  We consider the flavor structure of supersymmetric theories that can account
for the deviation of the observed time-dependent CP asymmetry in B --> phi K_S
from the standard model prediction. Assuming simple flavor symmetries and
effective field theory, we investigate possible correlations between sizable
supersymmetric contributions to b --> s transitions and to flavor changing
processes that are more tightly constrained. With relatively few assumptions,
we determine the properties of minimal Yukawa and soft mass textures that are
compatible with the desired supersymmetric flavor-changing effect and
constraints. We then present explicit models that are designed (at least
approximately) to realize these textures. In particular, we present an Abelian
model based on a single U(1) factor and a non-trivial extra-dimensional
topography that can explain the CP asymmetry in B --> phi K_S, while
suppressing other supersymmetric flavor changing effects through a high degree
of squark-quark alignment.
