user
Instruction
This is a table fact verification task. The goal of this task is to distinguish whether the given statement is entailed or refuted by the given table.


Table
Table Title: crew of the rms titanic
Table Content:
| name | class | hometown | boarded | position |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| andrews , mr thomas | first | belfast , ireland | belfast | shipbuilder |
| campbell , mr william henry | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | joiner |
| chisholm , mr roderick robert crispin | first | belfast , ireland | belfast | draughtsman |
| cunningham , mr alfred fleming | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | fitter |
| frost , mr anthony wood artie | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | fitter |
| knight , mr robert j | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | fitter |
| parkes , mr francis frank | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | plumber |
| parr , mr william henry marsh | first | belfast , ireland | belfast | electrician |
| watson , mr ennis hastings | second | belfast , ireland | belfast | electrician 's apprentice |


Statement
andrew , mr thomas , chisholm , mr roderick robert crispin , parr , mr william henry marsh all board second class from belfast


Answer Format
The final answer should be either "entailed" or "refuted" and use the following format:
```json
{
    "answer": "entailed" or "refuted"
}
```
rule
["refuted"]