<p>In short, yes offline basecalling is supported.</p>

<p>Oxford nanopore has made available an official offline basecaller, called albacore. If you have an account to the nanpore community website you can download it from <a href="https://community.nanoporetech.com/downloads" rel="noreferrer">here</a>.</p>

<p>Concerning running it in the field, last time I checked live basecalling was still requiring a lot of computing power, so you might want to run the MinION in the field, but basecall once back a your lab / computing facility.</p>

<p>I'm not aware of any plans to sue the third-party basecallers, I think Oxford Nanopore is pretty positive about them :-) </p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-05-31T11:04:44.187Z
Running the MinION in the field and base-calling back in the lab defeats the whole (well, part of) the purpose: namely, to get results instantaneously.
Konrad Rudolph
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-05-31T11:12:09.440Z
True in some cases, but sometimes you want to sequence samples in remote areas / places where it'd be impractical / impossible to go back to a lab with good quality DNA samples (i.e difficult access to dry ice for transport). The MinION makes it possible to sequence in the field, then analyse back in the lab.

EDIT: Also, for small sequencing run you can probably basecall with a good laptop (8+ cpus)
H. Gourlé
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-05-31T07:09:09.510Z
2017-05-31T07:09:09.510Z
H. Gourlé
<p>Short answer: yes, but you need to get permission (and modified software) from ONT before doing that.</p>

<p>... but that doesn't tell the whole story. This question has the potential to be very confusing, and that's through no fault of the questioner. The issue is that for the MinION, sequencing (or more specifically, generating the raw data in the form of an electrical signal trace) is distinct and separable from base calling. Many other sequencers also have distinct raw data and base-calling phases, but they're not democratised to the degree they are on the MinION.</p>

<p>The "sequencing" part of MinION sequencing is carried out by ONT software, namely MinKNOW. As explained to me during PoreCampAU 2017, when the MinION is initially plugged into a computer it is missing the firmware necessary to carry out the sequencing. The most recent version of this firmware is usually downloaded at the start of a sequencing run by sending a request to ONT servers. In the usual case, you can't do sequencing without being able to access those servers, and you can't do sequencing without ONT knowing about it. However, ONT acknowledge that there are people out there who won't have Internet access when sequencing (e.g. sequencing Ebola in Africa, or metagenomic sequencing in the middle of the ocean), and an email to <code>&lt;support@nanoporetech.com&gt;</code> with reasons is likely to result in a quick software fix to the local sequencing problem.</p>

<p>Once the raw signals are acquired, the "base-calling" part of MinION sequencing can be done anywhere. The ONT-maintained basecaller is Albacore, and this will get the first model updates whenever the sequencing technology is changed (which happens a lot). Albacore is a local basecaller which can be obtained from ONT by browsing through their community pages (available to anyone who has a MinION); ONT switched to only allowing people to do basecalling locally in about April 2017, after establishing that using AWS servers was just too expensive. Albacore is open source and free-as-in-beer, but has a restrictive licensing agreement which limits the distribution (and modification) of the program. However, Albacore is not the only available basecaller. ONT provide a FOSS basecaller called <a href="https://github.com/nanoporetech/nanonet" rel="nofollow noreferrer">nanonet</a>. It's a little bit behind Albacore on technology, but ONT have said that all useful Albacore changes will eventually propagate through to nanonet. There is another non-ONT basecaller that I'm aware of which uses a neural network for basecalling: <a href="https://bitbucket.org/vboza/deepnano" rel="nofollow noreferrer">deepnano</a>. Other basecallers exist, each varying distances away technology-wise, and I expect that more will appear in the future as the technology stabilises and more change-resistant computer scientists get in on the act.</p>

<p>Edit: ONT has just pulled back the curtain on their basecalling software; all the repositories that I've looked at so far (except for the Cliveome) have been released under the Mozilla Public License (free and open source, with some conditions and limitations). Included in <a href="https://github.com/nanoporetech/" rel="nofollow noreferrer">that software repository</a> is Scrappie, which is their testing / bleeding-edge version of Albacore.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-05-31T11:09:16.597Z
2017-06-07T22:47:06.100Z
2017-06-07T22:47:06.100Z
gringer
<p>I vaguely remember, that the original plan of Oxford Nanopore was to provide cheap sequencers (MinION), but charge for base-calling. For that reason the base-calling was performed in the cloud, and the plan was to make it commercial once the technology is established.</p>

<p>Of course, this limits the potential uses of MinION in the field, since huge areas do not have decent internet connection. Also, not all the data can be legally transferred to a third-party company in the clinical studies.</p>

<p>For example for the <a href="https://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature16996" rel="nofollow noreferrer">Ebola paper</a>, they had to create a special version of their software:</p>

<blockquote>
  <p>An offline-capable version of MinKNOW, with internet ‘ping’ disabled
  and online updates disabled was made available to us by Oxford
  Nanopore Technologies specifically for the project</p>
</blockquote>

<p>There are couple of third-party base-callers available today. I am aware of <a href="https://nanoporetech.com/publications/nanocall-open-source-basecaller-oxford-nanopore-sequencing-data" rel="nofollow noreferrer">Nanocall</a> and <a href="https://nanoporetech.com/publications/deepnano-deep-recurrent-neural-networks-base-calling-minion-nanopore-reads" rel="nofollow noreferrer">DeepNano</a>, but since they are not official, it can be hard for them to keep-up with the latest versions of sequencers and cells.</p>

<ol>
<li>Is it possible as of today to sequence offline without a special arrangement (like the Ebola one).</li>
<li>If not, what's the policy of Oxford Nanopore toward third-party base-callers? Are they going to help them, or to sue them eventually?</li>
</ol>

<ngs><minion>
Is it possible to perform MinION sequencing offline?
# Is it possible to perform MinION sequencing offline?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2017-05-31)

I vaguely remember, that the original plan of Oxford Nanopore was to provide cheap sequencers (MinION), but charge for base-calling. For that reason the base-calling was performed in the cloud, and the plan was to make it commercial once the technology is established.

