<p>I have panel data for counts of new firms in different regions for six years. I am estimating a static poisson regression with multiplicative fixed effects$^*$; I have also tried to estimate a dynamic model by introducing a lagged dependent variable, but could not make that latter model work. Now, I would like to test the residuals from the static model for autocorrelation, so that I have an idea of the importance of the dynamics. However, I cannot find any diagnostic tests for this in a textbook (I've looked at Wooldridge, Cameron &amp; Trivedi, Winkelmann, Greene), and also have not seen such a test in a research paper. Since the individual effects in the model are not identified, I don't know how to compute meaningful residuals in the first place.</p>

<p>Does anyone 1) know how to compute meaningful residuals; and 2) know of any diagnostic tests for these panel fixed effect poisson models?</p>

<p>FYI: I am using Stata (version 12.1) -xtpoisson, fe vce(robust)- command for the static model. Stata's postestimation commands can compute predicted values etc, but only assuming that the individual effects are all zero.</p>

<p>$^*$ The cross-section (or pooled) Poisson regression models the expected number of counts $y$ as $E[y_i|x_i]=\exp(X_i\beta)$, with $\beta$ the coefficients and $X_i$ the variables. A common way to add individual fixed effects with panel data is to let the effects $\alpha_{i}$ enter the model multiplicatively: $E[y_{it}|X_{it},\alpha_i]=\alpha_i\exp(X_{it}\beta)$.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2015-07-28T16:46:40.247Z
This is indeed a rather unexplored issue - even for non-panel data (for which they exist mostly negative results, like that portmanteau tests for autocorrelation need at least some adjustment to operate in a Poisson framework). I will gather some literature, but it is sparse and in many cases confined in manuscripts, technical reports, etc.
Alecos Papadopoulos
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-10-25T00:10:58.433Z
Maybe Cross validated can help you better? https://stats.stackexchange.com/ (for people revisiting this thread - i guess by now you found the answer already)
JoaoBotelho
<econometrics><fixed-effects>
How can I test for autoregressive residual terms in a fixed effects panel Poisson model?
Matthijs
# How can I test for autoregressive residual terms in a fixed effects panel Poisson model?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2015-07-24)

I have panel data for counts of new firms in different regions for six years. I am estimating a static poisson regression with multiplicative fixed effects$^\*$; I have also tried to estimate a dynamic model by introducing a lagged dependent variable, but could not make that latter model work. Now, I would like to test the residuals from the static model for autocorrelation, so that I have an idea of the importance of the dynamics. However, I cannot find any diagnostic tests for this in a textbook (I've looked at Wooldridge, Cameron & Trivedi, Winkelmann, Greene), and also have not seen such a test in a research paper. Since the individual effects in the model are not identified, I don't know how to compute meaningful residuals in the first place.

Does anyone 1) know how to compute meaningful residuals; and 2) know of any diagnostic tests for these panel fixed effect poisson models?

FYI: I am using Stata (version 12.1) -xtpoisson, fe vce(robust)- command for the static model. Stata's postestimation commands can compute predicted values etc, but only assuming that the individual effects are all zero.

$^\*$ The cross-section (or pooled) Poisson regression models the expected number of counts $y$ as $E[y\_i|x\_i]=\exp(X\_i\beta)$, with $\beta$ the coefficients and $X\_i$ the variables. A common way to add individual fixed effects with panel data is to let the effects $\alpha\_{i}$ enter the model multiplicatively: $E[y\_{it}|X\_{it},\alpha\_i]=\alpha\_i\exp(X\_{it}\beta)$.

**Tags:** econometrics, fixed-effects

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: This is indeed a rather unexplored issue - even for non-panel data (for which they exist mostly negative results, like that portmanteau tests for autocorrelation need at least some adjustment to operate in a Poisson framework). I will gather some literature, but it is sparse and in many cases confined in manuscripts, technical reports, etc.  
> **username_2**: Maybe Cross validated can help you better? https://stats.stackexchange.com/ (for people revisiting this thread - i guess by now you found the answer already)  

---

## 0 answers

