Punishing Renters

Keith Hennessey doesn't believe the Obama administration should use tax dollars to subsidize underwater homeowners with fixed rate mortgages. He highlights a program that would help homeowners with mortgage balances up to $729,750. An illustration of his point:

Imagine twin brothers, each with $180K
of annual income. One rents, and the other has a $700,000 mortgage on
a home that declined from $800,000 in value to $600,000 in value. Both
brothers lose their jobs. Why should the renter pay higher taxes to
subsidize his brother’s mortgage payments?

Losing a home due to financial hardship is tragic. Does that make it someone else’s responsibility?

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.