Best of North Coast
Copyright © 2020, Rancho Santa Fe Review | CA Notice of Collection
RSF Association to discuss Village Church's plans for columbarium
The Village Church's plan for a columbarium in their prayer garden.
(Courtesy)
By Karen BillingStaff Writer
The Village Church is hoping to add a columbarium to its prayer garden, a walled memorial garden with niches that hold remains. The church's plans are in question as the use of a columbarium is prohibited by the Rancho Santa Fe Association Protective Covenant.
The proposed project is on the docket for discussion at the Association board's Jan. 9 meeting at 9:30 a.m. at the Rancho Santa Fe Golf Club and the church is hopeful that the community will voice support for its effort.
In his 21 years at the Village Church, Rev. Dr. Jack Baca said the columbarium has always been a part of the plans to expand and improve the church facilities.
As it was not allowed by the Covenant, a columbarium was pushed to the side when they built the new sanctuary 10 years ago but they had a perfect space in mind in their memorial garden. Set between the sanctuary and fellowship hall, the existing courtyard would be enhanced with a gated entrance and a step stone walkway leading into the niched walls. The garden would also feature a wood slat bench and a water feature.
"We feel like now is the right time to address this question with the Association and the larger community," Baca said. "There is no visual impact from the outside…the privacy of the garden itself is important for people to have a quiet space where they can go and remember their loved ones."
The Village Church submitted its proposal to the Art Jury in mid-October.
"This was such a minimal development that they considered it just a landscape project," Baca said. "The prayer garden already exists, and there were just minor modifications to the existing interior space. The Art Jury had no comments with the conceptual plan."
The Art Jury remanded the whole application to the Association board due to the prohibition of columbarium developments. The Association board discussed the project at its Dec. 5 board meeting with President Rick Sapp holding a hard line and asserting that the board does not have the power to change the language of the Covenant and it would require a community-wide vote. A Covenant modification requires two-thirds approval and one hasn't been approved since the 1970s—if approved by the board, the project vote would go out in May with the election of the Association board candidates.
Director Steve Dunn noted that its "historically impossible" to do a Covenant modification because the Association does not even get close to 75 percent of membership to vote on anything. Dunn has spoken with the Association's attorney and he believes that boards do have a right to interpret the Covenant and to modify the intent without requiring a Covenant modification, if the decision recognizes that with time the original intent is no longer meaningful and is in the best interest of the Covenant.
"I believe a lot of people in our Covenant realize what the Village Church means to this community," Dunn said. "It's a church that's very much the heart of our community."
If the question does go to the ballot, Dunn said he believes that there could be overwhelming support, even if they do not get the required two-thirds to vote.
Dunn noted that three members of the board, including himself, are members of the Village Church and he does not know how they will handle conflict of interest. He hopes that there will be strong support from the community at the Jan. 9 meeting.
Article 1 of the Protective Covenant, which was recorded in February 1928, prohibits properties being used for a cemetery, columbarium or crematory. According to the church's submission to the Art Jury, at that time, cemeteries usually included the construction of a large building which held the ashes of deceased persons who did not want to be buried in the ground. Those buildings were called columbariums, which is a term that came from Latin meaning "pigeon house."
Article 1 also references the prohibition of uses of any building for the manufacture of gun powder, explosives or any by-product of kelp, fish meal, fish oil or fertilizer or for conducting a slaughterhouse or tannery, or institutions for the care of persons afflicted with tuberculosis or the care of "victims of drink or drugs."
"I have to believe the restrictions put in the CC and R's were because they did not want large, obvious cemeteries or buildings which is what a columbarium used to be," Baca said. "That is not at all what we envision this to be."
Many local churches now have columbariums, including the Church of the Nativity on El Apajo (outside of the Covenant). As Baca noted, burial practices have changed with the times—there are not many cemeteries in San Diego and cremation has increased with California being one of the leading states for cremation.
Due to the scarcity and cost of land in California, cremation is a respectful and more ecologically sound way of dealing with human remains, Baca said, and there are emotional and religious overtones to people wanting their final resting place to be nearer to a place dedicated to worship and community service.
