When our pilot teachers were visiting a school that is a little further along than we are at implementing Customized Learning, a colleague and I got talking about how we (us and our colleagues) had a lot of work to do on instruction if we were going to be successful with our implementation.
Then it hit us that a lot of teachers would say they already do a pretty good job with instruction and would object to being told that we had a lot of work to do on it.
And then I realized that both perspectives were right. We just weren’t talking about the same kind of instruction in each instance.
There are two kinds of instruction.
There is Instruction for Lower Order Thinking and Instruction for Higher Order Thinking.
So, it doesn’t matter if you use Bloom’s Taxonomy, New Bloom’s, Marzano’s Taxonomy, or Webb’s Depth of Knowledge, Instruction for Lower Level Thinking is focused on recall and simple application, and Instruction for Higher Order Thinking is focused on nontrivial application, complex reasoning, and creating.
Our teachers are really pretty good at Instruction for Lower Order Thinking. But we have a lot of work to do on Instruction for Higher Order Thinking.
The distinction, thinking of instruction as two types, doesn’t just help clarify our thinking.
This distinction would actually help us in a couple different ways.
We now could say, “You guys are really good at Instruction for Lower Level Thinking. But now, to do Customized Learning well, we need to help you get better at Instruction for Higher Level Thinking.” The message about getting better at instruction would have always been about support, but could have been taken as criticism of their abilities. Now, we can differentiate between validating their abilities, and identifying a need, and offering support to address that need.
And it helps us think about when should teachers apply each type of instruction.
And it will help teachers think about how the two kinds of instruction are different and which strategies support which type.
And it helps us think about leveraging what kinds of interventions to support teachers.
What would thinking of instruction as two types mean to you and the work you are doing in your school?