  Recent work on quantum annealing has emphasized the role of collective
behavior in solving optimization problems. By enabling transitions of clusters
of variables, such solvers are able to navigate their state space and locate
solutions more efficiently despite having only local connections between
elements. However, collective behavior is not exclusive to quantum annealers,
and classical solvers that display collective dynamics should also possess an
advantage in navigating a non-convex landscape. Here, we give evidence that a
benchmark derived from quantum annealing studies is solvable in polynomial time
using digital memcomputing machines, which utilize a collection of dynamical
components with memory to represent the structure of the underlying
optimization problem. To illustrate the role of memory and clarify the
structure of these solvers we propose a simple model of these machines that
demonstrates the emergence of long-range order. This model, when applied to
finding the ground state of the Ising frustrated-loop benchmarks, undergoes a
transient phase of avalanches which can span the entire lattice and
demonstrates a connection between long-range behavior and their probability of
success. These results establish the advantages of computational approaches
based on collective dynamics of continuous dynamical systems.
