  An \emph{odd $c$-coloring} of a graph is a proper $c$-coloring such that each
non-isolated vertex has a color appearing an odd number of times in its open
neighborhood. A \emph{proper conflict-free $c$-coloring} of a graph is a proper
$c$-coloring such that each non-isolated vertex has a color appearing exactly
once on its neighborhood. Clearly, every proper conflict-free $c$-coloring is
an odd $c$-coloring. Cranston conjectured that every graph $G$ with
$\text{mad}(G) < \frac{4c}{c+2}$ has an odd $c$-coloring for $c \geq 4$, and
proved the conjecture for $c\in\{5, 6\}$. Note that the bound $\frac{4c}{c+2}$
is best possible. Cho et al. solved Cranston's conjecture for $c \geq 5$, and
strengthened the result from odd $c$-coloring to proper conflict-free
$c$-coloring, but they did not give all the extremal non-colorable graphs $G$
with $\text{mad}(G) = \frac{4c}{c+2}$. The extremal problem is of interest. In
this paper, we give a characterization of all the non-proper conflict-free
$c$-colorable graphs $G$ with $\text{mad}(G) = \frac{4c}{c+2}$.
  For $c=4$, Cranston's conjecture is not true since a graph whose every block
is a $5$-cycle is a counterexample. Cho et al. proved that a graph $G$ with
$\text{mad}(G) < \frac{22}{9}$ and no induced $5$-cycles has an odd
$4$-coloring, we improve this result by proving that a graph $G$ with
$\text{mad}(G) \leq \frac{22}{9}$ (equality is allowed) is not odd
$4$-colorable if and only if $G$ belongs to a special class of graphs. On the
other hand, Cho et al. proved that a planar graph with girth at least $5$ has
an odd $6$-coloring, we improve it by proving that a planar graph without
$4^{-}$-cycles adjacent to $7^{-}$-cycles has an odd $6$-coloring.
