  This paper reports on the state of the art in underground SLAM by discussing
different SLAM strategies and results across six teams that participated in the
three-year-long SubT competition. In particular, the paper has four main goals.
First, we review the algorithms, architectures, and systems adopted by the
teams; particular emphasis is put on lidar-centric SLAM solutions (the go-to
approach for virtually all teams in the competition), heterogeneous multi-robot
operation (including both aerial and ground robots), and real-world underground
operation (from the presence of obscurants to the need to handle tight
computational constraints). We do not shy away from discussing the dirty
details behind the different SubT SLAM systems, which are often omitted from
technical papers. Second, we discuss the maturity of the field by highlighting
what is possible with the current SLAM systems and what we believe is within
reach with some good systems engineering. Third, we outline what we believe are
fundamental open problems, that are likely to require further research to break
through. Finally, we provide a list of open-source SLAM implementations and
datasets that have been produced during the SubT challenge and related efforts,
and constitute a useful resource for researchers and practitioners.
