East Devon Watch
Accountability, Affordable and Social Housing, Air pollution, Austerity cuts, Climate crisis, Conflict of interest, EDDC, Knowle/Honiton/Exmouth relocation, Mark Williams CEO EDDC, Scrutiny, Spin, Sustainability, Transparency
EDDC: "Relocation cost, No Deal Brexit, electric charging points and climate change motions rejected from being discussed"
Owl says: remember, the Chief executive, Mark Williams, is supposed to be a NEUTRAL civil servant and yet ALL of the refused motions are from ALL the minority groups ONLY……!
"Motions to support recycling, to call for a new property ombudsman to streamline complaints against shoddy builders, and for East Devon to get its fair share of the police precept rise will be discussed at next Wednesday's full council meeting.
But motions over the full relocation costs of the move from Sidmouth to Honiton, to put electric charging points in all car parks, what to prioritise in a 'No Deal' Brexit and on climate change will not be discussed.
Various motions that councillors had put forward for debate at East Devon District Council's full council meeting on Wednesday, February, were rejected by the council's chief executive, as either the agenda already provides the opportunity for debate or the wording of the motions were inaccurate.
Cllr Cathy Gardner had proposed a motion calling for the council to commit to publish an annual 'summary of accounts' for the relocation project until break-even is reached as relocation from Sidmouth to Honiton was proposed and predicated on the basis that the project would breakeven within 20 years and deliver cost-savings to the council tax payers of East Devon.
Cllr Gardner said: "Whilst some of this information is already available we feel it is vital for the ongoing costs to be published to show confidence that this project will breakeven. A majority of Councillors voted for relocation on the basis that money would be saved on energy bills. We are left unsure of whether breakeven will ever be proven."
But an EDDC spokesman said: "The rejected motion contained inaccuracies and omissions that had the potential to mislead councillors and it was also premature. It is however proposed to bring a report to the next meeting of the Cabinet that will summarise the position reached with regard to the sale of the Knowle and the relocation. Cllr Gardner can raise the matters she is concerned about as part of the debate into that report."
The motion would have called for the accounts to include
energy costs for the Knowle for the past 20 years (for comparison);
energy costs for both Blackdown House and Exmouth Town Hall per year;
the capital receipt for the sale of the Knowle;
a Red Book valuation of Blackdown House as of 1 March 2019;
the full costs for the relocation project since its inception, including: project management; removal, furnishing and equipment;
staff retraining and travel expenses;
new-build costs for Blackdown House; refurbishment costs for Exmouth Town Hall; and any other associated costs."
Cllr Matthew Booth's motion had called for the council to recognise that Climate Change and Global Warming are the key issues of our time, to acknowledge the strong concerns of young people in particular the recent walk out of school children and for the council to commit to introducing a policy of carbon measurement and reduction within all aspects of its own activity.
He said: "I personally do not care how we begin to do this, or who does it, but that we act now not wait for some planned strategy in the future."
An EDDC spokesman said that the issue of climate change emergency is acknowledged to be of critical importance but that it would be appropriate to wait to see what Devon County Council decides. They added: "Currently, however, the County Council is considering its position and will shortly debate the matter. As we are in a two tier area it is appropriate for the District Council to assess the position taken by the upper tier authority and then respond accordingly. The public would expect us to work in partnership with the County Council rather than unilaterally."
Cllr Eleanor Rylance had submitted a motion calling for the council to plan for and implement over the next five years a full rolling renovation programme of its car parks estates to fit and bring into operation electrical charging points at every space for domestic cars, and cycle parks with charging points for all types of cycle and that there should be mandatory EV charging points for the parking spaces of every new-built house in East Devon.
She added: "This council should approach the future of electrically-powered domestic vehicles with enthusiasm and proactivity, play a positive role in helping develop the use of electrical and should make this infrastructure, that will be a necessity within the next ten years, available in advance of full electrification of domestic vehicles in 2042.
But an EDDC spokesman said: ""The agenda already provides an opportunity for this issue to be raised so this motion was inappropriate."
Cllr Rylance had also submitted a motion that said in the event of a No Deal Brexit or a version of Brexit that causes significant disruption, the council should approach this event as a situation of emergency in respect of its most vulnerable residents, dedicating any available human, material and financial resources required to palliate any negative outcomes for these groups, but the motion was rejected.
Talking about all the motions, a council spokesman said: "The council agenda for February contains the most important annual decision, namely the setting of the budget and the approval of the Council Tax for the forthcoming year. The process leading to this meeting has included several meetings where members were encouraged to raise all items of future relevance so these could be assessed as part of our service planning process and for assessment as part of the budget.
