user
Instruction
This is a table fact verification task. The goal of this task is to distinguish whether the given statement is entailed or refuted by the given table.


Table
Table Title: 2008 japanese motorcycle grand prix
Table Content:
| rider | manufacturer | laps | time | grid |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| valentino rossi | yamaha | 24 | 43:09.599 | 4 |
| casey stoner | ducati | 24 | + 1.943 | 2 |
| dani pedrosa | honda | 24 | + 4.866 | 5 |
| jorge lorenzo | yamaha | 24 | + 6.165 | 1 |
| nicky hayden | honda | 24 | + 24.593 | 3 |
| loris capirossi | suzuki | 24 | + 25.685 | 6 |
| colin edwards | yamaha | 24 | + 25.918 | 7 |
| shinya nakano | honda | 24 | + 26.003 | 9 |
| andrea dovizioso | honda | 24 | + 26.219 | 13 |
| john hopkins | kawasaki | 24 | + 37.131 | 11 |
| james toseland | yamaha | 24 | + 37.574 | 10 |
| randy de puniet | honda | 24 | + 38.020 | 8 |
| marco melandri | ducati | 24 | + 39.768 | 16 |
| sylvain guintoli | ducati | 24 | + 45.846 | 15 |
| anthony west | kawasaki | 24 | + 55.748 | 17 |
| toni elias | ducati | 24 | + 59.320 | 14 |
| alex de angelis | honda | 24 | + 1:12.398 | 18 |
| chris vermeulen | suzuki | 16 | retirement | 12 |
| kousuke akiyoshi | suzuki | 0 | accident | 19 |


Statement
anthony west begin in grid 17 and finish the race with a time less than colin edward


Answer Format
The final answer should be either "entailed" or "refuted" and use the following format:
```json
{
    "answer": "entailed" or "refuted"
}
```
rule
["refuted"]