Campbell Name Removed from Award
Posted on August 27, 2019 by Mike Glyer
The Astounding Award for Best New Writer is the new title of the award formerly named for John W. Campbell, Jr. Analog editor Trevor Quachri announced the change today in a "Statement from the editor" at The Astounding Analog Companion blog.
The decision came quickly in the wake of Jeannette Ng's acceptance speech criticizing the award's namesake as a fascist, and widespread social media discussion.
Quachri echoed those criticisms in explaining the name change:
…However, Campbell's provocative editorials and opinions on race, slavery, and other matters often reflected positions that went beyond just the mores of his time and are today at odds with modern values, including those held by the award's many nominees, winners, and supporters.
As we move into Analog's 90th anniversary year, our goal is to keep the award as vital and distinguished as ever, so after much consideration, we have decided to change the award's name to The Astounding Award for Best New Writer.
…Though Campbell's impact on the field is undeniable, we hope that the conversation going forward is nuanced. George Santayana's proverbial phrase remains as true today as when it was coined: "Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it." We neither want to paper over the flaws of those who have come before us, nor reduce them to caricatures. But we have reached a point where the conversation around the award is in danger of focusing more on its namesake than the writers it was intended to recognize and elevate, and that is something nobody—even Campbell himself—would want.
The award has been given at the Worldcon since 1973, and Quachri says the nomination and selection process will remain the same. "It is also important to note that this change in no way reflects on past winners or their work, and they continue to stand deserving of recognition."
Jeannette Ng's initial response is:
I am not the only one who has spoke up about this over the years. There have been petitions, letters and opinion columns before me. I stand on the shoulders of giants and I fear I am be stealing all their thunder in this. https://t.co/QYsEe22tsN
— Jeannette Ng ??? (@jeannette_ng) August 27, 2019
One person pointed out that the Campbell Award by name is part of the WSFS Constitution and fears parliamentary foot-dragging, or worse, however the award is not a Hugo and a willing Worldcon committee could certainly implement the change.
[Thanks to Mark Hepworth, Hampus Eckerman, ULTRAGOTHA and Paul Weimer for the story.]
This entry was posted in Awards and tagged Jeannette Ng, John W. Campbell Award for Best New Writer, The Astounding Award for Best New Writer, Trevor Quachri by Mike Glyer. Bookmark the permalink.
53 thoughts on "Campbell Name Removed from Award"
Pingback: Pixel Scroll 8/28/19 I've Scrolled Through The File On A Pixel With No Name | File 770
Lis Carey on August 28, 2019 at 6:01 pm said:
@bill–
As I tried to say earlier, the Worldcon can administer, including conducting nominations and the tallying of votes, any award it pleases by using a separate ballot from the Hugo ballot.
It's the same Campbell Award the Worldcon has been administering for decades. It just has a new name now, something that is totally within the purview of Dell Magazines. As others have noted, as far as WSFS is concerned, this will be purely a technical fix, not something requiring a two-year amendment process with an unwieldy separate ballot in the meantime.
I realize this may be a disappointment for you, but them's the breaks.
Chip Hitchcock on August 28, 2019 at 7:35 pm said:
@Andrew: the Penfield device? A newfangled contrivance. Consider
Martel was angry. He did not even adjust his blood away from anger.