John H. Armstrong
The Mixed Legacy of Jimmy Carter
John Armstrong March 10, 2007 Politics
Former President Jimmy Carter has been in the news a lot lately. His most controversial book, Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, has brought him a great deal of air-time and some rather angry criticism. I have watched this conflict with a measure of sadness. I liked Carter, at least for a time. I even voted for him in 1976, but not in 1980. (Some still remind me of my "wasted vote" in 1976.) Back then I bought into the argument, such as it was, that we needed change, especially after the dark Nixon era. Jimmy Carter was a fresh face, a real outsider, a successful businessman, an Annapolis grad with military experience, and a forthright Christian. I respected Gerald Ford but thought Jimmy Carter would be a fresh alternative, a way to help us put the Watergate mess behind us as a nation.
I am now of the mind that the Carter administration was not a total disaster, but it came pretty close. The highpoint was the Sadat-Begin Middle East peace accord. From there his leadership was a virtual disaster. The tone of the nation was one of deep doubt and defeat, following Vietnam and the Watergate scandal, and our loss of national self-respect was truly profound. Ronald Reagan turned this around from 1981-89. His self-effacing humor, combined with his basic principles about the role of government, brought new hope and a restored sense of our national destiny.
But Jimmy Carter has often been hailed, and rightly so I think, as our best former-president. One thinks of his charitable work with Habit for Humanity, the actions for peace taken by the famous Carter Center in Atlanta, and his work for free and fair elections the world over. Some of his memoirs are even quite worth reading, including his historical-fiction. And I even agree with some of his concern about the political direction of the Southern Baptist Convention, though once again his own views are quite out of the mainstream to say the least. But when he wrote his most recent book he seemed to take the last decade of his public life to a new low.
For me this all began during the Lewinsky scandal. Carter could have played a powerful, bi-partisan role in those days. He was seen as a moral leader and a peacemaker but he chose to support the Democrats in their struggle to retain power and, with only minor protest, stood by Bill Clinton. I did not expect him to argue for impeachment, which I too had serious doubts about, but he could have done so much better. At least the old warhorse Robert Byrd rose to strongly condemn Clinton's impropriety and recklessness, along with Senators Joe Lieberman and Patrick Moynihan. But Carter seemed to take the lower road, disappointing me greatly at the time.
Then, during the recent controversial George W. Bush years (2001-2007), Carter has engaged in continual partisan attacks, sometimes in ways that are not in keeping with his peacemaker image at all. (Even Bill Clinton has taken a lesser role in attacking Bush during these past six-plus years. I will not speculate, at this point, what Bill Clinton might do when his wife's candidacy gets nearer the actual primaries in 2008. Clinton's relationship with former President George H. W. Bush does provide a model of how ex-partisans can seek higher good for worthy common causes after leaving office.)
So, what happened to Jimmy Carter? I have no idea but I do know this—he has changed his public approach over the past ten years. He has become more aggressive and more partisan then he ever was, even during his White House years. Perhaps this is a case where the people you hang out with do profoundly influence your actions and reactions. Carter has chosen, not inconsistently given his liberal populist views, to attack everything remotely conservative. The mainstream media has promoted this reaction. He now seems to use every occasion possible to attack this and that and then turn up the angry tone of our present national conversation, or lack thereof. Surely this man, who knows his Bible quite well, should see that he is not promoting the virtues of Christian faith in these actions.
Sadly, fourteen members of the Carter Center's advisory board resigned when his recent book came out. Even some leading Democrats, and a number of prominent Jewish leaders, reacted strongly against him this time. On Thursday of this week Carter spoke at George Washington University and met public protests, something he hasn't seen in years. Marchers carried signs saying, "Carter is a Liar." Rabbis were present in significant numbers. One said, "I believe Jimmy Carter is an anti-Semite and his intention is to hurt Jewish people." I do not believe that is true. Jimmy Carter is not an anti-Semite if you read his whole life and work. But this new book is unfortunately very bad. The use of the word "apartheid" should have cautioned Carter. Seemingly it would have done so many years ago. Something seems to have happened inside this decent man. He has become very angry, aggressive and incautious. I wish I understood this but I don't. I find it very sad when a former leader, who has had a real measure of dignity in his latter years of life, goes aggressively partisan and sharp-edged. His non-partisan efforts bore so much real Christian fruit among so many around the world. For a man who has been so deeply respectful of the thought of theologian Reinhold Niebuhr I wonder how he got so far from the realism and prophetic insightfulness of his favorite theologian?
