While Boswell's impressive volume is more historical and topographical
than Gilpin or Combe, his title reveals the emphasis readers and publishers
placed on the 'views'. The 'pleasing effect' of St. Michael's Mount and
its 'agreeable' situation with its 'pleasant and extensive' 'prospect'
are not archaeologically or strategically significant, but they certainly
make this remote corner of the kingdom worthy of a visit by the discerning
tourist. Most of the descriptions of English sites first appeared in the
London Magazine from 1747 to 1760.
Observations of picturesque beauty
William Gilpin is rightly credited with creating the terminology and
demand for picturesque travel writing. While the interest in awe-inspiring
nature and an appreciation (frequently condescending) of daily country
life can be found in the poems of Thomas Gray and the sentimental novels
of the day, Gilpin is the first to extend these interests to travel accounts.
His analysis of the sources of natural beauty border at times on the comical
('Cows are commonly the most picturesque in the months of April and May,
when the old hair is coming off' ), but his praises of the 'beetling'
mountain, the tremendous precipice and chasm and the winding path establish
the vocabulary of the picturesque and still inform many of our ideas of
the Lake District.
A satiric view
This volume is invaluable for its satiric view of late eighteenth-century
taste in travel. The Rowlandson illustration captures the picturesque
traveller's pretensions to learning that the verse echoes in terms like
'floating mists', 'low'r', 'tremendous'. Combe's iambic tetrameter lines,
with comic double rhymes like 'flout it/about it' and 'disaster/master',
echo the Hudibrastic satire of Samuel Butler a century earlier and jog
the reader along through an amusing series of misadventures.