December 5, 2019
‘Buildings’ in human bone may hold key to stronger 3D-printed lightweight structures
WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — What do bones and 3D-printed buildings have in common? They both have columns and beams on the inside that determine how long they last.
Now, the discovery of how a “beam” in human bone material handles a lifetime’s worth of wear and tear could translate to the development of 3D-printed lightweight materials that last long enough for more practical use in buildings, aircraft and other structures.
A team of researchers at Cornell University, Purdue University and Case Western Reserve University found that when they mimicked this beam and made it about 30% thicker, an artificial material could last up to 100 times longer.
“Bone is a building. It has these columns that carry most of the load and beams connecting the columns. We can learn from these materials to create more robust 3D-printed materials for buildings and other structures,” said Pablo Zavattieri, a professor in Purdue’s Lyles School of Civil Engineering.
Bones get their durability from a spongy structure called trabeculae, which is a network of interconnected vertical plate-like struts and horizontal rod-like struts acting as columns and beams. The denser the trabeculae, the more resilient the bone for everyday activities. But disease and age affect this density.
In a study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the researchers found that even though the vertical struts contribute to a bone’s stiffness and strength, it is actually the seemingly insignificant horizontal struts that increase the fatigue life of bone.
Christopher Hernandez’s group at Cornell had suspected that horizontal strut structures were important for bone durability, contrary to commonly held beliefs in the field about trabeculae.
“When people age, they lose these horizontal struts first, increasing the likelihood that the bone will break from multiple cyclic loads,” said Hernandez, a professor of mechanical, aerospace and biomedical engineering.
Studying these structures further could inform better ways to treat patients suffering from osteoporosis.
Meanwhile, 3D-printed houses and office spaces are making their way into the construction industry. While much faster and cheaper to produce than their traditional counterparts, even printed layers of cement would need to be strong enough to handle natural disasters – at least as well as today’s homes.
That problem could be solved by carefully redesigning the internal structure, or “architecture,” of the cement itself. Zavattieri’s lab has been developing architected materials inspired by nature, enhancing their properties and making them more functional.
As part of an ongoing effort to incorporate nature’s best strength tactics into these materials, Zavattieri’s lab contributed to mechanical analysis simulations determining if horizontal struts might play a larger role in human bone than previously thought. They then designed 3D-printed polymers with architectures similar to trabeculae.
The simulations revealed that the horizontal struts were critical for extending the fatigue life of bone. A YouTube video is available at https://youtu.be/XK7NZMZ4YDs.
“When we ran simulations of the bone microstructure under cyclic loading, we were able to see that the strains would get concentrated in these horizontal struts, and by increasing the thickness of these horizontal struts, we were able to mitigate some of the observed strains,” said Adwait Trikanad, a co-author on this work and civil engineering Ph.D. student at Purdue.
Applying loads to the bone-inspired 3D-printed polymers confirmed this finding. The thicker the horizontal struts, the longer the polymer would last as it took on load.
Because thickening the struts did not significantly increase the mass of the polymer, the researchers believe this design would be useful for creating more resilient lightweight materials.
“When something is lightweight, we can use less of it,” Zavattieri said. “To create a stronger material without making it heavier would mean 3D-printed structures could be built in place and then transported. These insights on human bone could be an enabler for bringing more architected materials into the construction industry.”
Other study authors include Ashley Torres, Cameron Aubin and Marysol Luna at Cornell and Clare Rimnac at Case Western Reserve University.
Hernandez and Zavattieri have been organizing and leading mentoring activities for students and young investigators as part of the Society of Hispanic Professional Engineers. The work was financially supported by the National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases and a National Science Foundation CAREER award for which Zavattieri is a recipient.
Writer: Kayla Wiles, 765-494-2432, email@example.com
Pablo Zavattieri, 765-496-9644, firstname.lastname@example.org
Christopher Hernandez, 607-255-5129, email@example.com
Note to Journalists: For a copy of the paper, please contact Kayla Wiles, Purdue News Service, at firstname.lastname@example.org. A YouTube video is available at https://youtu.be/XK7NZMZ4YDs. The video was created by Erin Easterling, digital producer for the Purdue College of Engineering, 765-496-3388, email@example.com. Other photos and multimedia of the bone-inspired 3D-printed materials are available in a Google Drive folder at http://bit.ly/3D-bone-inspired-media.
Bone-Inspired Microarchitectured Materials with Enhanced Fatigue Life
Ashley M. Torres,1 Adwait A. Trikanad,2 Cameron A. Aubin,1 Floor M. Lambers,1 Marysol Luna,1 Clare M. Rimnac,3 Pablo Zavattieri,2 Christopher J. Hernandez,1,4
1Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, USA
2Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA
3Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA
4Hospital for Special Surgery, New York, NY, USA
Microarchitectured materials achieve superior mechanical properties through geometry rather than composition. Although ultralightweight microarchitectured materials can have high stiffness and strength, application to durable devices will require sufficient service life under cyclic loading. Naturally occurring materials provide useful models for high-performance materials. Here, we show that in cancellous bone, a naturally occurring lightweight microarchitectured material, resistance to fatigue failure is sensitive to a microarchitectural trait that has negligible effects on stiffness and strength—the proportion of material oriented transverse to applied loads. Using models generated with additive manufacturing, we show that small increases in the thickness of elements oriented transverse to loading can increase fatigue life by 10 to 100 times, far exceeding what is expected from the associated change in density. Transversely oriented struts enhance resistance to fatigue by acting as sacrificial elements. We show that this mechanism is also present in synthetic microlattice structures, where fatigue life can be altered by 5 to 9 times with only negligible changes in density and stiffness. The effects of microstructure on fatigue life in cancellous bone and lattice structures are described empirically by normalizing stress in traditional stress vs. life (S-N) curves by √ψ, where ψ is the proportion of material oriented transverse to load. The mechanical performance of cancellous bone and microarchitectured materials is enhanced by aligning structural elements with expected loading; our findings demonstrate that this strategy comes at the cost of reduced fatigue life, with consequences to the use of microarchitectured materials in durable devices and to human health in the context of osteoporosis.