  The melting of Al clusters in the size range 49 <= N <= 62 has been studied
using two model interatomic potentials. The results for the two models are
significantly different. The glue potential exhibits a smooth relatively
featureless heat capacity curve for all sizes except for N = 54 and N = 55,
sizes at which icosahedral structures are favoured over the polytetrahedral.
Gupta heat capacity curves, instead, show a well-defined peak that is
indicative of a first-order-like transition. The differences between the two
models reflect the different ground-state structures, and neither potential is
able to reproduce or explain the size dependence of the melting transition
recently observed in experiments.
