Northern communities are especially overpopulated with stray and unowned dogs. There are probably enough animals within our own provinces to keep rescue groups and animal shelters fully occupied and focused for the unforeseeable future. Why then, are some organizations crossing borders to rescue animals from other countries? This is indeed a hot topic in the rescue community and not everyone is in favor of saving animals that are not Canadian born.
There are as many people vehemently opposed to cross border rescue efforts as there are people doing the actual rescuing. Are there pros and cons to this extension of the rescue "business"? Of course there are. Should it be stopped and, is that really up to the general public to decide?
In point form, the negative aspects of importing rescue animals:
- spiked numbers of unowned animals requiring homes within our own country
- inadequate import standards at border crossing may allow pathogens into the host country
- the import process does not teach communities abroad to manage their own stray and /or unwanted animal population
- increase in adopted rescue animals being surrendered
- Most rescues already in existence usually focus on a particular aspect of the dog community, for instance, senior dogs, breed type, northern community strays, lost dogs and/or unclaimed strays, small dogs, large breed, etc. An important note is that no matter what particular "specialization" a rescue seems to have, all dogs in need would be taken in and cared for. Further to this point, rescue organizations (for the most part) that are crossing borders are formed and operated with the intention of bringing in animals from foreign soil. They do their own fund raising and acquire their own teams of fosters and own the process of importing international animals for rescue purposes. Individuals who are likely to donate or volunteer to an organization generally support a rescue that they feel drawn to emotionally so donation dollars and volunteer hours are not likely subtracted from one place to add to another. Drilling down to the bottom line here, there may be more animals in rescue BUT, the international causes will draw in their own group of supporters with little effect on existing nationally focused groups.
- The truth is, there is a requirement to have higher standards for health checks at international borders. This is a concern in the sense that ill and afflicted dogs are being brought in as rescues and can potentially spread disease with other animals they come in contact with.
- Removing an animal from a situation saves the dog but may not have any sort of teaching effect on the humans the dog was rescued from. However, there are groups that travel the world with the intent of educating people on the correct and compassionate way to treat animals. Rescue organizations may or may not have an educational component within their structures and, are more likely to be focused on removing animals from life endangering situations. For example, most notably and heart breaking for many of us, teams of rescuers do cross into countries that have booming dog meat trades and intervene on behalf of the animals. Will the rescuers take time to re-educate the local citizens of these countries? Probably not but, there are people working laterally alongside rescues to tackle this issue and abundant other atrocities.
- Definitely a sad reality of animals being rescued, vetted, fostered and adopted is that some families are just not prepared for the addition of an animal into their homes. Regardless of where a dog may come from, it will require love, attention, direction, training, exercise, boundaries and everything else associated with having a new family member in the home. Unfortunately some families are unaware of how to manage simple behavioral challenges or feel overwhelmed by the responsibilities associated with having a dog and take the fastest way out of the situation. If you are among those considering taking a dog in that came from the streets, be they Canadian or somewhere else in this great wide world, it should be clear that an adjustment period is in order. We don't really expect an animal to take in stride being in a life threatening situation, being transported, vetted, fostered and adopted without needing some sort of guidance do we?