Simon and Kirby
Joe Simon and Jack Kirby, their studio, and the artists who worked for them
email: hmendryk at yahoo dot com
Images, Alphabetical
Images, Chronological
Inking Glossary
A Story too Incredible to be Real
by Harry Mendryk
Posted February 5, 2011 in 2011/02, 5 Studio, Artists, Featured Work, Kirby, Jack, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive and tagged Jack Kirby
Headline #24 (May 1947) "A Phantom Pulls The Trigger" page 6, pencils and inks by Jack Kirby
They said it on the cover, "All True Famous Detective Cases". Would Joe Simon and Jack Kirby say that if it was not true? But surely not all the stories in Headline Comics #24 could be true? Who would be credulous enough to believe the tale told in "A Phantom Pulls The Trigger"? A man going about the French countryside killing individuals for the sole reason of keeping the size of the population down? Whose philosophy comes from reading Thomas Malthus' "Over-Population"? A man who avoids detection by using a gun installed inside his wooden leg? Who after being uncovered and arrested is allowed to keep his now disarmed wooden leg and has friends smuggle in a new gun and bullets? Who uses his re-armed wooden leg right before his execution with unintended results? Who could possibly believe such an incredible story to be true?
Except it was.
Well as true as any story told by Simon and Kirby who seemed to adhere to the philosophy of never letting the facts get in the way of a good story. But the basic facts portrayed in "A Phantom Pulls The Trigger" all appear to be true. There really was a man who went by the names of Herman Gottler and Raoul Croc as presented in the story but not included in the story were his other names Gottlieb Einhalter and Armande Giraud. His armed and deadly wooden leg was so devious that after he had been found in the vicinity of several murders it remained undetected even though he was carefully searched. He undoubtedly would have continued to evade the law for some time had not one of his victims lived long enough to report seeing smoke coming from the end of the wooden leg. After capture, Raoul was quite open about what he had done and why he did it. In fact he attracted a number of admirers. And yes the authorities really did allow him to keep his unarmed wooden leg which Raoul re-armed with the help of his friends. While seated waiting for the executioner's sword, Raoul aimed his leg at one of his followers and set his pistol off. Only it seems the pistol's muzzle had become blocked with mud and stone and therefore exploded instantly killing Raoul.
But how had Simon and Kirby come across this story? The events occurred in France during the early part of the 19th century so it was unlikely to have been a object of discussion in New York City during the mid 20th century. A Google search revealed a few possible French links (I cannot read French) but only a single English source. That source was "Howitt's Journal of Literature and Popular Progress, Volume 1" by William Howitt and Mary Botham Howitt published in 1847 (the story told on pages 103 to 105 and 122 to 125). This does not seem to be likely reading material for either Joe or Jack. Perhaps Jack heard the story told in France while he was there as a soldier during World War II.
"A Phantom Pulls The Trigger" is special not only for its amazing story but also because it had one of the only two double page splashes for a crime comic (The Wide Angle Scream, It's a Crime);
← The Corrosive Influence of Pinball What? Who? →
Become a Member of the Kirby Museum!
Visit our Membership page Or simply...
© 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, & 2012 Harry Mendryk. All rights reserved. Unless otherwise marked, all images are my own restorations. Further some of the images have copyrights by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby or Joe Simon alone. I am fortunate that Joe Simon has allowed me to also include some previously unpublished material. Please do not copy from this blog without permission.
Comments © 2006-2012 their respective authors. All rights reserved.
Albistur, Jo (8)
Avison, Al (10)
Belfi, John (4)
Breifer, Dick (9)
Brewster, Ann (7)
Burgos, Carl (1)
Ditko, Steve (2)
Donahue, Vic (12)
Draut, Bill (52)
Gregg, George (5)
Infantino, Carmine (6)
Kirby, Jack (172)
McCarty, Bob (10)
Meskin, Mort (70)
Morrow, Gray (1)
Oda, Ben (1)
Oleck, Jack (2)
Powell, Bob (1)
Premiani, Bruno (9)
Prentice, John (29)
Riley, Ken (2)
Robinson, Jerry (10)
Severin, John (7)
Simon, Joe (61)
Stallman, Manny (8)
Starr, Leonard (14)
Stein, Marvin (22)
Walton, Bill (5)
Checklist (34)
Albistur, Joe (1)
Briefer, Dick (1)
Donahue, Vic (1)
Draut, Bill (1)
Eadeh (16)
Kirby, Jack (1)
McCarty, Bob (1)
Premiani?, Bruno (1)
Prentice, John (1)
Robinson & Meskin (1)
Simon, Joe (1)
Starr, Leonard (1)
Stein, Marvin (1)
Comic Checklists (33)
All For Love (1)
Black Magic, DC (1)
Black Magic, Prize (1)
Boys' Ranch (1)
Fighting American (1)
Foxhole (14)
In Love (1)
Justice Traps the Guilty (1)
My Date (1)
Personal Love (1)
Prize Comics Western (1)
Real West Romance (1)
Western Love (1)
Young Brides (1)
Young Love (1)
Young Romance (1)
Your Dreams (1)
Ink Checklist (1)
Periods (403)
1 Early (22)
2 Fox (14)
3 Timely (47)
4 DC (early) (46)
5 Studio (133)
6 Mainline (68)
In Love (16)
Police Trap (7)
7 Freelance (106)
Archie (13)
Atlas Kirby (14)
DC Kirby (4)
8 Marvel (12)
Marvel Kirby (6)
9 DC (late) (6)
Serial Posts (145)
Art of J. Simon (1)
Art of Romance (41)
Criminal Artists (4)
Early Jack Kirby (9)
End of S & K (1)
Harvey Horror (7)
It's a Crime (1)
Kirby Austere Inking (1)
Kirby Inkers (5)
Little Shop of Horrors (1)
Margin Notes (5)
Replacing S&K (4)
S&K Colorists (3)
Start of S&K (12)
Wide Angle Scream (16)
Topic (362)
Alternate Takes (16)
Art Editing (4)
Best of Simon & Kirby (2)
Comicscope (3)
Featured Work (64)
First Romance (1)
Harvey Covers (26)
Kirby Inking Kirby (4)
Kirby Krackle (3)
Kirby Or Not (30)
Odds & Ends (130)
S&K Superheroes (2)
Speaking Of Art (11)
Swiping (9)
Wertham & Censoring (5)
Why Comics Declined (1)
z Archive (625)
The postings on this blog are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent The Jack Kirby Museum & Research Center's positions, strategies or opinions.
Website © 2005-2017 Jack Kirby Museum & Research Center, Inc. All rights reserved. All characters and art presented on these pages are ©, ™ or ® their respective owners. No challenge to any owner's rights is intended or should be inferred.
The Jack Kirby Museum & Research Center is a tax-exempt non-profit educational corporation. Donations may be tax-deductible - please consult your tax advisor.