user
Instruction
This is a table fact verification task. The goal of this task is to distinguish whether the given statement is entailed or refuted by the given table.


Table
Table Title: papal election , december 1187
Table Content:
| elector | place of birth | cardinalatial title | elevated | elevator |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| paolo scolari | rome | bishop of palestrina | september 21 , 1179 | alexander iii |
| thibaud , osbcluny | france | bishop of ostia e velletri | 1184 | lucius iii |
| laborante de panormo | pontormo | priest of s maria in trastevere | september 1173 | alexander iii |
| melior le maitre , osbvall | pisa | priest of ss giovanni e paolo | march 16 , 1185 | lucius iii |
| giacinto bobone orsini | rome | deacon of s maria in cosmedin | december 22 , 1144 | lucius ii |
| graziano da pisa | pisa | deacon of ss cosma e damiano | march 4 , 1178 | alexander iii |
| ottaviano di paoli | rome | deacon of ss sergio e bacco | december 18 , 1182 | lucius iii |
| pietro diana | piacenza | deacon of s nicola in carcere | march 16 , 1185 | lucius iii |
| radulf nigellus | probably france | deacon of s giorgio in velabro | march 16 , 1185 | lucius iii |


Statement
melior le maitre , osbvall , pietro diana and radulf nigellus be elevate on march 16 , 1185


Answer Format
The final answer should be either "entailed" or "refuted" and use the following format:
```json
{
    "answer": "entailed" or "refuted"
}
```
rule
["entailed"]