1896: Charles Thiede, the first since Utah statehood
Add comment August 7th, 2012 Headsman
On this date in 1896, seven months after admittance as the 45th U.S. state,* Utah hanged Charles Thiede.
By birth a Pomeranian — the place, not the dog — this Salt Lake City saloon owner had gone to sea as a youth and had the hard drinking to show for it. He was plenty notorious before death row for getting into the drink himself, in which condition he often disported himself pummeling his wife, Mary.
When his wife turned up "mysteriously" done to death — her throat twice slashed — outside of Thiede's tavern one fine spring night in 1894, it didn't take much connecting of the dots to infer the guilt of her abusive husband, who also was the one who happened to "find" the body. Thiede, all the way to the end, would maintain his innocence, which nobody believed; a fistful of private detectives Thiede threw at the investigation in the weeks leading up to his death turned up little but a weird story about Mary dallying with a vengeful bootlegger. (Or Charles Thiede's own going hypothesis that some wandering Swedes tried to rape Mary.)
Still, it does have to be allowed that beating a spouse in private, however discreditable the deed, has a different character than slashing her throat on a public road. This was a distinct m.o., and there was little specific cause anyone could point to for Thiede's having done it. Circumstantial evidence has a way of stacking up against you when you're known as a violent drunk.
According to Frontier Justice in the Wild West, an Oregon firm was paid $150 to set up a scaffold (hidden from public view within a palisade) using the "twitch-up" design in vogue in the late 19th century. Thiede wasn't going to drop: he was going to be jerked upward by dropping a counterbalance.
The hanging rope passed through a hole in the crossbeam, over two pulleys, and down the side, where a 430-pound weight was attached. Under the noose was a low wooden platform upon which the condemned man was to stand while being prepared. In the entire construction of the gallows, not a nail or pin was used; it was bolted together so that it could be disassembled and used again.
This illustration of the setup for Charles Thiede's hanging appeared in the Aug. 11, 1896 Salt Lake Semi-Weekly Tribune. The caption explains the apparatus: "The executioner was concealed in the tent at right,and at a signal from the Sheriff pulled the hidden lever, which drew back (A) the projecting piece of steel which supported (B) the iron bar on which the 430-pound cube of lead rested, causing the weight to drop, and the body to be jerked upward."
This clever device worked perfectly, if the aforesaid Semi-Weekly Tribune is to be believed, but it would never see action again. Most Utahans preferred the state's other choice alternative for execution, the firing squad; there wouldn't be another hanging there until 1912.
Thiede himself was secretly buried in nearby Sandy, Utah, whose citizens were so incensed at becoming involuntary wardens of the killer's mortal remains that an armed standoff between Sandy residents and Thiede's people was only dialed down when the latter agreed to remove the remains from the cemetery proper and bury them in an adjacent feld.
* When the U.S. Supreme Court remanded the case to Utah shortly before the hanging, it at first accidentally addressed its order to the Territory of Utah.
2001: Vishal and Sonu, honor killings - 2020
1661: Jin Shengtan, literary scholar - 2019
1849: Celigny Ardouin, Haitian Minister of the Interior - 2018
1849: Ernst Elsenhans, Rastatt revolutionary - 2017
1844: William Saville, brutalising scene - 2016
1933: The Simele Massacre of Iraq's Assyrians begins - 2015
2009: Li Peiying, corrupt aviation kingpin - 2014
1864: Li Xiucheng, Taiping Rebellion general - 2013
1930: Thomas Shipp and Abram Smith, strange fruit - 2011
1936: The Sacred Heart, by Spanish leftists - 2010
1859: Ormond Chase, casus belli not quite - 2009
1777: A British spy, by Israel Putnam - 2008
1896: H. H. Holmes, America's first serial killer
1890: William Kemmler, only in America
1858: Marion Ira Stout, for loving his sister
1843: Allen Mair, irate
1867: Bridget Durgan, "hardly human"
1875: Six in Fort Smith under Hanging Judge Isaac Parker
1894: George Painter, Chicago infamous
Entry Filed under: 19th Century,Botched Executions,Capital Punishment,Common Criminals,Crime,Death Penalty,Execution,Hanged,History,Milestones,Murder,USA,Utah
Tags: 1896. 1890s, august 7, charles thiede, domestic violence, mary thiede, salt lake city, sandy