Archives Select Month February 2020 (1) August 2019 (10) June 2019 (1) May 2019 (2) April 2019 (1) March 2019 (1) February 2019 (1) August 2018 (7) July 2018 (1) March 2018 (1) February 2018 (2) January 2018 (4) December 2017 (4) September 2017 (1) August 2017 (1) June 2017 (1) April 2017 (4) March 2017 (1) February 2017 (2) January 2017 (4) December 2016 (7) July 2016 (3) May 2016 (5) April 2016 (3) February 2016 (3) January 2016 (10) December 2015 (4) November 2015 (4) October 2015 (5) September 2015 (5) August 2015 (4) July 2015 (11) June 2015 (4) May 2015 (5) April 2015 (18) March 2015 (19) February 2015 (16) January 2015 (19) December 2014 (13) November 2014 (14) October 2014 (21) September 2014 (19) August 2014 (22) July 2014 (20) June 2014 (17) May 2014 (21) April 2014 (17) March 2014 (16) February 2014 (20) January 2014 (23) December 2013 (19) November 2013 (20) October 2013 (19) September 2013 (23) August 2013 (20) July 2013 (22) June 2013 (20) May 2013 (21) April 2013 (23) March 2013 (22) February 2013 (20) January 2013 (24) December 2012 (23) November 2012 (22) October 2012 (24) September 2012 (17) August 2012 (18) July 2012 (16) June 2012 (17) May 2012 (18) April 2012 (20) March 2012 (21) February 2012 (20) January 2012 (18) December 2011 (25) November 2011 (15) October 2011 (33) September 2011 (32) August 2011 (31) July 2011 (32) June 2011 (30) May 2011 (32) April 2011 (31) March 2011 (32) February 2011 (32) January 2011 (34) December 2010 (33) November 2010 (33) October 2010 (32) September 2010 (31) August 2010 (32) July 2010 (32) June 2010 (30) May 2010 (31) April 2010 (30) March 2010 (31) February 2010 (29) January 2010 (32) December 2009 (32) November 2009 (32) October 2009 (34) September 2009 (35) August 2009 (36) July 2009 (32) June 2009 (30) May 2009 (32) April 2009 (31) March 2009 (31) February 2009 (27) January 2009 (34) December 2008 (31) November 2008 (25) October 2008 (36) September 2008 (38) August 2008 (37) July 2008 (33) June 2008 (29) May 2008 (31) April 2008 (28) March 2008 (38) February 2008 (32) January 2008 (46) December 2007 (37) November 2007 (35) October 2007 (32) September 2007 (23) August 2007 (23) July 2007 (20) June 2007 (26) May 2007 (29) April 2007 (33) March 2007 (35) February 2007 (26) January 2007 (29) December 2006 (27) November 2006 (33) October 2006 (23) September 2006 (18) August 2006 (22) July 2006 (24) June 2006 (20) May 2006 (16) April 2006 (13) March 2006 (14) February 2006 (10) January 2006 (12) December 2005 (6) November 2005 (14) October 2005 (14) September 2005 (14) August 2005 (20) July 2005 (14) June 2005 (20) May 2005 (21) April 2005 (17)
Categories Select Category Abortion ACT 3 Acton Institute Advent America and Americanism American Evangelicalism Apologetics Baseball Biblical Theology Bio-Medical Ethics Books Business Charismatic Christianity Christ/Christology Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Church History Church Tradition Civil Rights College Football Contemplation Counseling Creeds Culture Current Affairs Death Discipleship Divine Providence Donors and Funding Economy/Economics Education Emergent Church Environmentalism Eschatology Ethics Eucharist Evangelism Faith Feminism & Women Fiction Film Forgiveness Free Speech Freedom Friendship Games God's Character Gospel/Good News Hermeneutics History Homiletics/Preaching Homosexuality Humor Ideology Immigration Incarnation Interfaith Relations and Dialogue Islam Israel Jesus Justification and the New Perspective Kingdom of God Leadership Liturgy Lordship of Christ Love Marriage & Family Media Mercy Missional Church Missional-Ecumenism Money & Stewardship Music My Christian Unity Story Mysticism Orthodoxy Pastoral Renewal Patristics Personal Philosophy Pietism Poetry Politics Pope Francis Postmodernity Poverty Prayer Protestantism Psychology Race and Racism Reason Reformed Christianity Religion Renewal Resurrection Roman Catholicism Sacraments Science Scripture Separation of Church & State Sexuality Social Networking Southern Baptists Spiritual Warfare Spirituality Sports Television The Christian Minister/Ministry The Church The Future The Persecuted Church The Trinity The War on Terrorism Theology Travel Uncategorized Unity of the Church Wealth Web/Tech Weblogs Women in the Church
The ID Card of the Christian Community (Matthew 5:1-12), a sermon by John H. Armstrong
"I Have Come to Bring Fire on the Earth" (Luke 12:49-56), a sermon by John H. Armstrong
"The Parable of the Rich Fool" (Luke 12"13-21), a sermon by John H. Armstrong
8/11/2019 Chicago SWS Message by Dr. John Armstrong (John 13:1-17, "Jesus Washes the Disciples' Feet")
"Q & A on Costly Love," Part 7 of a series of sermons by John H. Armstrong titled, "Costly Love"
John Armstrong on The Life and Last Days of a Saint: Dr. Ben Campbell Johnson
Jane Hubbard on The Life and Last Days of a Saint: Dr. Ben Campbell Johnson
Elizabeth R. Schelhouse on One Lord, One Church (John 17:20-26), a sermon by John H. Armstrong
John Armstrong on Lord, Orchestrate My Desires (Revised)
Tom Snook on Lord, Orchestrate My Desires (Revised)
Copyright 2017 John H Armstrong. All rights reserved worldwide.