  The recent discovery at the LHC by the CMS and ATLAS collaborations of the
Higgs boson presents, at long last, direct probes of the mechanism for
electroweak symmetry breaking. While it is clear from the observations that the
new particle plays some role in this process, it is not yet apparent whether
the couplings and widths of the observed particle match those predicted by the
Standard Model. In this paper, we perform a global fit of the Higgs results
from the LHC and Tevatron. While these results could be subject to
as-yet-unknown systematics, we find that the data are significantly better fit
by a Higgs with a suppressed width to gluon-gluon and an enhanced width to
gamma gamma, relative to the predictions of the Standard Model. After
considering a variety of new physics scenarios which could potenially modify
these widths, we find that the most promising possibility is the addition of a
new colored, charged particle, with a large coupling to the Higgs. Of
particular interest is a light, and highly mixed, stop, which we show can
provide the required alterations to the combination of gg and gamma gamma
widths.
