user
Instruction
This is a table fact verification task. The goal of this task is to distinguish whether the given statement is entailed or refuted by the given table.


Table
Table Title: 2009 bradford bulls season
Table Content:
| player | position | weight & height | previous club | contracted until |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| michael platt | full back | 93 kg , 6 ft 2 in | castleford tigers | 2011 |
| rikki sheriffe | right wing | 14 st , 6 ft | harlequins rl | 2010 |
| paul sykes | right centre | 92 kg , 5 ft 10 in | harlequins rl | 2010 |
| chris nero | left centre | 15 st , 6 ft 1 in | huddersfield giants | 2010 |
| semi tadulala | left wing | 14 st , 6 ft | wakefield trinity wildcats | 2009 |
| ben jeffries | stand off | 14 st , 5 ft 9 in | wakefield trinity wildcats | 2009 |
| paul deacon (c) | scrum half | 80 kg , 5 ft 9 in | oldham roughyeds | 2010 |
| sam burgess | prop | 114 kg , 6 ft 4 in | bradford bulls | 2009 |
| terry newton | hooker | 98 kg , 5 ft 10 in | wigan warriors | 2009 |
| andy lynch | prop | 108 kg , 6 ft 2 in | castleford tigers | 2012 |
| steve menzies | second row | 98 kg , 6 ft 3 in | manly sea eagles | 2011 |
| glenn morrison | second row | 97 kg , 6 ft | parramatta eels | 2009 |
| jamie langley | loose forward | 108 kg , 6 ft 2 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| wayne godwin | hooker | 13 st , 5 ft 6 in | hull | 2011 |
| matt cook | second row | 95 kg , 6 ft | bradford bulls | 2009 |
| michael worrincy | second row | 98 kg , 6 ft 1 in | harlequins rl | 2010 |
| nick scruton | prop | 106 kg , 6 ft | leeds rhinos | 2011 |
| craig kopczak | prop | 98 kg , 6 ft 4 in | bradford bulls | 2009 |
| dave halley | right wing | 78 kg , 5 ft 9 in | bradford bulls | 2011 |
| matt james | prop | 100 kg , 6 ft 3 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| jason crookes | right centre | 83 kg , 5 ft | bradford bulls | 2011 |
| julien rinaldi | scrum half / hooker | 13 st , 5 ft | sunshine sea eagles | 2009 |
| richard johnson | left centre | 87 kg 5 ft 11 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| steve crossley | prop | 104 kg , 6 ft 2 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| david solomona | second row | 108 kg , 6 ft | wakefield trinity wildcats | 2009 |
| kieran hyde | full back | 85 kg , 5 ft 11 in | bradford bulls | 2011 |
| elliott whitehead | second row | 93 kg , 6 ft | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| tom olbison | centre | 96 kg , 6 ft 1 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| james donaldson | second row | 87 kg , 5 ft 10 in | bradford bulls | 2010 |
| andy tate | right centre | 85 kg , 6 ft 3 in | bradford bulls | 2011 |
| duane straugheir | right centre | 90 kg , 6 ft | bradford bulls | 2009 |


Statement
andy tate be the shortest player on the bradford bull


Answer Format
The final answer should be either "entailed" or "refuted" and use the following format:
```json
{
    "answer": "entailed" or "refuted"
}
```
rule
["refuted"]