Connor's Conundrums
Rants and musings about things political, philosophical, and religious.
Subscribe: RSS | E-mail
Moral Hazard in Utah: The Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control
photo credit: Tatyana Kildisheva
After years of flirting with various amounts of alcoholic prohibition, Utah created the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control in 1935. This department is granted statutory authority to conduct, license, and regulate the sale of alcoholic beverages within the state.
This is a government-enforced monopoly that exhibits the same corruption and failures that all such monopolies inevitably produce. The most recent example is the loss of $300,000 in taxpayer dollars. Uncovered through a legislative audit, the revelation that the DABC has been subsidizing a debt-laden and bankrupt distribution company led Senate President Michael Waddoups to tell the department's director that the loss "shows terrible management skills on your part….You're the person responsible for this debacle."
Those responsible for this debacle are Waddoups and his legislative cohorts who allow this moral hazard to exist in the first place. This is akin to a parent providing alcohol to his teenage son for a party with friends, and then blaming the son for drinking, driving, and causing an accident. While the teenage son made poor choices and shares blame for the damage, the ultimate responsibility lies with the parent who provided the opportunity for the damage to even occur in the first place.
When the legislature empowers a few bureaucrats to play fast and loose with taxpayer dollars, they cannot legitimately feign outrage when those individuals make poor decisions and abuse the misplaced trust they were given. This circumstance can be considered a microcosm of what we're seeing at the federal level, where the Federal Reserve is creating a monetary moral hazard by throwing money at the banks and institutions which helped cause our current economic crisis, further perpetuating the problem. At some point, and unless the supply is cut off, the moral hazard will cause the system to implode.
The government's monopoly over alcohol and intervention into the marketplace is a relic of the failed prohibition era and demonstrates the hypocrisy of any legislator who simultaneously supports the arrangement and also claims to champion the proper role of government. For under what rational argument can it be considered the government's legitimate role to be involved in business, strong-arm potential competitors out of the market, and mark up the product by at least 86%? What does that nefarious arrangement have to do with securing individual liberty?
The DABC, and Utah's corrupt control over an entire sector of the marketplace, is a stain on the fictional image that Utahns are somehow a liberty-loving, limited-government, self-reliant people. Rather than acting surprised at this audit's findings and expressing frustration at the reckless teenager types trying to manage what the legislature has tasked them with, government officials should instead put their legislative pens where their alleged principles are and turn alcohol distribution over to the private market.
Like this article? Get future ones delivered directly to your inbox.
← Of Soft Hearts and Social Safety Nets
An Invitation to Repeal →
7 Responses to "Moral Hazard in Utah: The Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control"
Jared Fulgham
May 18, 2011 at 9:42 am #
Thanks for posting this. I agree %100. Although I don't drink, I definitely think that the Utah system is broken. There are major issues when it comes to the DABC. Thanks for calling them out on this issue.
JJL9
May 18, 2011 at 11:07 am #
This issue needs to be dealt with once and for all. There is no rational argument in which a legislators champions individual liberty and freedom, the free market, and self accountability, and at the same time supports the state monopoly on liquor distribution.
May 18, 2011 at 2:10 pm #
From the DesNews:
Gov. Gary Herbert downplayed a new legislative audit that found a privately run liquor package agency lost $300,000, saying it's not clear there's a need for more oversight.
"I'm very comfortable that we're going to handle this issue fine. This is not a big problem," the governor said during Wednesday's taping of his monthly news conference on KUED Ch. 7.
When was the last time there was a "good" governor in Utah? Frankly, I'm disappointed with the people Utahans choose to represent them, in general. Not a great track record.
Clumpy
May 18, 2011 at 11:57 pm #
It's nonsense – if alcohol is legal, let the supermarkets and private liquor stores take care of it. The way the Utah legislature does it now – messing around with Utah's liquor customers (of which I am not one but a sympathizer) by using the state's monopoly as a political football whenever it suits them – is one of the most childish aspects of a highly childish state government.
"monopoly"? Are you sure? While I don't drink, I'm fairly certain that I've seen alcoholic beverages for sale at Smith's and/or Walmart in Utah County…
Brian, see here. Utah code controls, regulates, and licenses the distribution and consumption of alcohol. Drinks below a certain alcohol limit are available for public purchase through retail outlets at the good graces of the legislature. Drinks over a certain limit are sold only in state-owned stores. But it's all regulated through state law.
