  We use smoothed-particle hydrodynamics to examine differences between direct
collisions of single stars and binary star mergers in their roles as possible
blue straggler star formation mechanisms. We find in all cases that core helium
in the progenitor stars is largely retained in the core of the remnant, almost
independent of the type of interaction or the central concentration of the
progenitor stars.
  We have also modelled the subsequent evolution of the hydrostatic remnants,
including mass loss and energy input from the hydrodynamical interaction. The
combination of the hydrodynamical and hydrostatic models enables us to predict
that little mixing will occur during the merger of two globular cluster stars
of equal mass. In contrast to the results of Proctor Sills, Bailyn, & Demarque
(1995), we find that neither completely mixed nor unmixed models can match the
absolute colors of observed blue stragglers in NGC 6397 at all luminosity
levels. We also find that the color distribution is probably the crucial test
for explanations of BSS formation - if stellar collisions or mergers are the
correct mechanisms, a large fraction of the lifetime of the straggler must be
spent away from the main sequence. This constraint appears to rule out the
possibility of completely mixed models. For NGC 6397, unmixed models predict
blue straggler lifetimes ranging from about 0.1 to 4 Gyr, while completely
mixed models predict a range from about 0.6 to 4 Gyr.
