Peggy Noonan, bad #history, and the #metoo movement
Posted on December 4, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
via Slate and Nursing Clio
Both blogs discuss Peggy Noonan's November 23 Wall Street Journal column, in which Noonan claims the "sexual harassment racket" is a product of the sexual revolution and the growing availability of contraception and abortion:
"Once you separate sex from its seriousness, once you separate it from its life-changing, life-giving potential, men will come to see it as just another want, a desire like any other," Noonan wrote . "Once they think that, then they'll see sexual violations as less serious, less charged, less full of weight. They'll be more able to rationalize. It's only petty theft, a pack of chewing gum on the counter, and I took it."
Numerous women's historians, including Kathy Peiss, Ann Taves, Estelle Friedman, Danielle McGuire, Kathleen Brown, and Christine Stansell have disproven this claim, demonstrating the working women, especially slaves and free women of color, have faced sexual harassment and assault for centuries. What's new is that women's stories are finally being taken seriously and male predators are being punished for their actions.
Noonan's ideas can be traced back to the 19th century social purity movement, led by women who wanted to end prostitution and the sexual exploitation of women. According to historian Linda Gordon, social purity advocates "were unequivocally opposed to contraception" because it removed the fears of unwanted pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases that kept predatory men in line. However, Gordon also shows that social purity advocates were also photo feminist in the sense that they wanted to eliminate the sexual double standard, punish the customers of prostitution as well as prostitutes themselves, and raise the age of consent from age 10 to 18.
In other words, these reformers were combatting the sexual exploitation of women, which they saw as an offshoot of women's economic and legal dependence on men. In an article entitled "Social Purity," Susan B. Anthony wrote:
"Though women, as a class, are much less addicted to drunkenness and licentiousness than men, it is universally conceded that they are by far the greater sufferers from these evils. Compelled by their position in society to depend on men for subsistence, for food, clothes, shelter, for every chance even to earn a dollar, they have no way of escape from the besotted victims of appetite and passion with whom their lot is cast. . . The prosecutions on our courts for breach of promise, divorce, adultery, bigamy, seduction, rape; the newspaper reports every day of every year of scandals and outrages, of wife murders and paramour shooting, of abortions and infanticides, are perpetual reminders of men's incapacity to cope successfully with this monster evil of society."
Noonan and other foes of abortion have seized on these words and made Anthony into an anti-abortion heroine by taking Anthony's words out of context. To quote Anthony, by condemning abortion, and poo-pooing sexual harassment and other social injustices against women, today's pro-life activists are "only mowing off the top of the noxious weed, while the root remains."
Social Media is Scholarship
Posted on October 23, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
Via Chronicle Vitae where Mark Carrigan makes a strong case that social media can be intrinsic to scholarship. I agree! Knitting Clio started off as a scholarly blog. I still see it that way, even though much of my thinking lately has been off line or on other platforms (see my Twitter stream).
Crosspost from Nursing Clio: The Pill Kills: Women's Health and Feminist Activism
Posted on May 3, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
On December 16, 1975, a group of Washington, D.C. area women's health activists held the first-ever protest at the headquarters of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The demonstration took the form of a "memorial service" to commemorate the thousands of women who had died from using the contraceptive pill and other estrogen-containing drugs, and…
via Women's Health, Feminist Activism, and the Pill — Nursing Clio
The Reusable Condom – Episode 13 – Under The Knife
Posted on April 20, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
I'm teaching a course on material culture next semester — this gives me some good ideas!
The Chirurgeon's Apprentice
In Episode 13 of Under The Knife, I discuss the history behind reusable condoms, and the terrible diseases that made them necessary in earlier centuries. The video may or may not also involve me wearing an inflatable condom costume…
Don't forget you can now pre-order my book THE BUTCHERING ART by clicking here! And please subscribe to my YouTube Channel, and like/comment on the video!
