Babylonian Talmud is More Detailed On The Birth Of Jesus Than The Bible
For historians, whether Christian, Jewish or Muslim, the Talmud is in many ways the perfect primary source, a first-hand account with a direct connection to Judaism. Through the Talmud, we can learn more about the birth of Jesus as a historical event and, also, the “meaning” of the Star of Bethlehem.
There are two Talmuds: the Babylonian version and the Jerusalem version. This article focuses on the Babylonian Talmud, which is different in key instances. From the Babylonian Talmud we can learn more about Matthew’s nativity story, regarding the birth of Jesus, and, also, the phenomena known to us today at the Star of Bethlehem. Unfortunately, the Talmud, both versions, has often been viewed with doubt and distain by Christian historical scholars. But this is a mistake. Putting aside religious politics, we can see that the birth of Jesus and the Star of Bethlehem are both better described in the Babylonian Talmud than any other ancient source. And here’s why . . .
Babylonian Talmud, vol XXII, Masechet Sanhedrin, Edit. & Print A.J. Menkes & S. Sprechner, Lwow 1864. (Library of Jewish Community in Bielsko-Biala, Poland / CC BY-SA 4.0 )
What Is the Talmud And Why Is It Questioned By Others?
To many, if not most, Christians, the Jewish Talmud is one of the most confusing and misunderstood books of Judaism. Some scholars choose to avoid it as a historic source for Christianity in favor of the Torah and the New Testament. The term Talmud, most often, refers to the collection of books known as the Babylonian Talmud. Another collection of books that was written earlier is known as the Jerusalem Talmud.
The Babylonian Talmud has two main components: the Mishnah (c. 200 BC), a written collection of Rabbinic Judaism's Oral Law or the Oral Torah: the laws, statutes, and legal interpretations that were not recorded in the Five Books of Moses (Written Torah); and the Gemara (c. 500 BC), a clarification or explanation by Rabbis of the Mishnah and related Tannaitic writings that often ventures onto other topics and expands broadly on the Old Testament .
In layman’s terms, Orthodox Jews believe that the “Oral Law” was given to Moses while he was on Mt. Sinai along with Written Torah. Then it was passed on orally from Moses to Joshua to the Prophets and, finally, to the rabbis who wrote it out and referred to it as the Talmud. This occurred when the Jews were being dispersed from Israel during the Jewish Diaspora. And at that time, Jewish leaders were apprehensive that their traditions and knowledge were in danger of disappearing. The Talmud aided in keeping the Jewish people together and helped to preserve their heritage.
Babylonian Talmud manuscript copied by Solomon ben Samson, France, 1342 AD. (Sodabottle / CC BY-SA 3.0 )
The term "Talmud" may refer to either the Gemara alone, or the Mishnah and Gemara together. The Talmud was written during the Jewish Diaspora —a time of great antisemitic persecutions by pagan and Christian Roman emperors—and includes several anti-Christian remarks. Because of this, the Talmud has been banned and burned throughout history. With the invention of the printing press, numerous anti-Talmud literature soon followed. Even Martin Luther contributed to this belief. In On the Jews and Their Lies , Luther attacks the Talmud, suggesting repeatedly that, “their synagogues be burned, houses torn down, books be taken, and rabbis prohibited from teaching.” Today some scholars even consider Luther’s writings to be the basis of German antisemitism. The Lutheran Church has since denounced the work by Martin Luther, but attacks on the Talmud still persist by many different groups and religions.
Nevertheless, the Talmud is still the cornerstone of Judaism. Shmuel Safrai in A History of the Jewish People neatly summed up the influence of the Babylonian Talmud when he wrote:
“It became the basic—and in many places almost the exclusive—asset of Jewish traditions, the foundation of all Jewish thought and aspirations and the guide for the daily life of the Jews. Other components of national culture were made known only in so far as they are embedded in the Talmud. In almost every period and community until the modern age, the Talmud was the main object of Jewish study and education. And all the external conditions and event of life seemed to be but passing incidents, and the only true, permanent reality was that of the Talmud.”
