  Recently Strohmayer and Mahmoodifar presented evidence for a coherent
oscillation in the X-ray light curve of the accreting millisecond pulsar XTE
J1751-305, using data taken by RXTE during the 2002 outburst of this source.
They noted that a possible explanation includes the excitation of a non-radial
oscillation mode of the neutron star, either in the form of a g-mode or an
r-mode. The r-mode interpretation has connections with proposed spin-evolution
scenarios for systems such as XTE J1751-305. Here we examine in detail this
interesting possible interpretation. Using the ratio of the observed
oscillation frequency to the star's spin frequency, we derive an approximate
neutron star mass-radius relation which yields reasonable values for the mass
over the range of expected stellar radius (as constrained by observations of
radius-expansion burst sources). However, we argue that the large mode
amplitude suggested by the Strohmayer and Mahmoodifar analysis would inevitably
lead to a large spin-down of the star, inconsistent with its observed spin
evolution, regardless of whether the r-mode itself is in a stable or unstable
regime. We therefore conclude that the r-mode interpretation of the observed
oscillation is not consistent with our current understanding of neutron star
dynamics and must be considered unlikely. Finally we note that, subject to the
availability of a sufficiently accurate timing model, a direct
gravitational-wave search may be able to confirm or reject an r-mode
interpretation unambiguously, should such an event, with a similar inferred
mode amplitude, recur during the Advanced detector era.
