Documentary about the battle of the somme in july 1916 a number of excellent interviews from old soldiers good material on the great war. Lions led by donkeys v q3 what can we learn from these sources about how accurate lieutenant george’s view was of how soldiers viewed haig’s before the . The phrase lions led by donkeys is based on the leadership of the government and the on-scene leaders this section gives information regarding the leaders from the sources perhaps the man with the most influence on the at-the-scene battle was sir douglas haig (1861-1928). ‘lions led by donkeys’ based on the critical study of the historical sources, is it accurate to call douglas haig, the “butcher of the somme” haig title. To conclude, the statement ‘lions led by donkeys’ is an inaccurate assessment of the british army on the front line in ww1, as england did eventually win and, the generals cannot be blamed for the stalemate.
How accurate is the statement ‘lions led by donkeys’ in relation to british soldiers and generals of the first world war in the first world war, more men died than in any other war before. “lions led by donkeys” how accurate an assessment is this of the british army on the western front in the first world war written by alan clark a politician in the 1960s this quotation describes the leadership of the british military and their strategies used in the great war. How accurate is this assessment of the british army on the western front in the first world war the statement ‘lions led by donkeys’ means that there were brave soldiers led by incompetent generals. “lions led by donkeys”- a lesson plan for high school or secondary students on british tactics on the western front the following is a lesson plan i wrote up for several museums and educational sites in scotland during my time there.
In this essay i will look at the level of truth that can be found in the phrase “lions led by donkeys” and look specifically at the role haig had i will look at different sources and interpretations written by historians in reference to haig and allied generals and soldiers and politicians, to gauge how accurate the statement is. As expected, anyone who attempts to write about the british army of the great war must grapple with the lions led by donkeys enigma that has surrounded them ever since whilst the fact that the generals made mistakes is beyond doubt, what is also clear is that they did learn from their previous errors. Introduction is the statement lions led by donkeys accurate to answer this question, i will have to assess the attitude of the generals during the first world war were the generals donkeys and the soldiers lions. This sentiment was encapsulated in the phrase “lions led by donkeys”, a phrase that caught on following the publication of alan clark’s 1961 book the donkeys.
Axis history forum and this has led to the view that the british army was one of “lions led by donkeys” there is much evidence to suggest that this was the . Dr gary sheffield investigates whether the scale of human devastation in world war one can be blamed on incompetent leadership lions led by donkeys by dr gary sheffield the accuracy of . What's the meaning of the phrase 'lions led by donkeys' a description of the british soldiers of wwi what's the origin of the phrase 'lions led by donkeys'. The question “were the british soldiers ‘lions led by donkeys'” has been an ongoing debate since the end of the war a war which is dominated by images of bloody battles such as the somme and passchendaele – futile frontal attacks against the machine guns. Leadership and culture: lions led by donkeys – when managerial under-capacity is a choice take away line leaders of organisations can live in a work culture that oppresses them and builds in failure.