To historians, whether Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or other, the Talmud is the perfect primary source. It is a first-hand account with a direct connection to Judaism. It covers the daily laws and legal decisions for Jews, is a biographical dictionary with anthropological information, and is a guideline for rabbinic philosophy and debate. Because Jesus studied the Law and astonished the Temple teachers at age 12 (Luke 2:46-7), we can learn more about how Jesus lived and thought by studying the Talmud.
In the Gospel According to Matthew both the birth of Jesus and the Star of Bethlehem are mentioned but only in the vaguest terms. ( Michael Flippo / Adobe Stock)
In the past the Talmud was used, sometimes without acknowledgement, as a source for Christian theological works . But are there clues in its volumes that can provide more clarification to Matthew’s nativity story ? The answer is yes. There are two very interesting verses that contribute to what the author or authors of Matthew wrote just a few generations after the crucifixion of Jesus. Matthew is vague on the timing of the birth of Jesus, and what celestial object the Star of Bethlehem was.
Matthew 2:1-2 states:
“After Jesus was born in Bethlehem in Judea, during the time of King Herod, Magi from the east came to Jerusalem and asked, “Where is the one who has been born king of the Jews? We saw his star in the east and have come to worship him.”
Matthew provides no clue as to what exactly the star was, provides no date for the event, and does not acknowledge where the Magi came from, only the east (most likely Parthia/Persia).
- Can Astronomy Explain the Biblical Star of Bethlehem?
- A Christmas story: the arrival of a sweet baby boy – or a political power to change the world?
- 5,000-Year-Old Rock Painting Suggests a Nativity Scene 3,000 Years Before Jesus’ birth
The Jewish Month of the Nativity
Judaism before and during the time of Christ believed in the idea of the “integral age” of the great Jewish patriarchs . This meant that those who lived a divine life were born and later died during the Passover month of Nisan. Nisan in the Jewish calendar is the first month of the ecclesiastical year and the seventh month—eighth month during leap years—of the civil year. It is a spring month and occurs during the Gregorian months of either March or April. In Jewish history and tradition, it was the month of the Creation of the Universe (at the spring equinox), the death of Abraham, the Exodus from Egypt, Passover, and the birth and death of Isaac.
The Rosh Hashanah tractate of the Babylonian Talmud, which states that the truest Jewish patriarchs were born and died during Passover in the Jewish month of Nisan. (Gylatshalit / CC BY-SA 3.0 )
Joshua ben Hananiah (died 131 AD), also known as Rabbi Yehoshua, says:
“In Nisan the world was created, and in the same month the patriarchs were born, and in Nisan they also died; Isaac was born on the Passover; on New Year’s Day Sarah, Rachel, and Hannah were visited, Joseph was released from prison, and the bondage of our fathers in Egypt ceased. In Nisan our ancestors were redeemed from Egypt, and in the same month we shall again be redeemed.”
If this verse was from the Old Testament it would be highly suggested by Christians today that Jesus was born during the month of Nisan. Jesus has many symbolic links to Isaac. Both are perhaps the best-known “sons” from the Bible. Isaac, the son of Abraham, was spared from human sacrifice. Today Isaac is known as the Father of the Israelites. And Jesus, the Son of God, who was not spared, is known today as the savior of the world by Christians.
The Gospels inform us that Jesus was crucified during Passover around 30 AD. Some early Christians were also keen on the idea of Jesus being born and dying in Nisan at the time of Passover. Clement of Alexandria (c. 150 AD—c. 215) wrote in the Stromata that some of the Gnostic Christians in Alexandria were worshiping the Nativity on the same date as Easter. It can be reasoned that Jesus, a Jewish patriarch, was not only crucified and resurrected during a Passover celebration but was also born as well during a Passover celebration. This fits the belief of important patriarchs of Judaism being born during the month of Passover. It may not prove that Jesus was the savior or King of the Jews as that is a personal belief. However, messiah or not, it would give Jesus the credentials that enough people during his time might follow him or believe he was the chosen one. Another “credential” would be to born under a “star” similar to the one mentioned in Matthew.
