Overdosing many of the ammonia removing products on the market will actually inhibit the nitrifying bacteria from growing and becoming established in the new tank. So in reality, by adding more and more ammonia remover to the aquaria, you are actually doing more harm than good and delaying the establishment of your bio-filter.
The best way to use an ammonia-removing product is to follow the dosing directions – don’t just pour “some” into the tank, as this can lead to overdosing. Use the product when you first set up the tank, and if you see an increasing amount of ammonia in the water, it is better to do a partial water change than to pour more and more ammonia remover in the water.
Also, if you decided not to add a culture of living nitrifying bacteria to your system when you started, it is not good to add the bacteria later when there is already a high concentration of ammonia in the water. The best way forward is to change some of the water to get the ammonia concentration down below 2 mg/L-N (2 ppm-N), and then add the bacteria, but do not add more ammonia remover.
Why do ammonia removers inhibit the nitrifying bacteria? There are two major reasons for this and both may apply to your aquarium.
First, many ammonia removers are acids, so repeatedly adding them to the aquarium water will cause the pH to drop. This in turn means that the ammonia is in the ionized form (NH4+), which is the form the nitrifying bacteria CANNOT use. So the amount of ammonia converted to nitrite is less per day than if the pH were higher.
Second, some of the products have a chemical in them that inhibits the bacteria when the chemical is in a higher concentration, which occurs when the product is overdosed.
If your newly set-up tank is having problems cycling, consider how much ammonia remover you have been using; you may be overdosing and need to cut back.
DrTim’s Aquatics AquaCleanse is safe to use with our One & Only Live Nitrifying Bacteria.
In conclusion, using an ammonia remover can be a benefit when first setting up your aquarium, but relying on it to control ammonia during the start-up cycle, instead of water changes or using a live nitrifying bacteria mix, can be a mistake.