Leave your opinion here. Please be nice. Your Email address will be kept private.
Connor Boyack is president of Libertas Institute, a public policy think tank in Utah. He is the author of several books along with hundreds of columns and articles championing individual liberty. Connor's work has been publicly praised by national figures such as Ron Paul, Judge Andrew Napolitano, Tom Woods, and many others.
Why Does My Church Oppose Medical Marijuana?
Sex and the State: An Analysis of Consent
The Great and Abominable Church… of Caesar
What is Your Agency?
Dehumanization Through Objectification
View extended list »
Tweets by @cboyack
Passion-Driven Education: How to Use Your Child's Interests to Ignite a Lifelong Love of Learning
A child's curiosity and natural desire to learn are like a tiny flame, easily extinguished unless it's protected and given fuel. This book will help you as a parent both protect that flame of curiosity and supply it with the fuel necessary to make it burn bright throughout your child's life. Let's ignite our children's natural love of learning!
Feardom: How Politicians Exploit Your Emotions and What You Can Do to Stop Them
What do history's most notorious despots have in common with many of the flag-waving, patriotic politicians of our day? Both groups rise to power through the exploitation of fear, which has become a societal plague. There have been widespread casualties. We need an antidote. Feardom offers its readers a much-needed immunization.
The Tuttle Twins and the Road to Surfdom
History abounds with examples of government officials making decisions, well-intentioned or otherwise, that harm others. Unfortunately, these unintended consequences are never anticipated, and rarely considered once they occur. As the Tuttle Twins find in their latest adventure, central planning can ruin people's lives.
The Tuttle Twins and the Food Truck Fiasco
The oldest economic battle in history repeats itself in the fourth Tuttle Twins book. Ethan and Emily witness this battle firsthand as they help their food truck friends win public support to overturn the protectionist laws that shut them down.
The Tuttle Twins and the Creature from Jekyll Island
The third installment in the Tuttle Twins series finds Ethan and Emily confronting a scary creature that somehow controls money and markets. Your children will learn about money, inflation, banking, and other important monetary concepts in an exciting story, beautifully illustrated.
The Tuttle Twins and the Miraculous Pencil
In their second adventure, Ethan and Emily Tuttle go on a field trip to a fun factory where they learn how something as simple as a pencil is in fact a miracle—and one that nobody knows how to make! Your children will learn about the free market, why division of labor makes our lives better, and how spontaneous order is the key to human progress and happiness!
The Tuttle Twins Learn About The Law
Help your children learn about the proper role of government with this engaging book full of detailed, colorful illustrations! Ethan and Emily Tuttle learn from their wise neighbor Fred about the law, what our rights are and why we have them, and how we should voluntarily help those in need!
Latter-day Liberty: A Gospel Approach to Government and Politics
A fundamental aspect of the good news of the gospel is the message of liberty. As President Joseph F. Smith said, "The Kingdom of God is a Kingdom of freedom; the gospel of the Son of God is the gospel of liberty." Men of God, both ancient and modern, have spoken on this issue repeatedly. This book analyzes what liberty is and how it applies to government.
Latter-day Responsibility: Choosing Liberty Through Personal Accountability
Liberty is a fundamental and eternal principle, but it cannot exist without its counterpart—personal responsibility. From self-defense and self-reliance, to faith, family, and financial freedom, this book pinpoints precise actions needed from each of us if liberty is to successfully be preserved.
Anxiously Engaged: Essays of Faith, Family & Freedom
This book is a compilation of essays written over the years, organized topically. At 610 pages, it's great for reference material if you're debating something with a friend and want to look up some arguments that you can use to support your pro-liberty positions.
"An amazing book"
—Ron Paul on Latter-day Liberty
"Clear, compelling, full of faith"
—Judge Andrew Napolitano on Latter-day Responsibility
"Sophisticated and compelling"
—Tom Woods on Feardom
Significant discounts available for bulk orders of 20 or more. Contact me for information.
Subscribe: RSS | Email
Connor Boyack © 2021. All Rights Reserved.