The Best of 2018: Em's List
I read a lot of romance in 2018. My list of favorites is shorter than in years past, but I liked my favorites so much, I read most of them more than once – and I thoroughly enjoyed each of them all over again!
Salt Magic Skin Magic by Lee Welch
Friends, I hate that cover too. But look beyond it! Salt Magic Skin Magic is magical. Romantic. Suspenseful. Mysterious. Sexy. It's all those things and a tremendously engaging story. Featuring a pair of opposites – Soren, Lord Thornby, magically entrapped on his family's rural estate, and John Blake, a magician who specializes in inanimate magic – this enemies to lovers romance is compelling and engrossing from start to finish. The principal characters are terrific, the story is wildly imaginative and clever, the writing is excellent… and there's magic! Salt Magic Skin Magic is historical romance at its best.
Best of Luck by Kate Clayborn
While I loved the first two Chance of a Lifetime books, Best of Luck is the best and my favorite of the three. Alex and Greer are an unlikely pair: he's a world-renowned photographer who never stays in one place for long or forms attachments to the people he meets; she's completing her long-postponed college education at a school close to her family and friends and already has a position at the local hospital waiting for her after graduation. Their relationship shouldn't work, but it does. Brilliantly. Alex and Greer have great chemistry, and their romance had me riveted from the first page to the last. Everything about this novel sparkles.
The Prince by Katharine Ashe
In The Prince, author Katharine Ashe elevates two minor secondary characters featured in earlier Devil's Duke novels to principal roles; the combination is electric. Ziyaeddin is an exiled prince biding his time until he can return home, Libby is a clever and intelligent feminist ahead of her time. It's a slow and torturous burn as these two flirt and challenge each other from the moment they meet. The romance is swoon-worthy, the writing is crisp, clever and confident, and The Prince is one of the best novels of the year.
The Kiss Quotient is smart, special, and wonderful. From the odd (extreme) opposites pairing, to its shades of Pretty Woman premise, it doesn't seem like The Kiss Quotient should work – but it does! Magnificently. The novel treds familiar ground – a socially awkward woman falls hard for a handsome and confident man – but there's nothing formulaic about it. Our heroine, Stella Lane, has Asperger's. But she refuses to allow it to limit her life experiences and she hires Michael Phan, a professional escort, to teach her physical intimacy. Michael is a masterful lover but he also seems to 'get' Stella almost from the moment they meet. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to understand himself very well. The writing is fresh and engaging, the story is wholly original, and the romance is passionate, sexy and nothing like you expect. Everything about The Kiss Quotient – the clever cover, the wonderful story, the terrific writing -adds up. (that's a little math humor for you).
Melt for You by JT Geissinger
Melt for You made me melt for it. Funny, bittersweet and delightful, I read it from start to finish one rainy weekend afternoon. Joellen Bixby is a modern day wallflower. Overworked, underpaid, secretly in lust for her boss, and lacking in self-confidence and love for herself, Joellen finds herself at odds with her (temporary) next-door neighbor. Cameron McGregor, the Scottish rugby team captain, moves into the apartment across from Joellen after fleeing a fake news story splashed across the european tabloids. Confident, brash, big and beautiful, he's everything Joellen isn't – so he decides to teach her everything he knows after she agrees to feed him. Their relationship is hysterically funny and lovely, the opposites pairing is brilliant, and I loved it – and them! I wasn't as fond of the plot contrivance that ensures they spend time together, but this story is simply so charming that barely detracts from it's many pleasures. Melt for You is, by far, Ms. Geissinger's best work to date.
Buy it at: Amazon
The Henchmen of Zenda by K.J. Charles
Every time I start a K.J. Charles book I'm convinced it can't possibly be as good as the one that preceded it, but happily, every time Ms. Charles proves me wrong. Told from an alternate point of view and substantially queerer (Ms. Charles' words), The Henchmen of Zenda is loosely based on the classic The Prisoner of Zenda, and the author packs A LOT into its short page count. There are villains, double crosses, kidnappings, sword fights, a princess, intrigues and doppelgangers, and a sexy May-December, opposites attract love affair. The story is complex and features a large cast of memorable secondary characters – and it demands all of your attention as you read it. But it's worth your time and focus, friends. The Henchmen of Zenda is the wonderful, swashbuckling story you hoped for when you glimpsed that lovely cover, and I loved every single thing about it.
