IT News UG Information Technology Managed Services
Samsung's Galaxy S21 phones come with plenty of features — but not a charger
Apple makes welcome change to 'Big Sur' security for Macs
Samsung Galaxy S21, S21 Plus, and S21 Ultra first look: polished design (and prices)
Here's how Samsung's Galaxy S21 compares to the Pixel 5, OnePlus 8T, and more
Pandemic rebound? PC shipments post biggest upswing in a decade
Galaxy reality check: 4 big reasons to avoid Samsung's Android phones
Microsoft adds Teams 'task publishing' for front-line workers
Apple takes big steps to boost diversity in tech
Apple takes huge steps to boost diversity in tech
Q&A: Workplace exec on employee productivity, app plans for 2021
Home/AI/Artificial Intelligence/Timnit Gebru's actual paper may explain why Google ejected her
Timnit Gebru's actual paper may explain why Google ejected her
IT News Ug December 5, 2020	Artificial Intelligence Leave a comment 211 Views
FTC settles with photo storage app that pivoted to facial recognition
Let the dulcet tones of Google's Blob Opera ring in the holiday season with machine learning
Timnit Gebru's team at Google is going public with their side of the story
A paper co-authored by former Google AI ethicist Timnit Gebru raised some potentially thorny questions for Google about whether AI language models may be too big, and whether tech companies are doing enough to reduce potential risks, according to MIT Technology Review. The paper also questioned the environmental costs and inherent biases in large language models.
Google's AI team created such a language model— BERT— in 2018, and it was so successful that the company incorporated BERT into its search engine. Search is a highly lucrative segment of Google's business; in the third quarter of this year alone, it brought in revenue of $26.3 billion. "This year, including this quarter, showed how valuable Google's founding product — search — has been to people," CEO Sundar Pichai said on a call with investors in October.
Gebru and her team submitted their paper, titled "On the Dangers of Stochastic Parrots: Can Language Models Be Too Big?" for a research conference. She said in a series of tweets on Wednesday that following an internal review, she was asked to retract the paper or remove Google employees' names from it. She says she asked Google for conditions for taking her name off the paper, and if they couldn't meet the conditions they could "work on a last date." Gebru says she then received an email from Google informing her they were "accepting her resignation effective immediately."
The head of Google AI, Jeff Dean, wrote in an email to employees that the paper "didn't meet our bar for publication." He wrote that one of Gebru's conditions for continuing to work at Google was for the company to tell her who had reviewed the paper and their specific feedback, which it declined to do. "Timnit wrote that if we didn't meet these demands, she would leave Google and work on an end date. We accept and respect her decision to resign from Google," Dean wrote.
In his letter, Dean wrote that the paper "ignored too much relevant research," a claim that the paper's co-author Emily M. Bender, a professor of computational linguistics at the University of Washington, disputed. Bender told MIT Technology Review that the paper, which had six collaborators, was "the sort of work that no individual or even pair of authors can pull off," noting it had a citation list of 128 references.
Gebru is known for her work on algorithmic bias, especially in facial recognition technology. In 2018, she co-authored a paper with Joy Buolamwini that showed error rates for identifying darker-skinned people were much higher than error rates for identifying lighter-skinned people, since the datasets used to train algorithms were overwhelmingly white.
Gebru told Wired in an interview published Thursday that she felt she was being censored. "You're not going to have papers that make the company happy all the time and don't point out problems," she said. "That's antithetical to what it means to be that kind of researcher."
Since news of her termination became public, thousands of supporters, including more than 1,500 Google employees have signed a letter of protest. "We, the undersigned, stand in solidarity with Dr. Timnit Gebru, who was terminated from her position as Staff Research Scientist and Co-Lead of Ethical Artificial Intelligence (AI) team at Google, following unprecedented research censorship," reads the petition, titled Standing with Dr. Timnit Gebru.
"We call on Google Research to strengthen its commitment to research integrity and to unequivocally commit to supporting research that honors the commitments made in Google's AI Principles."
The petitioners are demanding that Dean and others "who were involved with the decision to censor Dr. Gebru's paper meet with the Ethical AI team to explain the process by which the paper was unilaterally rejected by leadership."
Google did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Saturday.