"We see a memorial garden as an extension and as a continuation of our ministry here, not only to our members but it's an added value to the greater community with zero downside," Baca said.
Baca said he is hopeful that the community and the Association will see their project as a valuable addition and will allow the church to move forward.
Get the RSF Review weekly in your inbox
Karen Billing
Become a press patron
At a time when local news is more important than ever, support from our readers is essential. If you are able to, please support the Rancho Santa Fe Review today.
RSF Association considers Village Church's plans for columbarium
The Village Community Presbyterian Church hopes to move ahead with its plans to build a columbarium, a memorial garden with niches to keep human cremains, a use that is currently prohibited by the Rancho Santa Fe Association's Protective Covenant.
D-Day documentary screening at Rowe School on Jan. 25 to benefit Honor Flight
Solana Santa Fe students win calendar contest with clean air artwork
Two Solana Santa Fe students were selected out of nearly 500 submissions from kindergarten through high school students in San Diego County to have their artwork featured in the County Air Pollution Control District's 2020 calendar.
Race aiming for 20 customer installations a week in January
Rancho Santa Fe Connect installations are ramping up in the month of January, providing gigabit internet service to Covenant homeowners.
Rowe 7th grade team garners first place alliance trophy at FIRST Tech Challenge Robotics League meet
During the second FIRST Tech Challenge meet of the season, held Jan. 11 at R.
Two measures could decide future of rural San Diego County growth
Measures A & B on March ballot deal with housing development in county's unincorporated areas
Hergesheimer re-elected San Dieguito board president in her last term
The San Dieguito Union High School District board elected officers at its Dec. 17 meeting as two long-time board members stated that this would be their last year in office.
D-Day paratrooper to be featured at Jan. 25 screening in Rancho Santa Fe
Honor Flight San Diego and Normandy Jump 2019 will present a special screening of "Libertas," the first in a series of three documentaries commemorating the 75th anniversary of D-Day on Saturday, Jan. 25 at 11 a.m. at the R.
Statue of Lilian Rice planned for Rancho Santa Fe village
This year the Rancho Santa Fe Historical Society plans to erect a monument to one of California's first female architects, the woman who designed the Rancho Santa Fe village and nearly 100 structures almost 100 years ago.
New year, new laws: REAL ID to be enforced in California and other new regulations for 2020
With 2020 at the starting gate, the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) is reminding Californians of the upcoming federal enforcement date for REAL ID. Starting Oct. 1, 2020, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security will require a valid passport or other federally approved document, like a REAL ID driver license or identification card, to board flights within the United States and access secure federal facilities and military bases.
Torrey Pines basketball player overcomes bone cancer
Falcons junior Nick Herrmann spent 70 days in the hospital and it was feared he might lose his leg
'The Great Leap' brings jumpshots, high emotion to Cygnet Theatre in San Diego, Jan. 22-Feb. 16
"The Great Leap," a basketball-centric play, is coming to Old Town San Diego's Cygnet Theatre Jan. 22, 2020. Written by multi-award-winner Lauren Yee, it was one of the 10 most-produced plays in the United States in 2019, along with her "Cambodian Rock Band," recently staged at La Jolla Playhouse. "The Great Leap," which premiered in Denver in 2018, is about an American basketball team going to China for an exhibition game. There's more than a game at stake; there are long-buried personal histories, a clash of dreams and ambitions, and the main setting is Beijing in 1989, when student protesters were about to be massacred in Tienanmen Square. With all this going on, there's still plenty of humor — one of the playwright's conspicuous gifts.
'Abandoned San Diego' author to speak at RSF Library Jan. 25
Author Jessica Johnson will appear at the Rancho Santa Fe Library Saturday, Jan. 25, at 2 p.m. to talk about "Abandoned San Diego," her book about fascinating — and some hidden — places in San Diego.
'5K Paw Walk in the Garden' to be held Feb. 15
Benefit event presented by Rancho Coastal Humane Society and San Diego Botanic Garden
Event briefs: Jan. 16
Comedy 'Men Are From Mars – Women Are From Venus LIVE!'
RSF E-Edition