Long Shot and Block Shot (Hoops 1 & 2) by Kennedy Ryan
Although very VERY different, the first two books in the Hoops series by Kennedy Ryan (a new to me author) are fantastic. In Long Shot, Iris DuPree meets star college basketball player Augustus West at a bar the night before the college basketball national championship. Something intense flares between them – but when Augustus presses her for a kiss at the end of the night, she reluctantly turns him down. Iris is already in a relationship. That fateful decision reverberates through the rest of the novel. Mesmerizing, harrowing and lovely, this book will absolutely break you. Block Shot re-introduces readers to Jared Foster, step-brother, agent and business partner to Augustus. Ten years ago, Jared fell hard for Banner Morales. When he confessed his feelings, he happily discovered she felt the same. Unfortunately, their one-night stand ended in disaster, and she's avoided him ever since. When Jared relocates to LA, he finds himself vying with Banner for clients, and decides it's time to take his shot with her again. Jared doesn't care that Banner is already in a committed relationship; he wants Banner and he'll do whatever he can to win her. Steamy, sexy, smart and completely addictive, Block Shot is nothing like the novel that precedes it, but every bit as good.
Buy Long Shot at: Amazon Buy Block Shot at: Amazon
Object of Desire by Dal Maclean
Much as she did with Ben Morgan in her loosely linked first book, Bitter Legacy, Dal Maclean took a character I actively disliked and had me totally invested in his story anyway. Tom Gray is the titular object of desire – he lives life on his own terms and doesn't like anyone or anything to threaten his independence or freedom. He's mostly oblivious to his effect on the people around him (and a supremely unreliable narrator), and finds himself in a heap of trouble when the estranged wife of his lover is found murdered and evidence suggests he killed her. When his lover hires a private investigator to clear his name, he's relieved…until he discovers the PI is Will Foster, his former partner – the man he abruptly and brutally dumped two years ago. Oh Tom. You're such a dick! (I rooted for him and Will anyway). Sexy, suspenseful and dark, Object of Desire is my favorite romantic suspense novel of the year.
The Duke I Tempted by Scarlett Peckham
After the death of his wife and infant child, Archer Stonewell, the Duke of Westmead, needed an outlet for his guilt and pain. He found it submitting on his knees at Charlotte Street. Only there can Archer be his true self; outside of Charlotte Street, he ruthlessly suppresses all emotion in his personal and business life. Only, he can't seem to control himself once he meets Poplar – Poppy – Cavendish, an ambitious, self-taught botanist, with whom he suddenly and irrevocably, falls in love. Poppy wants Archer and his secrets; Archer wants a wife to beget an heir – and nothing else. Their marriage of convenience doesn't quite work out the way either expects. The Duke I Tempted tempts with it's oh, so beautiful cover, and then lures you in once these two flawed and lonely souls find one another.
This year saw the start of several new series that I absolutely fell in love with, and it's impossible to tell you which one I like best. A few standouts: Sidney Bell's, The Woodbury Boys is simply wonderful, and I'm completely invested in the Big Bad Wolf series by Charlie Adhara, one of the smartest and most unique shifter series I've had the pleasure to read. The characters are compelling, the individual mysteries are clever, and overarching storyline will keep me coming back for more; and finally, the Riven duology by Roan Parrish. This pair of books are lush, romantic and deeply affecting.
I also enjoyed the continuation/ending of several other series I've grown to love and want to recommend them once again: Bec McMaster fans were treated to TWO new novels in the amazing London Steampunk: The Blue Blood Conspiracy in 2018, and both books – You Only Love Twice and To Catch a Rogue – earned DIKs here at All About Romance. I was disappointed by book 5, Squared Away, in Annabeth Albert's Out of Uniform series – but after the tremendously good Tight Quarters, I have my fingers crossed that the last book, Rough Terrain, will end the series on a high note.
By Emily Wittmann|2019-01-09T11:08:47-05:00January 3rd, 2019|Categories: Best of List, EmAAR, Romance reading|Tags: Best of 2018|15 Comments
A nice list, Em!
Peckham is such a rising talent; I'm looking forward to her next novel!
I always love doing my Best of, and reminiscing/rereading favorite books.