The so-called Star of Bethlehem is still misunderstood but the Babylonian Talmud does tell us more. ( gldcreations / Adobe Stock)
Vague And Detailed Descriptions of the Star of Bethlehem
Matthew only briefly describes the celestial object over Bethlehem sometime before the death of Herod in 4 BC as a “star” that rose with no other description. It could have been a comet, conjunction of celestial objects, or a supernova. The only primary source that I have discovered that could be the star was cited from a Chinese astronomical observation made in March of 5 BC (see my previous Ancient Origins article ). This is a tantalizing source when used in concurrence with the Talmud because it corresponds chronologically with the belief of vital leaders of Judaism being born during the month of Nisan. In 5 BC, Passover was on March 23. But the definition of “star” in the Talmud needs further examination to discover if a comet could also be defined as a star.
If you guessed that there exists a verse from the Talmud that describes a comet as a star, then you are correct. In the Babylonian Talmud, Tract Horioth, Rabban Gamaliel II, the first leader of the Sanhedrin as nasi after the fall of the Second Temple in 70 AD, has a dispute with Rabbi Yehoshua over the amount of provisions of food on a trip. Gamaliel says, “There is a star which appears once in seventy years that makes the captains of the ships err, and I thought perhaps it will appear now and make us err, I therefore prepared more food.” The ‘star’ that appears every seventy years is most likely Halley’s comet.
Both Gamaliel and Yehoshua were young men when Halley’s comet made an appearance in 66 AD. In the Soncino version of the Babylonian Talmud the word “appears” is replaced with “rises”, which is even more coherent with Matthew in the NIV translation. Therefore, near the time that Matthew was written, comets were also referred to as stars by the Jewish rabbis and were known to rise in the heavens, like the account in Matthew.
Hayley's Comet was not the Star of Bethlehem, but some other comet might have been. ( muratart / Adobe Stock)
The Chinese comet of March 5 BC was not the only comet observed and recorded as a star during Passover. In 66 AD, Halley’s comet returned to the Earth’s vicinity shortly before the Jewish revolt against the Roman Empire. The comet was first observed by the Chinese in January, and made its closest approach to Earth on March 20, close to the spring equinox. According to the historian Josephus, the Jews were not apprehensive about bad omens. His remarkable account states:
“Thus it was that the imposter and pretended messengers of Heaven at that time beguiled the wretched people; while the manifest portents that foreshowed the approaching desolation they neither heeded nor credited; but, as if confounded and bereft alike of the eyes and mind, they disregarded the immediate warnings of God. Thus it was when a star resembling a sword stood over the city, and a comet which continued for a year. Thus also it was, when prior to the revolt and the first movements of the war, at the time when the people were assembling for the feast of unleavened bread… By the inexperienced this was deemed favorable, but by the sacred scribes it was at once pronounced a prelude of that whish afterwards happened. (The Jewish War of Flavius Josephus, 1858 Edition)”
Therefore, comets were often referred to as stars by ancient writers. Another interesting fact is that the Crucifixion of Jesus most likely—based on data from the US Navy and NASA—occurred during the month of April in ether 30 AD or 33 AD. Even though this is in a different month of the 5 BCE Passover, it was still in the month of Passover or Nisan. This is because of the difference between the solar based Gregorian calendar and the lunar based Jewish calendar. Even in modern times Easter is sometimes celebrated in March and sometimes April.
I’m working on a new book that is close to completion that explores in greater detail some of the events that were in the heavens at the same time as the March 5 BC comet. There is much that was occurring around Passover of 5 BC that the Magi would have been interested in!
Top image: The birth of Jesus with all its elements: the three kings, the holy family and the Star of Bethlehem. Source: honeyflavour / Adobe Stock
By Robert W. Weber
Abbot, Jacob. Alexander the Great . Akron, OH: New Warner Co. , 1910.
Deutsch, Gotthard. “Luther, Martin.” In JewishEncyclopedia.com, American Edition, 55 vols. St. Louis and Philadelphia: Concordia Publishing House and Fortress Press, 1955.
Josephus, Flavius, Robert Traill, and Isaac Taylor. The Jewish War of Flavius Josephus: a New Translation by the Late Rev. Robert Traill, Edited, with Notes, by Isaac Taylor. With Pictorial Illustrations . Boston: John P. Jewett and Company, 1858.
Rodkinson, Michael L. New Edition of the Babylonian Talmud . Boston: Talmud Society, 1918.
Goldberg, B. Z., Abraham Malamat, and Haim Hillel Ben-Sasson. A History of the Jewish People . Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1976.