Menstruation on Mercy Street
Posted on March 7, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
Now that season 2 of the PBS drama Mercy Street has wrapped up, I'm going to comment on an incident that has been bugging me for several weeks. In this season, young Alice Green turns into a "She Rebel" by spying for the Confederates. In one scene, she fends off a Union soldier who wants to inspect her handbag by saying she is carrying supplies for her "monthlies" and doesn't want to be embarrassed by having a man see them.
After this episode aired, my friend Lara Friedenfelds wrote a great piece on menstruation in the Victorian era for the National Museum of Civil War medicine blog. She observes that most women carried on with their lives during their periods rather than swooning on chaise lounges. So, it's not hard to imagine that Alice was in fact menstruating while she was galloping around the countryside for the Rebs.
What I have trouble believing is that Alice would discuss her period in front of men (including her own father). Historian Joan Jacobs Brumberg has shown that during the nineteenth century, doctors complained about mothers did not prepare their daughters for menstruation. In other words, young girls couldn't talk with their mothers about this delicate topic, much less their fathers, and certainly not men outside their families.
Otherwise, this season's treatment of medical history has once again been top notch. Can't wait for season 3.
[added later — my friend Penny Richards observes below that this was the era before sanitary napkins and tampons. So, Miss Alice would be using a piece of cloth, which her slave would be in charge of carrying and laundering for her].
Sorry, Generation X was not a bunch of lazy Slackers
Posted on February 14, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
via Timeline, where Stephanie Buck trots out the tired stereotype of Generation X as a bunch of lazy slackers "who who skateboarded through high school with flannel shirts and angry music during a period of economic stability."
I could just say "whatever," but since I'm a historian, and by some measures, belong to Generation X (I'm younger than Douglas Coupland, author of Generation X). I can assure you that the late 1980s and early 1990s were not times of economic stability. This was the Bush 41 recession that helped pave the way for the election of President Bill "the economy stupid" Clinton. The title of chapter 2 of Generation X, "Our Parents Had More," sums up the climate of diminished opportunities for those of us graduating from college and graduate school. Richard Linklater's film "Slacker" also depicts the lives of overeducated/underemployed "misfits" in a college town (Ithaca, NY had many real-life counterparts).
I was one of the few people in my graduate school cohort to get a tenure-track job (or a job at all).
So, let's dispense with these generational stereotypes, m'okay?
This is what a New Wave feminist looks like
Posted on January 23, 2017 by Heather Munro Prescott
Over the weekend, I saw a discussion of "new wave feminists" on Twitter.
I immediately thought of these awesome group of women New Wave musicians:
[Image courtesy of BBC. Can you name them all?}
Turns out I was mistaken: the reference was to a group of pro-life feminists who had originally been included as partners for the Women's March on Washington. After complaints from pro-choice groups, the march organizers cancelled the partnership with New Wave Feminists.
The concept of pro-life feminism is not new: Feminists for Life has been around for decades. Even Margaret Sanger was opposed to abortion.
I believe that the tent of feminism should include pro-life feminists. However, New Wave Feminists are hardly inclusive. Here's a quote from their website:
"New Wave Feminists are here to take feminism back from those who have corrupted it.
Sometime before we were born
our womanhood was traded for a handful
of birth control pills,
the "privilege" to degrade ourselves in playboy,
and the "right" to abort our children.
It's time for the return of common sense feminism which refuses to exploit women in the name of liberation and create victims while settling for equality. Instead, we will live up to our full potential and demand others rise up to that level as we embrace how strong and bad ass women truly are."
