<p>Why say &quot;to be&quot; instead of &quot;it is&quot; or &quot;exists&quot;?</p>
<p>In english there are many alternative ways to say something, differing only in formality, nuance, or emphasis. The same is true of Chinese.</p>
<p>是 is neutral, 為 is more formal/literary, 乃 is an even more formal and literary alternative.</p>
<p>I recommend seeing example uses of vocab to get an idea of what formality or ways it is used. For example the 乃 I just listed can be a formal and literary &quot;is&quot; but you are much more likely to see it used as &quot;therefore&quot; in regular speech.</p>
<p>Compare 為 you will encounter it as &quot;is&quot; in formal speech but usually its &quot;act&quot; definition is more common. It could also be a rhetorical question marker in classical chinese, but that knowledge won't help much with modern mandarin.</p>
<p>I think word use is mainly contextual, and looking at the vocab as its used in a sentence or piece is key. Looking at them as individual terms, especially when they are single character terms, to me at least is not so useful.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-11-19T19:19:11.867Z
2022-11-19T19:19:11.867Z
zagrycha
<p>為 can be used as &quot;to be&quot;, as well as &quot;take...to be&quot;. Both are correct depending on the full context.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-11-19T18:02:39.760Z
2022-11-19T18:02:39.760Z
r13
<p>These two, in this situation, mean the same, but 為 is almost never used in spoken language to mean the same as 是.
Actually even in dictionary, 是 and 為 are redundant for definition. If you have to use it, i would say 為 is like something where traditional chinese characters are still used would use in written language to mean the same as 是.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-11-21T05:13:04.643Z
2022-11-21T05:26:01.897Z
2022-11-21T05:26:01.897Z
hx3ds
<p>In the definition for the term &quot;琥珀&quot; at <a href="https://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/dictView.jsp?ID=83080&amp;q=1&amp;word=%E7%90%A5%E7%8F%80" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/dictView.jsp?ID=83080&amp;q=1&amp;word=%E7%90%A5%E7%8F%80</a>, there's the text &quot;為淡黃色、褐色或赤褐色的半透明固體&quot;. &quot;為&quot; is used instead of &quot;是&quot; for the verb &quot;to be&quot; in what seems to be a common grammatical phenomenon.</p>
<p>Can someone explain why and how I choose the proper verb?</p>

<grammar><vocabulary>
Why use "為" instead of the verb "是" for the meaning "to be"?
# Why use "為" instead of the verb "是" for the meaning "to be"?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2022-11-19)

In the definition for the term "琥珀" at <https://dict.revised.moe.edu.tw/dictView.jsp?ID=83080&q=1&word=%E7%90%A5%E7%8F%80>, there's the text "為淡黃色、褐色或赤褐色的半透明固體". "為" is used instead of "是" for the verb "to be" in what seems to be a common grammatical phenomenon.

Can someone explain why and how I choose the proper verb?

**Tags:** grammar, vocabulary


---

## 3 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2022-11-19. Score: 3

Why say "to be" instead of "it is" or "exists"?

In english there are many alternative ways to say something, differing only in formality, nuance, or emphasis. The same is true of Chinese.

是 is neutral, 為 is more formal/literary, 乃 is an even more formal and literary alternative.

I recommend seeing example uses of vocab to get an idea of what formality or ways it is used. For example the 乃 I just listed can be a formal and literary "is" but you are much more likely to see it used as "therefore" in regular speech.

Compare 為 you will encounter it as "is" in formal speech but usually its "act" definition is more common. It could also be a rhetorical question marker in classical chinese, but that knowledge won't help much with modern mandarin.

I think word use is mainly contextual, and looking at the vocab as its used in a sentence or piece is key. Looking at them as individual terms, especially when they are single character terms, to me at least is not so useful.


---

### Answer by username_2 on 2022-11-19. Score: 0

為 can be used as "to be", as well as "take...to be". Both are correct depending on the full context.


---

### Answer by username_3 on 2022-11-21. Score: 0

These two, in this situation, mean the same, but 為 is almost never used in spoken language to mean the same as 是.
Actually even in dictionary, 是 and 為 are redundant for definition. If you have to use it, i would say 為 is like something where traditional chinese characters are still used would use in written language to mean the same as 是.


---

