OHC Curator E. S. Thomas warns about DDT use… in 1948!
Edward S. Thomas
In doing background research for our new exhibit Going, Going, Gone? Endangered and Extinct Species, I was reading through some of Edward S. Thomas’s older newspaper articles. Ed Thomas was the Curator of Natural History from 1931 – 1962 at what was then called the Ohio State Archaeological and Historical Society (now the Ohio History Connection). He was also a prolific writer and authored a column in the Columbus Dispatch for almost 60 years. Many of Edward Thomas’s columns were reprinted in the book “In Ohio Woods and Fields” published by the Dispatch Printing Co. in 1981. One of his articles caught my eye, not from the title “Beware of the Boomerang!” but from the letters “DDT” that jumped off the page.
In the exhibit we feature Rachael Carson, and talk about how she warned the world about the dangers of indiscriminate use of the insecticide DDT. Her landmark book “Silent Spring” was published in 1962; so why was Ed Thomas mentioning DDT 14 years earlier!? What did he know that wasn’t to be common knowledge for over a decade later? Here are some quotes from his article:
“Applied to window and door screens or to the inside walls of stables, DDT is little short of miraculous in exterminating flies and mosquitoes.But and note this carefully neither DDT nor any other insecticide is selective. It destroys good and bad alike and it fails to affect certain dangerous insects.”
DDT insect spray
“Here is a homely example: I have been dusting our roses with a shot-gun rose dust. Among a number of other things, it contains DDT. DDT is moderately effective against rose aphids, but it is horribly lethal to some of the aphids enemies, such as syrphus flies and many near-microscopic wasp-like parasites which feed solely on aphids. Result: the dust has not controlled the aphids on my roses. Aphids on other plants in my garden seem more numerous than usual.I am seriously debating whether I should use DDT on roses.”
“DDT has another serious drawback. It is extremely lethal to fishes, frogs and salamanders and aquatic insects. I must warn against using it in ponds to destroy mosquito larvae unless you are willing also to destroy every other living thing in the pond.”
“I am especially concerned over a new type of spraying equipment, known as a ‘mist sprayer’, which is capable of spraying tons of DDT or other potent insecticides at high velocity through dense woodland. If used indiscriminately its capacity for harm is limitless.”
“The new insecticides are proving invaluable in combating many specific pests which have previously been difficult to control. But let’s use them sparingly, cautiously, and as intelligently as possible. If we don’t, they’re likely to boomerang–with a bang.”
Not only does he warn us about DDT, 24 years before it was officially banned in 1972, but this article illustrates the value of natural history – of close observation of the natural world. Ed Thomas noted the problem with DDT, and the complexity and interactivity of all species, just by carefully observing the insect populations on his rose bushes.