  In functional programming, datatypes a la carte provide a convenient modular
representation of recursive datatypes, based on their initial algebra
semantics. Unfortunately it is highly challenging to implement this technique
in proof assistants that are based on type theory, like Coq. The reason is that
it involves type definitions, such as those of type-level fixpoint operators,
that are not strictly positive. The known work-around of impredicative
encodings is problematic, insofar as it impedes conventional inductive
reasoning. Weak induction principles can be used instead, but they considerably
complicate proofs.
  This paper proposes a novel and simpler technique to reason inductively about
impredicative encodings, based on Mendler-style induction. This technique
involves dispensing with dependent induction, ensuring that datatypes can be
lifted to predicates and relying on relational formulations. A case study on
proving subject reduction for structural operational semantics illustrates that
the approach enables modular proofs, and that these proofs are essentially
similar to conventional ones.
