Hawker Siddeley HS.141
|HS.141 promotional model in company livery.|
|First flight||Not flown|
The Hawker Siddeley HS.141 was a 1970s design study and submission for a British V/STOL airliner requirement. Designed by Hawker Siddeley Aviation and tested in wind tunnels neither prototypes nor production aircraft were produced.
Design and development
In 1969 the British Transport Aircraft Requirements Committee (TARC) issued a design study "Outline Requirement" (OR) for a 100-seat VTOL airliner capable of a range of 450 miles (725 km). Emphasis was to be on noise reduction by using steep approach and departure profiles, much like those used today at London City Airport. It was thought at the time that money would be better invested on designing new aircraft types than building a third London airport.
Hawker Siddeley investigated various configurations of aircraft, powerplant and control systems including an early proposal using ogival delta wings and twin fins, before submitting their draft design proposal to the TARC in January 1970. At the March 1970 German Aviation Show in Hanover, the first official details were released of the newly named HS.141 project.
The HS.141 design was a jet airliner of all-metal construction with a T-tail and a low-mounted swept wing with a quarter-chord sweepback of 28 degrees. The design featured two wing-mounted "cruise" engines and 16 lift fan engines mounted in sponsons either side of the fuselage (eight per side). The engines under main consideration were the Rolls-Royce RB.220 turbofan for forward propulsion and the Rolls-Royce RB.202, a high bypass ratio lift fan engine using technology developed for the Rolls-Royce RB.162 lift jet. Both engines were themselves design studies by Rolls-Royce and it was feared that there would be delays in their development due to the company's problems at the time. One new engine type also considered for main propulsion was the 'SNECMA M.56', which became the CFM International CFM56. Variations using fewer lift fan engines for STOL operations only were also studied as it was realised that the engines could account for 15% of the total weight of the aircraft and 35% of the final cost.
During the design stage many solutions involving high-lift devices were explored including flaps blown by the "cruise" engines. The flight control system proved the greatest challenge to the design team, systems had to be devised to control the aircraft in slow or hovering flight. This was to be achieved by swivelling the lift engines in their mounts combined with varying the thrust of each engine to provide control in pitch, roll and yaw. The lift engines were said to be a useful safety feature in the event of failure of the main 'cruise' engines. Significant design information was gained from flight trials with the Dornier Do 31 aircraft being developed at the same time in Germany.
The passenger cabin was conventional with five or six seats abreast, luggage and freight was to be loaded in pre-packed pallets and raised up into the lower fuselage using a system similar to the Douglas DC-8.
Extensive wind tunnel testing with 1/10 scale models was carried out.
Intended flight operations
A conventional take-off and landing flight profile was shown to cover a "noise footprint" of 20 square miles (50 km2) in line with an airport's runway when using a limit of 90 decibels, by using an approach path of six degrees (double the normal angle) and a climb out path of 15 degrees the footprint could be reduced to 3 square miles (8 km2). This form of STOL operation was expected to be in place at British city airports by the late 1970s. To reduce the noise footprint further to a circle with a diameter of just 3,000 ft VTOL operations were expected to commence in the early 1980s.
The suggested minimum noise take-off technique for the HS.141 was to use full power from the lift engines in a vertical climb to 250 ft (76 m) then reducing power to 83% to continue this climb to 1,000 ft (300 m). At this height the aircraft would transition into forward flight using vectored thrust from the lift engines and then accelerate and climb to 2,000 ft (600 m) using increasing thrust from the cruise engines. By this stage the aircraft would have reached an airspeed of 168 knots (310 km/h) and would be fully supported by its wings alone, the lift engines being shut down and covered by hinged doors.
For an approach to a vertical landing the procedure was to be virtually reversed with the approach commencing at 2,000 ft (600 m) and 4 miles (6.4 km) from the landing point.
Despite the work and funds that Hawker Siddeley had expended, the lack of enthusiasm for civil VTOL operations combined with the cancellation of the lift engine development, doomed the project.
- HS.141 "datum aeroplane"
- Basic variant. 102–119 passengers dependent on seat pitch. To have used 16 RB.202 lift fans.
- HS.141 "stretched"
- Fuselage increased in length to 135 ft 2 in (41.2 m) to accommodate up to 150 passengers. To have used 20 RB.202 lift fans.
Specifications (HS.141 'datum aeroplane' as designed)
Data from Air Enthusiast, 1971.
- Crew: Not given
- Capacity: 102 to 119 passengers
- Length: 120 ft 2 in (36.63 m)
- Wingspan: 75 ft (22.86 m)
- Height: 29 ft 10 in (9 m)
- Wing area: 1,060 sq ft (98.47 sq m)
- Empty weight: 110,300 lb (50,031 kg)
- Max. takeoff weight: 134,200 lb (60,872 kg)
- Maximum speed: 435 kts (806 km/h) (Mach 0.92)
- Cruise speed: 375 kts (695 km/h) (Mach 0.85)
- Range: 1,200 miles (1,931 km)
- Aircraft of comparable role, configuration and era
- Related lists
- Swanborough 1971, p. 39.
- Swanborough 1971, p. 40.
- Dorrell, David, ed. "Britain's Aircraft Industry enters the 1970s." Air Pictorial, Volume 32, No. 9, September 1970, p. 308.
- Swanborough 1971, p. 41.
- Swanborough 1971, p. 42.
- Swanborough 1971, p. 43.
- NASA 1972, p. 10.
- NASA TT F14, 619. Latest V/STOL aircraft projects of Hawker Siddeley Aviation – November 1972
- Paul, G. J. Christopher. "Farnborough Report." Air Pictorial, October 1970, p. 351.
- Payne, Richard. Stuck on the Drawing Board: Unbuilt British Commercial Aircraft Since 1945. Stroud, UK: The History Press Ltd, 2004. ISBN 978-0-7524-3172-7.
- Swanborough, Gordon. Air Enthusiast, Volume One. London: Pilot Press, 1971. ISBN 0-385-08171-5.
- West, Richard G. "Fan Lift in VTOL Design". Royal Aeronautical Society (Rotorcraft Section). January 1969.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Hawker Siddeley HS.141.|