What's your favorite album by GN'R?
APPETITE FOR DISCUSSION :: GN'R - NEWS, RUMOURS AND DISCUSSIONS
What's your favorite GN'R album?
Appetite for Destruction
Use Your Illusion I
Use Your Illusion II
The Spaghetti Incident!?
Chinese Democracy
Can't choose, love'em all!!
by Soulmonster on Fri Jul 09, 2010 7:17 pm
Every forum needs this survey
Last edited by Soulmonster on Fri Apr 15, 2016 9:09 pm; edited 3 times in total
Re: What's your favorite album by GN'R?
by Soulmonster on Tue Aug 23, 2011 9:04 am
I voted for AFD. I think its hype is a bit exaggerated in general, but it will always be very special to me.
by 666 on Tue May 15, 2012 5:27 pm
gotta go with CD.
by Damn_Smooth on Tue May 15, 2012 11:50 pm
I can't vote because it changes almost weekly. I love them all.
Damn_Smooth
by Soulmonster on Wed May 16, 2012 7:07 am
Then hopefully the next album will be a step above the others
by Johan on Wed May 16, 2012 5:51 pm
I opted for UYI I, the combination of the more sophisticated, epic songwriting of UYI II and still raw agression from AFD.
by Soulmonster on Wed May 16, 2012 6:04 pm
I actually prefer UYI II to I. If I were to rank the albums I think it would go like this:
1. Appetite for Destruction
2. UYI II
3. Chinese Democracy
4. UYI I
5. Lies
6. The Spaghetti Incident!?
It's cool that CD is in the lead, though. I like the fact that GN'R still create new fans and isn't just a nostalgia band for old people.
by 666 on Thu May 17, 2012 4:23 am
I don't mean to be a sourpuss but I think UYI 1 is all filler with the exception of November Rain and Don't Damn Me.
by puddledumpling on Fri May 18, 2012 5:47 am
@Damn_Smooth wrote: I can't vote because it changes almost weekly. I love them all.
by Soulmonster on Fri May 18, 2012 9:43 am
Okay, I've added a "love'em all!!" option.
by Damn_Smooth on Sat May 19, 2012 12:06 am
Thank you. Voted.
by Johan on Thu May 24, 2012 2:09 pm
@666 wrote: I don't mean to be a sourpuss but I think UYI 1 is all filler with the exception of November Rain and Don't Damn Me.
So you think Coma is filler? Don't Cry? Double Talkin' Jive? Dust N' Bones? Maybe most of them are less grand than on UYI I, but I love those songs..
by Soulmonster on Thu May 24, 2012 2:26 pm
...and Right Next Door to Hell, Garden of Eden, Perfect Crime...
Just the video from Garden of Eden is reason enough to like UYI 1
by 666 on Thu May 24, 2012 4:11 pm
@Johan wrote:
Indeed I do.
Double Talkin Jive and Dust N Bones are the very definition of filler.
I don't like Coma at all. Don't understand how or why people do. I will go to my grave thinking people like it just because it's 10 minutes long. It's 10 minutes long, it has to be good!! Just like when fans mention the length of a concert as if that means anything in terms of quality.
Don't Cry is just blah boring. Horrible horrible horrible lyrics. The alt version on 2 is so much better.
I like Coma because of:
1 Great main riff
2 No clear basic verse-chorus-verse-chorus setup
3 Great vocals by Axl
4 Epic ending
I often like long songs, but not because of their length but because of most long songs I know are from bands which really keep the songs exciting and interesting for the whole 7/8/9/10+ minutes.
Metallica's St. Anger has fine examples of what NOT to do if you want to include longs songs.
For Don't Cry, I think the music is more important than the lyrics, so the 2 different versions don't matter too much to me, although the different interlude ending of the Alt. version is pretty cool (more like another verse with different vocals compared to the actual 'please remember' interlude).
St Anger..it's almost like they didn't remember how to end songs. They were interminable. They just kept going and going, repeating themselves with no clear vision.
I'm more of a lyric guy although all parts are important for a quality song. That's why I don't like This I Love. Great piece of music, horrendous lyrics. And the song suffers because of the lyrics.
Give me a Nick Cave with his great lyrics any day over an Yngwie Malmsteen and his guitar prowess. Although to be fair, Nick Cave is a great musician and his band The Bad Seeds are incredible as well.
I like Coma because of the ending but could do without the first 5 minutes, Double Talkin' Jive because of the rumbling riff and Don't Cry alternative version because of Axl's vocal melodies (not the lyrics). I am not a huge fan of Dust N' Bones.
I also dislike This I Love because of the horrible lyrics, but also because of the sappy melody and orchestration.
by King Nothing on Sun Jun 03, 2012 8:15 pm
I love Chinese Democracy and Appetite for Destruction! Both are amazing albums.
King Nothing
by Soulmonster on Sun Jun 03, 2012 9:21 pm
I am surprised CD is leading in the poll. Not that it is a bad album, just that I thought the typical GN'R fan prefers old guns. Perhaps most fans on fan boards are fans of the current music? In either way, great that the band can still create new fans and create music that people love.
by 666 on Sun Jun 03, 2012 9:24 pm
For me, being a fan since the very beginning, my musical tastes have expanded a great deal over time and I don't find AFD or the Illusions albums appealing anymore aside from a handful of songs. They really sound dated to me and I find it difficult to even get thru a few songs, let alone one of the albums as a whole. I might feel the same way about CD in a few years too though!
I've had periods where I've felt early GN'R was outdated, especially in regards to whatever current music I was listening at the time. But I always go back to it, especially AFD, and get into it again. Sure, it is dated and so obviously created by a young, immature guys who I can't really relate to much any more, but still...it's an affection thing, I guess.
by Jayadwi on Thu Jul 05, 2012 6:42 am
I like all their album but most is 'Use Your Illusion II', I can't explain why. I just like it more than the others.
Jayadwi
by Soulmonster on Thu Jul 05, 2012 7:00 am
You could try ranking the songs on UYI II: https://www.a-4-d.com/t1755-ranking-the-songs-on-use-your-illuions-ii
Ok, I'll do it. Thank you.
My pleasure, we also have threads for the other albums if you feel like ranking those songs, too
by Soulmonster on Fri May 31, 2013 10:38 am
Only 14 votes, but interesting that CD is the most popular record here at A4D.
Free forum | Music | Rock, Punk, Alternative | © phpBB | Free forum support | Report an abuse | Forumotion.com