Presentation on theme: "Hearing & Deafness (4) Pitch Perception 1. Pitch of pure tones 2. Pitch of complex tones."— Presentation transcript:
Hearing & Deafness (4) Pitch Perception 1. Pitch of pure tones 2. Pitch of complex tones
Pitch of pure tones Place theory Place of maximum in basilar membrane excitation (excitation pattern) - which fibers excited Timing theory Temporal pattern of firing - how are the fibers firing - needs phase locking
Phase Locking of Inner Hair Cells Auditory nerve connected to inner hair cell tends to fire at the same phase of the stimulating waveform.
Phase-locking 2 periods1 period nerve spike
Pure tones: place vs timing Low frequency tones Place & timing High frequency tones Place only 1. Phase locking only for tones below 4 kHz 2. Frequency difference threshold increases rapidly above 4 kHz. 3. Musical pitch becomes absent above 4-5 kHz (top of piano)
Frequency thresholds increase above 4 kHz BCJ Moore (1973) JASA.
Pitch of complex tones: fundamental & harmonics
Helmholtzs place theory Pitch = frequency of fundamental Coded by place of excitation Peaks in excitation highlow
Arguments against Helmholtz 1. Fundamental not necessary for pitch (Seebeck)
Missing fundamental No fundamental but you still hear the pitch at 200 Hz Track 37
Same timbre - different pitch
Distortion: Helmholtz fights back Sound stimulus Middle-ear distortion Produces f2 - f Sound going into cochlea
Against Helmholtz: Masking the fundamental Unmasked complex still has a pitch of 200 Hz Tracks 40-42
amp Against Helmholtz: Enharmonic sounds Middle-ear distortion gives difference tone ( = 200) BUT Pitch heard is actually about 210 Tracks 38-39
Schoutens theory Pitch due to beats of unresolved harmonics Tracks 43-45
Problems with Schoutens theory (1) 1. Resolved harmonics dominant in pitch perception - not unresolved (Plomp) down frequency (Hz) down
Problems with Schouten (2) 1. Musical pitch is weak for complex sounds consisting only of unresolved harmonics 2. Pitch difference harder to hear for unresolved than resolved complexes
Against Schouten (3): Dichotic harmonics Pitch of complex tone still heard with one harmonic to each ear (Houtsma & Goldstein, 1972, JASA) Hz pitch No chance of distortion tones or physical beats
Goldsteins theory Pitch based on resolved harmonics Brain estimates frequencies of resolved harmonics (eg ) - could be by a place mechanism, but more likely through phase- locked timing information near appropriate place. Then finds the best-fitting consecutive harmonic series to those numbers (eg ) -> pitch of 200.5
Two pitch mechanisms ? Goldstein has difficulty with the fact that unresolved harmonics have a pitch at all. So: Goldsteins mechanism could be good as the main pitch mechanism… …with Schoutens being a separate (weaker) mechanism for unresolved harmonics
Schoutens + Goldstein's theories base apex log (ish) frequency resolved unresolved Output of 1600 Hz filterOutput of 200 Hz filter /200s = 5ms /200s = 5ms
input Autocorrelator Meddis, R. & O'Mard, L A unitary model of pitch perception. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 102, JCR Licklider
Some other sounds that give pitch SAM Noise: envelope timing - no spectral –Sinusoidally amplitude modulated noise Rippled noise - envelope timing - spectral –Comb-filter (f(t) + f(t-T)) -> sinusoidal spectrum (high pass to remove resolved spectral structure) the steps from a fountain Chichen Itza Binaural interactions
Huygens repetition pitch Christian Huygens in 1693 noted that the noise produced by a fountain at the chateau of Chantilly de la Cour was reflected by a stone staircase in such a way that it produced a musical tone. He correctly deduced that this was due to the successively longer time intervals taken for the reflections from each step to reach the listener's ear.
Effect of SNHL Wider bandwidths, so fewer resolved harmonics Therefore more reliance on Schouten's mechanism - less musical pitch?
Problem we havent addressed What happens when you have two simultaneous pitches - as with two voices or two instruments - or just two notes on a piano? How do you know which harmonic is from which pitch?
Bach: Musical Offering (strings)
Harmonic Sieve Only consider frequencies that are close enough to harmonic. Useful as front-end to a Goldstein-type model of pitch perception. Duifhuis, Willems & Sluyter JASA (1982). frequency (Hz) Hz sieve spacing 0 blocked
Mistuned harmonics contribution to pitch declines as Gaussian function of mistuning Experimental evidence from mistuning expts: Moore, Glasberg & Peters JASA (1985). Darwin (1992). In M. E. H. Schouten (Ed). The auditory processing of speech: from sounds to words Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter frequency (Hz) Match low pitch F 0 (Hz) Frequency of mistuned harmonic f (Hz) F o = a - k f exp(-f 2 / 2 s 2 ) s = 19.9 k = 0.073
Is harmonic sieve necessary with autocorrelation models? Autocorrelation could in principle explain mistuning effect – mistuned harmonic initially shifts autocorrelation peak –then produces its own peak But the numbers do not work out. –Meddis & Hewitt model is too tolerant of mistuning.