  We show that a wide class of tree-level scattering amplitudes involving
scalars, gauge bosons, and gravitons, up to three of which may be massive, can
be expressed in terms of a Cachazo-He-Yuan representation as a sum over
solutions of the scattering equations. These amplitudes, when expressed in
terms of the appropriate kinematic invariants, are independent of the masses
and therefore identical to the corresponding massless amplitudes.
