This lighthouse was built by former Wisconsin State Senator, William Bray, in 1909. After failing to convince the government of the need for a lighthouse at the point to mark the shallow dangerous reefs just off-shore, Mr. Bray used his own money to buy the land, construct the tower and pay for ongoing maintenance. He then assumed the role of keeper lighting the lamp each night. The plans came from Mr. Bray’s friend, a noted architect named George Andrews Rockwell.
Once shipping traffic had increased on Lake Winnebago, the Federal Government finally realized the importance of the lighthouse. At this point, the government did assume the operating costs of the light. The lighthouse has been known by many different names over the years, which corresponds with the owners of the property at that time. Some of the past names include Bray (1909), Thompson (1918), and Buckstaff (1940s). It was also known as the Rockwell Lighthouse after the original architect.
The lighthouse was decommissioned in the 1950s, and fell into neglect. The neighborhood was renovated in the 1980s which allowed the tower to be better secured. The owners of the property then restored and re-lit the tower in 1986.