Capacity for exercise inherited?
Working on mice in the lab, they found that activity level can be
enhanced with "selective breeding" - the process of breeding plants and
animals for particular genetic traits. Their experiments showed that
mice that were bred to be high runners produced high-running offspring,
indicating that the offspring had inherited the trait for activity.
"Our findings have implications for human health," said Theodore Garland Jr., a professor of biology,
whose laboratory conducted the multi-year research. "Down the road
people could be treated pharmacologically for low activity levels
through drugs that targeted specific genes that promote activity.
Pharmacological interventions in the future could make it more
pleasurable for people to engage in voluntary exercise. Such
interventions could also make it less comfortable for people to sit
still for long periods of time."
In humans, activity levels vary widely from couch-potato-style inactivity to highly active athletic endeavors.
"We have a huge epidemic of obesity in Western society, and yet we have
little understanding of what determines variation among individuals for
voluntary exercise levels," Garland said.
The researchers began their experiments in 1993 with 224 mice whose
levels of genetic variation bore similarity to those seen in wild mouse
populations. The researchers randomly divided the base population of
mice into eight separate lines - four lines bred for high levels of
daily running, with the remaining four used as controls - and measured
how much distance the mice voluntarily ran per day on wheels attached to
With a thousand mice born every generation and four generations of mice
each year, the researchers were able to breed highly active mice in the
four high-runner lines by selecting the highest running males and
females from every generation to be the parents of the next generation.
In the control lines, breeders were chosen with no selection imposed,
meaning that the mice either changed or did not change over time purely
as a result of random genetic drift.
By studying the differences among the replicate lines, the researchers
found that mice in the four high-runner lines ran 2.5-3-fold more
revolutions per day as compared with mice in the four control lines.
They also found that female and male mice evolved differently: females
increased their daily running distance almost entirely by speed; males,
on the other hand, increased speed but they also ran more minutes per
The study is an example of an "experimental evolution" approach applied
rigorously to a problem of biomedical relevance. Although this approach
is common with microbial systems and fruit flies, it has rarely been
applied to vertebrates due to their longer generation times and greater
costs of maintenance. The results of such studies can inform biologists
about fundamental evolutionary processes as well as "how organisms
work" in a way that may lead to new therapeutic strategies.
"This study of experimental evolution confirms some previous
observations and raises new questions," said Douglas Futuyma, a
distinguished professor of ecology and evolution at Stony Brook
University, New York, who was not involved in the research. "It shows
that ‘there are many ways to skin a cat': different ways in which a
species may evolve a similar adaptive characteristic - running activity,
in this case. Garland and coauthors go further by beginning to explore
the detailed ways in which an adaptive feature, such as muscle size or
metabolic rate, may be realized and by showing sex differences in the
response to selection. It would be fascinating to know, and challenging
to find out, if any one of these different responses is adaptively
better than others."
Garland was joined in the research by Scott Kelly, Jessica Malisch, Erik
Kolb, Robert Hannon, Brooke Keeney, Shana Van Cleave and Kevin
Middleton, all of whom work in his lab.
The study was supported primarily by a grant to Garland from the National Science Foundation.
Details of the experimental set-up
The mice run on wheels attached to their cages. Wheel running is a
completely voluntary behavior for the mice. They can sit in their cages
and not run at all. If they do run, they can get off the wheels at any
time. For the experiments, each mouse was given access to the wheels
for only six days of their lives. A computer recorded every minute how
much distance (revolutions) the mice ran for the six days. The
researchers selected breeders depending on how much distance the mice
ran on days 5 and 6.