  The Misner initial value solution for two momentarily stationary black holes
has been the focus of much numerical study. We report here analytic results for
an astrophysically similar initial solution, that of Brill and Lindquist (BL).
Results are given from perturbation theory for initially close holes and are
compared with available numerical results. A comparison is made of the
radiation generated from the BL and the Misner initial values, and the physical
meaning is discussed.