This Article was first published on theverge.com
About IT News Ug
Previous Elon Musk reportedly plans to move to Texas
Next Chrome OS 87 adds tab search to help you find that one tab you opened hours ago but need to look at again
Massachusetts on the verge of becoming first state to ban police use of facial recognition
The bill still requires signing by the state's governor
Shop Amazon Devices | All-new Fire HD 10 tablet
Categories Select Category AI (1,420) Adobe (525) Amazon (3) Apps (1) Artificial Intelligence (64) Business (2) Coronavirus (1) Creators (2) Culture (1) Cybersecurity (1) Disney (1) Entertainment (1) Facebook (1) Film (1) Gaming (1) How-to (1) Instagram (2) Kickstarter (1) Mobile (7) Music (2) Policy (1) Politics (1) Robot (2) Robots (737) Samsung (2) Sony (1) Tech (26) US & World (2) Amazon (463) Amazon (163) Amazon Alexa (14) Amazon Prime Day 2020 (2) Antitrust (2) Artificial Intelligence (5) Aviation (1) Black Friday 2020 (1) Business (3) CES 2020 News (3) CES 2021 News (1) Circuit Breaker (3) Coronavirus (23) Creators (1) Cyber Monday (2) Cybersecurity (3) Drones (3) Energy (1) Entertainment (12) Environment (5) Facebook (1) Film (4) Gadgets (5) Gaming (5) Google (5) Headphones (2) Health (3) Marvel (1) Mobile (2) Music (2) Netflix (3) Policy (9) Politics (2) Regulation (1) Reviews (5) Robot (1) Samsung (1) Science (1) Slack (1) Smart Home (4) Sony (1) Space (2) Speech and Moderation (1) Streaming Wars (3) Tech (64) The Vergecast (2) TV Shows (7) US & World (1) Verge Deals (1) Wearable (4) Android (1,135) Android (2) Artificial Intelligence (1) AT&T (2) Augmented Reality (2) Black Friday (1) Business (1) CES 2020 News (10) CES 2021 News (1) Circuit Breaker (6) Dell (1) Featured Stories (1) Featured Videos (1) Film (1) Gadgets (2) Headphones (15) Health (4) Huawei (1) Intel (1) Laptops (3) Law (1) LG (1) Mobile (1) Netflix (1) OnePlus (1) Processor Newsletter (1) Reviews (3) Samsung (150) Tech (25) The Vergecast (1) TV Shows (1) TVs (5) USB-C (2) Verizon (3) Wearable (12) Apple (1,103) Adobe (8) Antitrust (2) Apple event (27) Apple Rumors (8) Apps (37) Augmented Reality (5) Beats (2) Black Friday 2020 (1) Business (7) Cameras and Photography (6) CES 2020 News (1) CES 2021 News (2) Circuit Breaker (12) Coronavirus (9) Creators (8) Culture (1) Cybersecurity (11) Dell (1) Design (2) Desktops (6) Disney (1) Editorial (5) Entertainment (40) Facebook (3) Featured Stories (5) Featured Videos (2) Fitness (1) Gadgets (10) Games Review (1) Gaming (19) Google (13) Hands-on (1) Headphones (23) How-to (8) HP (2) Intel (1) Internet Culture (1) iOS (8) iPad (17) iPhone (32) Kickstarter (1) Laptops (12) LG (2) Linkedin (1) Logitech (2) macOS (12) Mobile (40) Music (2) Netflix (2) OnePlus (1) Phone Cases (1) Photography (1) Podcasts (1) Policy (18) Politics (1) Privacy (1) Processor Newsletter (5) Report (2) Reviews (33) Samsung (1) Science (2) Smart Home (1) Sony (1) Space (1) StoryStream (1) Streaming Wars (2) Tech (340) Tech Apple (17) The Vergecast (8) TL;DR (1) Transportation (6) TV Shows (1) TVs (3) Twitter (2) US & World (13) USB-C (2) Vaping (1) Verge Deals (1) Virtual Reality (1) Wearable (18) Web (4) WWDC 2019 (1) WWDC 2020 (27) Xiaomi (1) YouTube (2) Cars (301) Aviation (1) Business (2) Cars (161) CES 2020 News (5) CES 2021 News (2) Electric Cars (2) Entertainment (3) Environment (2) Ford (3) Geneva Motor Show (1) GM (2) Health (1) Mercedes-Benz (1) Motorsports (1) Rideables (2) Robot (1) Tech (9) Tesla (2) Transportation (65) Uber (1) Volkswagen (1) Cloud Computing (190) Data Centers (47) Facebook (1,613) 2020 election (6) Antitrust (1) Apps (1) Augmented Reality (3) Business (3) Coronavirus (14) Creators (4) Cryptocurrency (2) Cybersecurity (4) Disney (1) Entertainment (5) Environment (3) Facebook (155) Featured Stories (1) Film (1) Gadgets (1,061) Health (6) How-to (1) Instagram (29) Microsoft (1) Mobile (26) Motorsports (1) Music (2) Oculus (5) Policy (15) Politics (28) Privacy (1) Reviews (1) Science (2) Speech and Moderation (6) Tech (126) The Vergecast (1) Transportation (1) Twitter (2) US & World (4) Virtual Reality (21) YouTube (1) Google (987) 2020 election (1) Android (88) Antitrust (3) Apps (20) Artificial Intelligence (4) Asus (2) Augmented Reality (7) Breaking (1) Business (10) Cameras and Photography (7) CES 2020 News (5) CES 2021 News (5) Chrome (15) Chromebook (2) Circuit Breaker (4) Copyright (1) Coronavirus (14) Creators (1) Culture (1) Cybersecurity (7) Disney (1) Editorial (3) Entertainment (44) Exclusive (1) Featured Stories (1) Featured Videos (1) Gadgets (4) Gaming (5) Good Deals (2) Google (1) Google Assistant (14) Google Pixel (19) Hands-on (9) Headphones (6) How-to (19) HP (1) Huawei (3) Hulu (1) Laptops (6) Law (2) Lenovo (2) Mobile (42) Netflix (1) OnePlus (1) Podcasts (1) Policy (15) Processor Newsletter (1) Reviews (16) Robot (1) Samsung (4) Science (4) Smart Home (1) Sonos (2) StoryStream (1) Tech (354) Tech Google (16) The Vergecast (2) TL;DR (2) Transportation (16) TVs (2) US & World (7) Virtual Reality (2) Wearable (6) Web (2) Xiaomi (2) YouTube (10) Hardware (462) Internet (126) IPhone (27) IT News (654) Microsoft (633) 2020 election (1) Amazon (1) Apps (10) Artificial Intelligence (2) Augmented Reality (1) Business (3) Cameras and Photography (1) CES 2020 News (9) CES 2021 News (1) Circuit Breaker (1) Coronavirus (5) Creators (4) Cybersecurity (6) Dell (1) Editorial (3) Entertainment (172) Exclusive (2) Featured Stories (6) Featured Videos (3) Gaming (6) Good Deals (1) Google (9) Hands-on (6) Headphones (3) Health (1) How-to (6) HP (1) Huawei (2) IBM (1) Intel (3) Laptops (3) Microsoft Build (7) Mobile (3) Music (1) PC Gaming (1) Podcasts (2) Report (5) Reviews (17) Samsung (1) Science (5) Slack (7) Sonos (1) Tech (74) The Vergecast (2) Twitter (1) USB-C (1) Verge Deals (1) Watch This (1) Windows 10 (22) Xbox (3) Mobile (357) Networking (142) Operating Systems (300) Security (252) Software (416) Software Downloads (4) Storage (71) Telsa (156) Aviation (1) Cars (60) Coronavirus (3) Culture (1) Elon Musk (6) Energy (1) Environment (1) Ford (1) Google (1) Health (2) HP (1) Law (1) Politics (1) Privacy (1) Space (1) Tesla (42) Transportation (15) Twitter (2) Virtualization (15)
BMW becomes the latest automaker to shut down its subscription service
Windows 10X is now Microsoft's true answer to Chrome OS
You'll soon be able to upload files as big as 250GB to OneDrive, Microsoft Teams, and SharePoint
Samsung reveals the Galaxy S21 series, $200 cheaper this time
The new Asus Fanless Chromebox could easily be mistaken for a wireless router