The controversial spiral staircase (“subidorium”) from Monforte Castle in Rio Livre
The recent installation of an iron spiral staircase at Castelo de Monforte de Rio Livre, in Águas Frias (Chaves), Portugal, has generated a heated debate between advocates of modernization and advocates of historic preservation.
Purpose of the ladder:
The staircase, nicknamed &quot;subidorium&quot; by the author of the image, has the sole purpose of facilitating access to the entrance door of the keep, located at the top of the wall.
Impact on visitor experience:
However, its construction raised significant concerns. The staircase and the railing that accompanies it prevent visitors from circulating freely around the walls, depriving them of the stunning view of the Tâmega river valley, the Brunheiro mountain plateau, the neighboring villages and the surrounding Portuguese and Spanish mountains, including the castle. from Monterrey to Verin.
Conflicting perspectives:
Proponents of the intervention argue that the staircase was necessary for safety reasons and to facilitate access to the keep for people with reduced mobility. Furthermore, they maintain that their presence does not significantly compromise the aesthetics of the castle.
On the other hand, detractors of the staircase criticize its intrusion into a historic structure such as the castle, arguing that its construction distorts the authenticity of the monument and limits visitors' experience in appreciating the region's natural beauty.
Points for reflection:
The controversy surrounding the Monforte de Rio Livre staircase raises important questions about the balance between modernization and preservation of historical heritage. It is crucial to carefully consider the advantages and disadvantages of such interventions, seeking solutions that reconcile accessibility and security with preserving authenticity and the visitor's experience.
It is up to each person to consider:
Does the spiral staircase significantly compromise the aesthetics of the castle?
Does its presence crucially impede the enjoyment of the panoramic view?
Was its construction really necessary for safety and accessibility reasons?
Are there less invasive alternatives to achieve the same goals?
.
The resolution of the debate lies in open dialogue and the search for creative solutions that consider different perspectives and guarantee the preservation of the rich historical and cultural heritage of Castelo de Monforte de Rio Livre.
.
Text &amp; Photography: ©MárioSilva
.
.