<p>First, to clear things up, it isn't up to the exchange to quote a certain price/rate. It's all up to the users of that exchange what they ask/bid for a bitcoin. For example there are two exchanges, X and Y, with both have an ask one 500 USD and a bid on 400 USD. Then person A bids a higher price, lets say 470 (instead of 400), on exchange X. Person B asks a lower price, 430 (instead of 500), but he is one exchange Y, so their offers are never matched by the exchange itself. You however, are smarter. If you buy that coin (lets assume they both offer/ask a whole coin) from B, and sell it to A, you made a $40 profit (minus fees). Caching! Of course, these numbers are not plausible anymore. Think in cents/btc.</p>

<p>The discrepancy on different exchanges can indeed be the results of the effects you name. A few months ago, you could buy 'MtGox bitcoin', with a lower price then normal bitcoin. You weren't sure however that you could return that coin in the future.</p>

<p>But to answer your question, this arbitrage process can be completely automised and therefor fast as hell. There is no handwork involved anymore (just depositing/withdrawing USD/EUR). It is not very difficult to program (I half did it, without any knowledge in php or good programming skills), so there are a lot of scripts running, trying to make a small profit. Every ask/bid that has an arbitrage option is closed within tenths of a second. You cannot do it by hand. If you have made a script by yourself, you can get lucky if you import the data and execute your order at the right time. </p>

<p>edit: you can take a look at <a href="https://www.cryptocoincharts.info/v2/arbitrage" rel="nofollow">this site</a>, they list options of arbitrage.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-06-25T21:52:38.173Z
If you understood arbitrage, I'm sorry that I explained it again. You seem to understand the cause of it, but the explanation about the exchanges quoting the price needed a clarification in my opinion. You then can skip the first to paragraphs :)
Mathias711
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-06-25T21:45:56.360Z
2014-06-25T21:45:56.360Z
Mathias711
<p>There are several bitcoin exchanges which trade bitcoins to $US and also several other markets which trade bitcoin for other currencies.  Each exchange however quotes a different price in effective $US for a bitcoin.  </p>

<p>This discrepancy may be a result of differing fees at exchanges, and risks associated with each exchange and so on, but temporary discrepancies may also be a result of market inefficiencies and arbitrage opportunities.</p>

<p>How efficient are bitcoin markets currently (including both $US dollar markets and other currencies), and how quickly are potential arbitrage opportunities eliminated?</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-06-25T22:50:53.427Z
Do I know you from another site? Can you by any chance guide me to the bitcoin exchanges you use? http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/26954/is-there-a-us-broker-for-bitcoins
Tom Au
CC BY-SA 3.0
2014-06-26T05:38:09.053Z
@TomAu, yes you probably know me from Earth Sciences proposal.  I am Geodude there, and I used to have the highest reputation.  The exchanges I was referring to are the ones listed at https://bitcoinwisdom.com/, which lists exchanges for US (e.g. Bitstamp, BTC-e), CYN (e.g. OK Coin, Huobi), EUR, CAD, RUR etc.
Kenshin
<economic-theory><market><arbitrage>
How efficient are bitcoin markets?
Kenshin
# How efficient are bitcoin markets?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2014-06-25)

There are several bitcoin exchanges which trade bitcoins to $US and also several other markets which trade bitcoin for other currencies. Each exchange however quotes a different price in effective $US for a bitcoin.

This discrepancy may be a result of differing fees at exchanges, and risks associated with each exchange and so on, but temporary discrepancies may also be a result of market inefficiencies and arbitrage opportunities.

How efficient are bitcoin markets currently (including both $US dollar markets and other currencies), and how quickly are potential arbitrage opportunities eliminated?

**Tags:** economic-theory, market, arbitrage

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Do I know you from another site? Can you by any chance guide me to the bitcoin exchanges you use? http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/questions/26954/is-there-a-us-broker-for-bitcoins  
> **username_0**: @username_1, yes you probably know me from Earth Sciences proposal.  I am Geodude there, and I used to have the highest reputation.  The exchanges I was referring to are the ones listed at https://bitcoinwisdom.com/, which lists exchanges for US (e.g. Bitstamp, BTC-e), CYN (e.g. OK Coin, Huobi), EUR, CAD, RUR etc.  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_2 on 2014-06-25. Score: 3 | Accepted answer

First, to clear things up, it isn't up to the exchange to quote a certain price/rate. It's all up to the users of that exchange what they ask/bid for a bitcoin. For example there are two exchanges, X and Y, with both have an ask one 500 USD and a bid on 400 USD. Then person A bids a higher price, lets say 470 (instead of 400), on exchange X. Person B asks a lower price, 430 (instead of 500), but he is one exchange Y, so their offers are never matched by the exchange itself. You however, are smarter. If you buy that coin (lets assume they both offer/ask a whole coin) from B, and sell it to A, you made a $40 profit (minus fees). Caching! Of course, these numbers are not plausible anymore. Think in cents/btc.

The discrepancy on different exchanges can indeed be the results of the effects you name. A few months ago, you could buy 'MtGox bitcoin', with a lower price then normal bitcoin. You weren't sure however that you could return that coin in the future.

But to answer your question, this arbitrage process can be completely automised and therefor fast as hell. There is no handwork involved anymore (just depositing/withdrawing USD/EUR). It is not very difficult to program (I half did it, without any knowledge in php or good programming skills), so there are a lot of scripts running, trying to make a small profit. Every ask/bid that has an arbitrage option is closed within tenths of a second. You cannot do it by hand. If you have made a script by yourself, you can get lucky if you import the data and execute your order at the right time.

edit: you can take a look at [this site](https://www.cryptocoincharts.info/v2/arbitrage), they list options of arbitrage.

> **Comments:**
> **username_2**: If you understood arbitrage, I'm sorry that I explained it again. You seem to understand the cause of it, but the explanation about the exchanges quoting the price needed a clarification in my opinion. You then can skip the first to paragraphs :)  

---

