  The creative industry is both concerned and enthusiastic about how generative
AI will reshape creativity. How might these tools interact with the workflow
values of creative artists? In this paper, we adopt a value-sensitive design
framework to examine how generative AI, particularly Photoshop's Generative
Fill (GF), helps or hinders creative professionals' values. We obtained 566
unique posts about GF from online forums for creative professionals who use
Photoshop in their current work practices. We conducted reflexive thematic
analysis focusing on usefulness, ease of use, and user values. Users found GF
useful in doing touch-ups, expanding images, and generating composite images.
GF helped users' values of productivity by making work efficient but created a
value tension around creativity: it helped reduce barriers to creativity but
hindered distinguishing 'human' from algorithmic art. Furthermore, GF hindered
lived experiences shaping creativity and hindered the honed prideful skills of
creative work.
