Tags:** translation, topolect, poetry

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: I guess we _can_ consider this song as a form of poetry, which is why I tagged this question `poetry`.  
> **username_0**: For those who are willing to finish the translation, the reference spells `乎` as `予`, `抹` as `袂`, `磅心` as `蓬心`, `跟` as `綴` (or rather, the word in the song which is distinct from `gēn` but has the same meaning), the word spelt `這` as `遮`. Also, `無彩` means `kěxì` or `徒然` or `浪費`, so that line should translate to `In vain did I, in vain did I / Have such deep feelings`.  
> **username_1**: Not  correct. 恨你是恨到老 is wrong. It means "hate you forever(untill I'm old)."  誤人青春上可惱 definitely missed the mark, it roughly means "wasting people's youth is annoying." 永遠來甲你 makes no sense. The last proverb is fine.  
> **username_0**: Uh-huh OK. So `誤` = `to waste`, and `人青春` is implying a `de` between `rén` and `qīngchūn`, right? As for the other phrase I guess there is Hokkien at work. Looking `甲` up gives meanings `jìrán`, `dào` and `zěnme huì` / `nǎhuì`. Do you speak Hokkien?  
> **username_1**: Sorry, I don't speak Hokkien. Disregard my comment.  
> **username_0**: According to the reference dict in the question, `誤` can translate to `tuolei` from Min. So maybe that phrase is "Being a burden on people's youth is very (the `shàng` character meaning `zuì`, cf question) annoying". What do you think?  
> **username_1**: Wasting is more likely. As the lyric refers to wasting her or his flowering youth on someone who ran away from commitment. If im not mistaken, the singer is listing her or his lovers crimes.  
> **username_1**: Tuolei is dragging around like ball and chain. The lover ran away, which is definitely not dragging around.  
> **username_0**: Yeah, I guess so. It's just that the reference doesn't give `waste` as a translation for `誤` from Min. It does give `妨害`, `damage`, though. How about that? If `waste` is still better, we'll just have to wait for a Hokkien speaker to see this and enlighten us :).  
> **username_1**: 误：耽误。waste time, delay. http://baike.baidu.com/subview/66533/6253785.htm?fr=aladdin  
> **username_1**: (1) 耽误 [miss due to delay]　http://baike.baidu.com/view/324335.htm?fr=aladdin  
> **username_0**: @username_1 I've summed up the comments in the update.  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_2 on 2014-09-14. Score: 6 | Accepted answer

愛人跟人走  
my love has gone with someone else

```
離開已經三年後  
It's already 3 years since you left me;
你煞有去無回頭
you gone away without turning back
真是乎人想抹到
[This] really is unexpected.
心肝親像磅心的菜頭
My heart is like a broken radish

想抹到想抹到
I couldn't imagine, I couldn't imagine
你會去跟人走
You would go away with someone else.
無彩我無彩我
You didn't care for me, you didn't care for me,
感情用這厚
Who had so deep feelings [for you].
外表漂泊無捨效
Looking handsome, natural and unrestrained was of no effect.
誤人青春上可惱
wasting people's youth is the most annoying.

啊無情的人
Ah… cruel person,
恨你是恨到老
hate you forever(until I'm old, or until death).
永遠來甲你
With you I will never…
田無溝水無流
across the line to each other (have a relationship)

```

word meanings and notes:

無彩:

```
無彩: means "in vain", "uselessly",  
the translation above is **meaning translation**,  
because he don't care about me, so whatever I do, is useless
the **direct translation** is:
無彩我無彩我
waste my, waste my
感情用這厚
so deep feelings [for you].

```

煞:

```
煞 also means "surprisingly"
你煞有去無回頭
you gone away surprisingly without turning back

```

> 田無溝水無流：
>
> > direct translation ( or literal translation )is:
> >
> > > If the field has no ditch, the water won't flow.
> >
> > metaphor explaining:
> >
> > > "the field" is like " I ", "the water" is like " you (or he, the one who left her)".  
> > > ditch, in OALD8, the english meaning is:  
> > > a long channel dug at the side of a field or road, to hold or take away water  
> > > so, "the ditch" is like "the way to contact me"  
> > > "flow" is like "talk to me or touch me"  
> > > so, the whole sentence is:  
> > > if I don't allow you to contact me, you won't have any chance to talk to me or touch me.

useful online dictionary:

<http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/index.html>

<http://twblg.dict.edu.tw/holodict_new/result_detail.jsp?n_no=9721&curpage=1&sample=%E7%85%9E&radiobutton=1&querytarget=1&limit=20&pagenum=1&rowcount=13>

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: OK. But doesn't `bô-tshái` mean `kěxì` or `in vain`? And isn't `suah-ū` the same as `哪有`, which means `how did you…?`? Also, `until` has one l. `till` has two.  
> **username_2**: I have edited the anwser again.  And thank you for correcting my english.  
> **username_0**: You are welcome. I'd suggest block quotes rather than preformatted text for the notes on the words. What does `田無溝水無流` mean exactly? I mean, it's used in some metaphorical way, since the literal meaning is (isn't it?) the one I stated in the question. So what does it mean in this "metaphorical" sense?  
> **username_2**: I have edited the anwser again.  your literal meaning is right. and I've added metaphor explaining. and I've learned something new about "stackexchange" from you.  

---