Sorry, so-called New Wave Feminists. If you want respect from other feminists, you need to take the beam out of your own eye. Supporting reproductive rights does not "corrupt" feminism. I'm pretty badass myself. Here's what an old-school, New Wave feminist looks like (Knitting Clio in 1986)
Protest Day Playlist
I've heard that the 1980s are back (including bad fashion choices), so I've decided to put together a playlist of protest songs that got us through the Reagan/Bush 41 era:
REM, "Exhuming McCarthy" — because of POTUS attacks on free press
Dead Kennedys, "Jock-o-rama" — because the "beef patrol" is in charge (for now)
The Replacements, "Bastards of Young" — because of everyone's favorite soccer dad, Senator Tim Kaine
Fishbone, "Party at Ground Zero" — because the Donald now has the nuclear codes
Public Image Ltd/Africa Bambaata — "World Destruction" – see above
Men at Work, "It's a Mistake" — because we're headed for a new Cold War
Billy Bragg, "Help Save the Youth of America" — because they need it
X — "Johnny Hit and Run Pauline" — because we need support for Violence Against Women Act
The Police, "Invisible Sun" — because we need to keep hoping things will get better
Neil Young, "Rockin' in the Free World" — because it's a free country (for now)
Public Enemy, "Fight the Power" — let's do it!
Readers feel free to add to the list (blog is moderated so comments won't appear right away)
Knitting Clio is knitting pussy hats
As you all know, I actually do knit. Like other crafty women, my election anxiety by knitting pussy hats for the Women's March on Washington on January 21. I can't attend the main event but will be going to the Sister March in Hartford and sending my friends to Washington with my handiwork.
Back to knitting . . .
Signal Boost: My article on the IUD for Technology's Stories
[image courtesy of Virginia Smith, Sharlen Creations]
Here's a signal boost for my latest article, "This is Not a Dalkon Shield" for the Society for the History of Technology publication Technology's Stories. Make sure to check out the other stories while you're there!
If you want your very own pair of IUD earrings, you can order them here.
Archives Select Month June 2019 April 2019 November 2018 September 2018 August 2018 April 2018 March 2018 February 2018 January 2018 December 2017 October 2017 May 2017 April 2017 March 2017 February 2017 January 2017 December 2016 November 2016 September 2016 August 2016 July 2016 June 2016 May 2016 April 2016 March 2016 February 2016 January 2016 December 2015 November 2015 September 2015 July 2015 June 2015 May 2015 April 2015 March 2015 February 2015 January 2015 December 2014 November 2014 October 2014 September 2014 August 2014 July 2014 June 2014 May 2014 April 2014 March 2014 February 2014 January 2014 December 2013 November 2013 October 2013 September 2013 August 2013 June 2013 May 2013 March 2013 January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007
The latest The Knitting Clio Daily! paper.li/hmprescott?edi… Thanks to @jackiantonovich @historianess @ianmilligan1 1 month ago
The latest The Knitting Clio Daily! paper.li/hmprescott?edi… Thanks to @SisterSong_WOC @ProfMSinha 1 month ago
The latest The Knitting Clio Daily! paper.li/hmprescott?edi… Thanks to @JonathanSadowsk @CT_History @BitchMedia… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 1 month ago
RT @ProfGidlow: New hashtag: #damnrightimadoctor. Then change your profile name and add "Dr." Who's in? tps://www.wsj.com/articles/is-th… 1 month ago
The latest The Knitting Clio Daily! paper.li/hmprescott?edi… Thanks to @gamingthepast @docfreeride @saramunrovt 1 month ago
Drunk Austen
chefsimone.wordpress.com/
Namaste Nation
Dan Cohen
Historical Me
Nick Streifel's History Blog
How did Vikings communicate at sea?
Justin Edwards
Danczuk Digital History
History Has Its Eyes On Me
Overthinking It
The Crocheting Historian
Exploring New Worlds
Gabe Benjamin's History Homepage
I WILL NOT SOON FORGET YOUR KINDNESS OR YOUR DECENCY
recklessknitting.wordpress.com/
The New England Quarterly
History Rules
It is a truth universally acknowledged that a single woman must be in want of a drink
Orientalism and Yoga in the 21st Century
is a Vice Provost, Dean, and Professor at Northeastern University
History for the Future
By Norse code
Follow me on twitter: @jmedwards29
Why Do You Write Like You're Running Out Of Time?
A site to think about my academic work the same way I do everything: by overthinking it.
Blog for History 511: Digital History
History Happens
A journal of New England cultural, literary, political, and social history