---
abstract: 'In this note it is shown that for a mono-energetic collection of Bosons, at a certain (non-zero) momentum or temperature, there is condensation while there is another momentum or temperature at which there is infinite dilution and below which the gas exhibits anamolous Fermionic behaviour.'
author:
- |
    B.G. Sidharth\
    Centre for Applicable Mathematics & Computer Sciences\
    B.M. Birla Science Centre, Adarsh Nagar, Hyderabad - 500 463\
    India
title: A NOTE ON DEGENERATE AND ANAMOLOUS BOSONS
---

We start with the well known formula for the occupation number in a Bose gas[@Huang]: $$\langle n_p\rangle = \frac{1}{z^{-1}e^{\beta \epsilon_p} -1}\label{e1}$$ where $$\beta \equiv  1/kT.$$ We also define, $$z' \equiv \lambda^3/v \equiv zb, \lambda =
\left({\frac{2\pi \hbar^2}{mkT}}\right)^{1/2}$$

When $\epsilon_p = 0, z=1$, we have from (\[e1\]), $\langle n_0\rangle =
\infty$. This is the Bose-Einstein condensation.

Let us now consider a mono-energetic collection of Bosons: $$\langle{n_p}' \rangle = \langle n_p\rangle \delta(p-p_0)\label{e2},$$ so that $$kT \approx \epsilon_{p_0} = \frac{p_0^2}{2m}, \quad
\lambda = (4\pi)^{1/2} \frac{\hbar}{p_0},\quad \beta \epsilon_{p_0} \approx
1\label{e3}$$ From (\[e2\]) we get, $$N = \frac{V}{\hbar^3} \int_0^\infty 4\pi p^2dp\delta
(p-p_0)\langle n_p\rangle,\label{e4}$$ where $N$ is the total number of particles and $V$ is the total volume. Using (\[e1\]) and (\[e3\]) in (\[e4\]) we get, $$1 = \frac{4\pi v p_0^2}{\hbar^3} \langle n_{p_0}\rangle =
\left[{\frac{(4\pi )^{5/2}}{p_0}}\right]
\frac{v}{\lambda^3} \left[{\frac{1}{z^{-1} e-1}}\right]$$ so that we have $$z'^{-1} \left[{\frac{(4\pi )^{5/2}}{p_0}- eb}\right] = -1\label{e5}$$ We can see from (\[e5\]) that if $$p_0 \approx \frac{(4\pi )^{5/2}}{eb-1}\label{e6}$$ (or at the corresponding temperature) then $z'\approx 1$. But this is the condition for condensation: Remembering that $\lambda$ is of the order of the particles’ deBroglie wave length and $v$ is the average volume per particle, this means that the gas gets very densely packed. On the other hand, if $$p_0 \approx \frac{(4\pi )^{5/2}}{eb}\label{e7}$$ then as can be seen from (\[e5\]) $z' \approx 0$. In this case we have the opposite effect: The gas becomes very dilute. Finally, if $$p_0 <\frac{(4\pi )^{5/2}}{eb},\label{e8}$$ then equation (\[e5\]) leads to a contradiction: We require that $z' <0$, which is not possible.

The contradiction disappears if we realize that for momenta given by (\[e8\]) or for the corresponding temperatures the Bosons effectively behave like Fermions. In this case, the average occupation number is given, instead of (\[e1\]), by, $$\langle n_p\rangle = \frac{1}{z^{-1}e^{\beta \epsilon_p}+1}$$ and instead of (\[e5\]) we have, $$z'^{-1} \left[{\frac{(4\pi)^{5/2}}{p_0}- eb}\right] = +1$$ and condition(\[e8\]) poses no problem. We now characterize $b$, which we have defined above in $z'=zb$. It is known that (cf.ref.[@Huang]), $$z'\left[{1 - \frac{\langle n_0\rangle}{N}}\right] = g_{3/2}(z)$$, where $\langle n_0\rangle$ is the occupation number for energy or momentum $=0$. As we are dealing with a mono-energetic Bose gas with non-zero energy (i.e. at non-zero temperature), we have, $$\frac{\langle n_0\rangle}{N} \approx 0,$$ so that, $$z' \equiv zb \approx g_{3/2}(z) = z\left[{1+\frac{z}{2^{3/2}}+
\frac{z^2}{3^{3/2}}+\ldots}\right] \quad (0 \le z \le 1)\label{e9}$$ It easily follows that (cf.ref[@Huang]), $$1 < b < 2.6$$. Infact if $z<<1$, we have from (\[e9\]), $$b \approx 1\label{e10}$$ This is the case (\[e7\]) where $z'$ and consequently $z$ are $\approx 0$. So (\[e7\]) now becomes, $$p_0 \approx \frac{(4\pi)^{5/2}}{e}\label{e11}$$ Coming now to the inequality (\[e8\]), we observe that for Fermions, we have instead of (\[e9\]), (cf.ref.[@Huang]), $$z'\equiv zb = f_{3/2}(z) = z - \frac{z^2}{2^{3/2}}+
\frac{z^3}{3^{3/2}}\label{e12}$$ If now the inequality (\[e8\]) is nearly an equality, as we can choose, then, as in the case of (\[e7\]), we will have, $z'\approx 0$ so that $z \approx 0$ also and from (\[e12\]) we can see that $b$ satisfies (\[e10\]). So the inequality (\[e8\]) becomes, $$p_0 < \frac{(4\pi)^{5/2}}{e}\label{e13}$$ We finally come to the case of condensation given by (\[e6\]). Here, from (\[e9\]) it follows that $$g_{3/2}(z) \approx 1,$$ which gives, $$z \approx 0.7, b\approx 1.4.$$ Inserting this value of $b$ in (\[e6\]), we get, $$p_0 \approx \frac{(4\pi)^{5/2}}{1.4e{-1}}\label{e14}$$ To sum up, for a collection of mono-energetic Bosons, ([*i*]{}) at the momentum given by (\[e14\]) we have condensation; ([*ii*]{}) at the momentum given by (\[e11\]) we have infinite dilution; ([*iii*]{}) for momenta given by (\[e13\]) we have anamolous Fermionic behaviour.

[99]{} K. Huang, “Statistical Mechanics”, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1975.