Of course, this limits the potential uses of MinION in the field, since huge areas do not have decent internet connection. Also, not all the data can be legally transferred to a third-party company in the clinical studies.

For example for the [Ebola paper](https://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature16996), they had to create a special version of their software:

> An offline-capable version of MinKNOW, with internet ‘ping’ disabled
> and online updates disabled was made available to us by Oxford
> Nanopore Technologies specifically for the project

There are couple of third-party base-callers available today. I am aware of [Nanocall](https://nanoporetech.com/publications/nanocall-open-source-basecaller-oxford-nanopore-sequencing-data) and [DeepNano](https://nanoporetech.com/publications/deepnano-deep-recurrent-neural-networks-base-calling-minion-nanopore-reads), but since they are not official, it can be hard for them to keep-up with the latest versions of sequencers and cells.

1. Is it possible as of today to sequence offline without a special arrangement (like the Ebola one).
2. If not, what's the policy of Oxford Nanopore toward third-party base-callers? Are they going to help them, or to sue them eventually?

**Tags:** ngs, minion

---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_3 on 2017-05-31. Score: 8 | Accepted answer

Short answer: yes, but you need to get permission (and modified software) from ONT before doing that.

... but that doesn't tell the whole story. This question has the potential to be very confusing, and that's through no fault of the questioner. The issue is that for the MinION, sequencing (or more specifically, generating the raw data in the form of an electrical signal trace) is distinct and separable from base calling. Many other sequencers also have distinct raw data and base-calling phases, but they're not democratised to the degree they are on the MinION.

The "sequencing" part of MinION sequencing is carried out by ONT software, namely MinKNOW. As explained to me during PoreCampAU 2017, when the MinION is initially plugged into a computer it is missing the firmware necessary to carry out the sequencing. The most recent version of this firmware is usually downloaded at the start of a sequencing run by sending a request to ONT servers. In the usual case, you can't do sequencing without being able to access those servers, and you can't do sequencing without ONT knowing about it. However, ONT acknowledge that there are people out there who won't have Internet access when sequencing (e.g. sequencing Ebola in Africa, or metagenomic sequencing in the middle of the ocean), and an email to  with reasons is likely to result in a quick software fix to the local sequencing problem.

Once the raw signals are acquired, the "base-calling" part of MinION sequencing can be done anywhere. The ONT-maintained basecaller is Albacore, and this will get the first model updates whenever the sequencing technology is changed (which happens a lot). Albacore is a local basecaller which can be obtained from ONT by browsing through their community pages (available to anyone who has a MinION); ONT switched to only allowing people to do basecalling locally in about April 2017, after establishing that using AWS servers was just too expensive. Albacore is open source and free-as-in-beer, but has a restrictive licensing agreement which limits the distribution (and modification) of the program. However, Albacore is not the only available basecaller. ONT provide a FOSS basecaller called [nanonet](https://github.com/nanoporetech/nanonet). It's a little bit behind Albacore on technology, but ONT have said that all useful Albacore changes will eventually propagate through to nanonet. There is another non-ONT basecaller that I'm aware of which uses a neural network for basecalling: [deepnano](https://bitbucket.org/vboza/deepnano). Other basecallers exist, each varying distances away technology-wise, and I expect that more will appear in the future as the technology stabilises and more change-resistant computer scientists get in on the act.

Edit: ONT has just pulled back the curtain on their basecalling software; all the repositories that I've looked at so far (except for the Cliveome) have been released under the Mozilla Public License (free and open source, with some conditions and limitations). Included in [that software repository](https://github.com/nanoporetech/) is Scrappie, which is their testing / bleeding-edge version of Albacore.


---

### Answer by username_1 on 2017-05-31. Score: 5

In short, yes offline basecalling is supported.

Oxford nanopore has made available an official offline basecaller, called albacore. If you have an account to the nanpore community website you can download it from [here](https://community.nanoporetech.com/downloads).

Concerning running it in the field, last time I checked live basecalling was still requiring a lot of computing power, so you might want to run the MinION in the field, but basecall once back a your lab / computing facility.

I'm not aware of any plans to sue the third-party basecallers, I think Oxford Nanopore is pretty positive about them :-)

> **Comments:**
> **username_2**: Running the MinION in the field and base-calling back in the lab defeats the whole (well, part of) the purpose: namely, to get results instantaneously.  
> **username_1**: True in some cases, but sometimes you want to sequence samples in remote areas / places where it'd be impractical / impossible to go back to a lab with good quality DNA samples (i.e difficult access to dry ice for transport). The MinION makes it possible to sequence in the field, then analyse back in the lab.  EDIT: Also, for small sequencing run you can probably basecall with a good laptop (8+ cpus)  

---

