<p>It sounds as though you have ideas on the tools you'd like to use, but not on an actual question that you want to use them to answer.</p>

<p>You probably need to either come up with such a question, or focus instead on methodology - in studying the tools and the effectiveness of using them in a given scenario.</p>

<p>For nearly any modelling project, its viability will be affected by whether data are available to validate the model. If no appropriate data are available for the area you're looking at, you probably don't have a project (because what use is a model if you have no idea whether it's right?).</p>

<p>Bear in mind that these comments are all generalisations based on very limited information. The best advice is still "talk to your advisor".</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-12-29T07:48:49.967Z
2019-12-29T07:48:49.967Z
Semidiurnal Simon
<p>I would like to write my thesis on modelling extreme rainfall events in urban areas coupling a 2D surface model with an 1D sewer channel model. I have access to a good software which models hydrodynamically and offers me 3 different modelling approaches. My basic idea was to apply all three approaches and compare them and see what happens but my prof. is not convinced yet. He is happy with the model but he wants me to formulate a clear research question and ideally a hypothesis. Further, I can apply the model but I have no data to verify the results. </p>

<p>I'm stuck here, I don't know how to come up with a good research question and hypothesis. Maybe you can give me some ideas of what I could do?</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-12-26T14:11:30.210Z
Welcome to Earth Science SE. Your question may be better suited for the Academia SE (https://academia.stackexchange.com/)? As it is not on the science itself, but rather on how to come up with a good research question.
Jean-Marie Prival
CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-12-28T12:44:43.503Z
The canonical answer given on Academia SE is "talk to your adviser".
Wolfgang Bangerth
CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-12-29T07:45:27.200Z
I would consider this off-topic on academia.se, because it is enough about the science that it requires field-specific knowledge.
Semidiurnal Simon
CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-12-29T21:36:17.917Z
ask what are you trying to predict and why? Do you want to know when the sewer system will be overwhelmed so water flows down the streets? Do you want to know when the sewage treatment plant will be threatened? If this is a PhD, I'd expect you to come up with a better model or at least a detailed analysis of where and why the models fall over. Good luck!
haresfur
<hydrology><models>
research question for modelling extreme rainfall event with coupled 2D surface and 1D sewersystem model
bluesky
# research question for modelling extreme rainfall event with coupled 2D surface and 1D sewersystem model

(Asked by: username_0 on 2019-12-26)

I would like to write my thesis on modelling extreme rainfall events in urban areas coupling a 2D surface model with an 1D sewer channel model. I have access to a good software which models hydrodynamically and offers me 3 different modelling approaches. My basic idea was to apply all three approaches and compare them and see what happens but my prof. is not convinced yet. He is happy with the model but he wants me to formulate a clear research question and ideally a hypothesis. Further, I can apply the model but I have no data to verify the results.

I'm stuck here, I don't know how to come up with a good research question and hypothesis. Maybe you can give me some ideas of what I could do?

**Tags:** hydrology, models

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Welcome to Earth Science SE. Your question may be better suited for the Academia SE (https://academia.stackexchange.com/)? As it is not on the science itself, but rather on how to come up with a good research question.  
> **username_2**: The canonical answer given on Academia SE is "talk to your adviser".  
> **username_3**: I would consider this off-topic on academia.se, because it is enough about the science that it requires field-specific knowledge.  
> **username_4**: ask what are you trying to predict and why? Do you want to know when the sewer system will be overwhelmed so water flows down the streets? Do you want to know when the sewage treatment plant will be threatened? If this is a PhD, I'd expect you to come up with a better model or at least a detailed analysis of where and why the models fall over. Good luck!  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_3 on 2019-12-29. Score: 1 | Accepted answer

It sounds as though you have ideas on the tools you'd like to use, but not on an actual question that you want to use them to answer.

You probably need to either come up with such a question, or focus instead on methodology - in studying the tools and the effectiveness of using them in a given scenario.

For nearly any modelling project, its viability will be affected by whether data are available to validate the model. If no appropriate data are available for the area you're looking at, you probably don't have a project (because what use is a model if you have no idea whether it's right?).

Bear in mind that these comments are all generalisations based on very limited information. The best advice is still "talk to your advisor".


---

