  We analyze the current status of three P-wave baryon states $N(1710){1/
2}^+$, $N(1900){3/2}^+$, and $\Delta(1600){3/2}^+$ as given in the Review of
Particles Physics (RPP). Since the evidence for a particle's existence is
linked to its RPP "star" rating, we discuss its subjective present definition.
We also present the accumulating evidence supporting these states and give our
new "star" rating recommendations.
