Empire Center Sues Cuomo Administration for Withholding Nursing Home COVID Data
The Empire Center today filed a lawsuit against the state Department of Health (DOH) after DOH refused to release records showing the full count of coronavirus deaths among nursing home residents, including those that occurred after patients were transferred to hospitals.
The Empire Center submitted a Freedom of Information Law request to DOH in August for data collected daily by the Department from nursing home operators. The records, which track the deaths of nursing home residents regardless of where death occurs, are needed to determine how many nursing home residents have perished from the novel coronavirus since it arrived in New York last winter.
The lawsuit, filed in state Supreme Court in Albany County, seeks the release of Health Emergency Response Data System (HERDS) data regularly submitted to DOH by facilities throughout the state. DOH through HERDS collects daily numbers of confirmed and presumed COVID deaths that take place inside and outside nursing homes and assisted care facilities.
DOH has been undercounting COVID-19's impact on New York's nursing home residents by excluding those who succumbed to the virus outside the facilities, including after being admitted to a hospital. The Department notified the Empire Center this month that it was still conducting a "diligent search" for the requested records—despite public comments by state Health Commissioner Howard Zucker indicating the data were readily available—and requested more time.
After the Empire Center appealed, the Department still refused to share the records and Wednesday said the records "need to be located and then reviewed," to consider the records' "responsiveness, accuracy, legal privileges, and applicable FOIL exemptions" before letting the public see them. The records in question are numbers supplied by facilities via electronic questionnaire that DOH partially publishes on its website, specifically excluding deaths that occurred outside nursing homes.
"The novel coronavirus caught New York unprepared and hit the state more severely than almost anywhere in the world," said Bill Hammond, the Empire Center's senior fellow for health policy. "This case isn't about assigning blame or embarrassing political leaders. It's about gaining a full and accurate understanding of what happened, which is crucial to improving our defenses against the next pandemic."
"There's no excuse for refusing to release these records immediately," said Tim Hoefer, president of the Empire Center. "The Health Department should have released them on its own months ago, given how serious this issue is. The Freedom of Information Law was written specifically to let New Yorkers see what their government is doing without having to hire a lawyer and file a lawsuit. It should never take a lawsuit to get the government to obey it."
The Empire Center, based in Albany, is an independent, not-for-profit, non-partisan think tank dedicated to promoting policies that can make New York a better place to live, work and raise a family.
Tags: Coronavirus Covid-19 Nursing homes NYPandemicResponse
Statement on the release of new COVID-19 Death Toll data
The Cuomo administration left out many people who died without a test during the early weeks of the pandemic	Read More
An Open Letter to Lt. Gov. Kathy Hochul
As an organization committed to openness in government, we welcome your commitment to leading a fully transparent administration	Read More
Empire Center Appeals COVID FOIL Request Delays
Empire Center has appealed four delayed Freedom of Information Law requests pertaining to state COVID-19 data	Read More
Three of 62 Requested COVID Data Sets Made Available through FOIL
Just three COVID data sets have been made fully available in the month since the Empire Center officially submitted 62 FOIL requests	Read More
Empire Center Recognized for Exposing NY Nursing Home Coverup
In recognition of the importance of government transparency, the Empire Center has been selected as a finalist for the for its role in exposing the coverup of thousands of COVID-related deaths among New York's elderly population. In the thick of the	Read More
Arbeeny Family and Empire Center Partner to Promote Open Government
The family of Norman Arbeeny has made a generous donation to the Empire Center to bring more openness and transparency to New York State government.	Read More
Empire Center Demands Dozens of Coronavirus Data Sets from the NYS DOH
The Empire Center filed 62 Freedom of Information Law requests for coronavirus-related records from the Department of Health.	Read More
A Shadowy Non-Profit that Employs One-Fifth of the New York State Health Department Claims To Be Exempt from FOIL
In another blow to transparency in Albany, a non-profit group closely tied to the state Health Department is refusing to publicly disclose its payroll records under the Freedom of Information Law. (HRI) has funct	Read More