Re: the Welch cover. In retrospect, I regret opening a gushing recommendation with a criticism. Though I said it poorly, my opinion is that the cover doesn't do justice to the ABSOLUTE BRILLIANCE of this book, and I wish it was different.
Dabney Grinnan
Reply to Em
The cover doesn't work for me. I think, like most things, it's a different strokes for different folks thing.
CarolineAAR
Reply to Dabney Grinnan
I did the same thing on my review of Caressed by Ice by Nalini Singh, which I was thinking about when I saw people criticize you for this on Twitter. https://allaboutromance.com/my-summer-of-singh/
I think it's valid because people ARE influenced by covers, and I've definitely had people look at a book I wanted them to read and say "Ew, no." In the Singh case, the hero looks like you fished the corpse of an early-1990s stripper out of a frozen river. That's terrible for an incredibly sexy, powerful, and vibrant hero. For Salt Magic Skin Magic, the cover has a dated aesthetic and makes the book look amateurish, which by all accounts could not be more inaccurate.
I will certainly reflect on ways to phrase my cover critiques better, but I think it's within the reviewer's purview.
Reply to CarolineAAR
Not to mention that SBTB does cover snark on a regular basis.
I think cover art is fair game for critique as it is part of selling the product.
I also engage in snarky commentary on titles from time to time. Romance writing in general suffers from a severe lack of creativity when it comes to titling books. I tend to notice when a book I'm interested in also has a unique title, as that can actually entice me to read the book.
Reply to Blackjack
I agree with that as long as we are careful not to blame an author who likely had no control. Carla Kelly has often shared her original titles (Marrying the Captain was supposed to be Worthy; that's the one that sticks in my head). So if I hate a title, I try to focus on the title ("this is so generic") without saying "what was the author thinking," etc.
The Prince by Ashe is on sale for $1.99. I really liked the one in the series before it, The Earl a Devil's Duke, so I will definitely by checking out The Prince. In Best of Luck by Claybourn, both characters have gone through a lot, and their story has depth that has me thinking about it long after finishing the book. Thanks Em for your reviews.
Caz Owens
Reply to Kay
Actually, The Duke comes before The Prince – but it was really poor and not up to KA's usual standard, so I'm not surprised you've missed it out! :P The Earl, however, is terrific.
I have a number of Em's favorites on my favorite end-of-year list, including the fabulous Best of Luck from Kate Clayborn, my very favorite book of the entire year. I also though loved Gissinger's Melt for You and Hoang's The Kiss Quotient. I'm going to recommend the Welch book to my niece as she loves fantasy/romance. I have The Prince and The Duke I Tempted on my tbr list for 2019.
Maria Rose
Our crossover is The Kiss Quotient, but I almost had The Duke I tempted on my list too! (it made my top 20). I love Kennedy Ryan, but haven't been able to keep up with her new stuff – hope to remedy that this year!
Emily Wittmann
Reply to Maria Rose
The Ryan books are excellent! I hope you get back to them soon – I think you are in for a treat!
Wow great way to start off your post by dissing a beautiful cover.
Reply to J
But it's a really ugly cover.
Reply to pft
Agreed. The book is terrific (it's in my forthcoming Best of list) but the cover is horrible :(
chrisreader on Writing to a Soundtrack: A Guest Post by Alexandra Y. Caluen
Caz Owens on Writing to a Soundtrack: A Guest Post by Alexandra Y. Caluen
chrisreader on Bridgerton on Netflix. Love it? Loathe it? Here's a place to discuss it!
Susan/DC on Bridgerton on Netflix. Love it? Loathe it? Here's a place to discuss it!
trish on Writing to a Soundtrack: A Guest Post by Alexandra Y. Caluen
Eggletina on Bridgerton on Netflix. Love it? Loathe it? Here's a place to discuss it!
Dabney Grinnan on Bridgerton on Netflix. Love it? Loathe it? Here's a place to discuss it!
Writing to a Soundtrack: A Guest Post by Alexandra Y. Caluen
The Best Book of 2020: Round Two
Best Belated Reads of 2020
the [email protected]: What's your least favorite insult leveled at romance?
The Best Book of 2020? The readers decide!
The Best Book of 2020: AAR Staff Picks
Dear Streaming Services: What to do after Bridgerton?
the [email protected]: Who would you cast in Lord of Scoundrels and other favorite romances?
The Best of 2020 – Dabney's list
The Best of 2020 – Lisa's List