"It is unfortunate that some members did not take these opportunities and have chosen instead to submit their proposed motions.
"It is also noted that the wording of the motions was not checked in advance with relevant officers who would have been able to give timely advice as to their wording."
But motions on the police precept, protection for new home owners and supporting recycling will be discussed.
Cllr Tom Wright's motion says: "In view of the £24 per band D property increase in policing precept, this council urges the Chief Constable to recognise the needs of East Devon when deciding how to allocate extra resources. East Devon residents are the biggest contributors to the police budget in Devon, other than Plymouth. It is only fair that we should get a fair share of the larger cake."
Cllr Douglas Hull's motion says: "The Government has stated that it would therefore be introducing as a priority a new property ombudsman to streamline complaints against shoddy builders. As a council that not only provides an excellent and highly regarded building control service but also has seen significant levels of new building in its district, we call on the government to fulfil its pledge to provide this much needed remedy for homeowners as a matter of the highest priority."
Cllr Peter Burrows' motion says: "This Council continues to support the fine work done by the EDDC Recycling team in achieving the best results in Devon and to support and encourage local Organisations and voluntary groups who are involved in trying to reduce the amount of single use plastics used in their communities & beaches by making resources and expertise available, where appropriate. The order of priority should be – Reduce, Reuse, Recycle. To actively help promote such activities through the Councils social media platforms."
The full council meeting will be held at East Devon District Council's new Honiton Heathpark HQ on February 27 at 6pm."
https://www.devonlive.com/news/devon-news/relocation-cost-no-deal-brexit-2557565
← "Flybe or Flybmi? Airline reassures passengers after rival goes into administration"
"Housing developer forced to scrap 'misleading' ads targeting first-time buyers" →
3 thoughts on "EDDC: "Relocation cost, No Deal Brexit, electric charging points and climate change motions rejected from being discussed""
mpellatt says:
Waiting on the next tier up before deciding what to do ?? The last thing climate change needs is a top-down approach. If we're to make a difference, it absolutely has to be bottom-up. Perhaps if EEDC said it was waiting for the parish councils it would make sense. (only joking there)
I see, to remember that so much research was done on a motion by the Tories, asking for criminal checks on councillors to be made and results published, that the proposers and seconded didn't even know that what they were advocating would be a criminal offence. Williams is a lawyer I believe yet it slipped past him. Why, just because if came from Tories
Jenna Carpenter says:
Can 'they' just refuse to discuss matters extremely important to residents/Council Tax payers, who have many questions on these matters. Or do they have a lot to hide?
Follow East Devon Watch on WordPress.com
Tim on Vaccine priority: who should get the Covid jab next in UK?
Liz on Devon County Council slams government's 'Victorian era' free school meal scheme
Budleigh Resident on Vaccinating the over 70's – story changes
Roland Craven on Free School Meal vouchers to return after backlash over 'disgraceful' food hampers – how to claim them and who is eligible
Paul F on Free School Meal vouchers to return after backlash over 'disgraceful' food hampers – how to claim them and who is eligible
Enter your email address to receive emails whenever there is a new post.
992,160 pages viewed
Sustainable tourism key to Cumbria's new carbon neutral plan 20 Jan 2021
Fears over coronavirus vaccine supplies as rate drops 20 Jan 2021
Grim milestone 20 Jan 2021
New Onward research: Levelling Up the Tax System 20 Jan 2021
Statue of fossil hunter Mary Anning to be erected after campaign 20 Jan 2021
Campaign to Save Clyst St Mary
Community Voice on Planning
Conflicts of Interest in East Devon .. Anna Minton's report
Councillor Claire Wright
Councillor Susie Bond
CPRE – Campaign to Protect Rural England
CPRE Devon
Devon Local Nature Partnership
East Devon Alliance Matters (discussion group)
East Devon Alliance website
East Devon Watch Facebook
East Devon Watch Twitter
EastDevonTories a-twitter
EDA Matters
Fight for Feniton's Future
Local listing guide
Real Zorro blog
Save Our Sidmouth
Seaton Matters
Sidmouth Independent News
Straitgate Quarry Action Group
Vision Group for Sidmouth – Futures Forum
What Do They Know (Freedom of Information (FOI) requests)
Accountability Affordable and Social Housing Austerity cuts DCC Democracy Developers/ Development EDDC Environment (local) General Election Health and Social Care (local) Hugo Swire Inequality Knowle/Honiton/Exmouth relocation Local Enterprise Partnership Local Plan Misc NHS (local) Scrutiny Transparency Voting