Forget the Colton and Tia drama — the most exciting thing about the upcoming season of Bachelor in Paradise is the arrival of Grocery Store Joe, a.k.a. the extremely adorable guy from Chicago who got sent home night one on Becca’s season of The Bachelorette. We loved his less-than-chatty charm at the Men Tell All, and now we’ve got an exclusive first look at Joe’s arrival in Paradise. “Hopefully this stint in Paradise will last longer than your stint on The Bachelorette,” says host Chris Harrison to Joe, before offering this heartfelt advice: “Don’t screw this up this time!”