  Numerical simulations of fluids in astrophysics and computational fluid
dynamics (CFD) are among the most computationally-demanding calculations, in
terms of sustained floating-point operations per second, or FLOP/s. It is
expected that these numerical simulations will significantly benefit from the
future Exascale computing infrastructures, that will perform 10^18 FLOP/s. The
performance of the SPH codes is, in general, adversely impacted by several
factors, such as multiple time-stepping, long-range interactions, and/or
boundary conditions. In this work an extensive study of three SPH
implementations SPHYNX, ChaNGa, and XXX is performed, to gain insights and to
expose any limitations and characteristics of the codes. These codes are the
starting point of an interdisciplinary co-design project, SPH-EXA, for the
development of an Exascale-ready SPH mini-app. We implemented a rotating square
patch as a joint test simulation for the three SPH codes and analyzed their
performance on a modern HPC system, Piz Daint. The performance profiling and
scalability analysis conducted on the three parent codes allowed to expose
their performance issues, such as load imbalance, both in MPI and OpenMP.
Two-level load balancing has been successfully applied to SPHYNX to overcome
its load imbalance. The performance analysis shapes and drives the design of
the SPH-EXA mini-app towards the use of efficient parallelization methods,
fault-tolerance mechanisms, and load balancing approaches.
