Whither transparency
David Berlind is appalled at the DOJ for asking for information on search data from MSN, AOL, Yahoo! and Google.
By Phil Windley for Between the Lines | January 23, 2006 -- 15:42 GMT (07:42 PST) | Topic: Big Data Analytics
David Berlind is appalled at the DOJ for asking for information on search data from MSN, AOL, Yahoo! and Google. Google's been lauded on all sides for this decision, but I wonder why. Google isn't doing this to protect their customers. They're doing it for the PR value and to protect business secrets.
The DOJ is asking for the data to answer a question that comes up over and over again in court cases related to online pornography: do filters work well enough? The ACLU and other litigants use the argument that "filters work well and therefore there is no compelling government interest" as a pillar of their cases. Leaving aside the merits (or lack thereof) of these bills, I think it's disingenuous to say "of course filtering works" and then say "you can't have the data you want to determine that for yourself."
Transparency seems to be fine for everyone else. I can think of a number of ways Google could have cooperated and negotiated reasonable protections for it's data. In the end, this really isn't about privacy--it's about marketing and PR.
Digital Transformation Robotics Internet of Things Innovation Enterprise Software CXO
More from Phil Windley
Twitter now officially part of the live web
Which part of "share" didn't you understand?
Going green with DC power
Economics that are impossible to stop
Will Google's more-efficient 'Reformer' mitigate or accelerate the arms race in AI?
Google's latest refinement to the popular "Transformer" language model promises to make state of the art available to those with a smaller computer budget. But the advances could ...
AI can fight climate change but there's a catch: Optimization doesn't automatically equal emissions reduction
Luminaries of AI such as Yoshua Bengio gathered in Vancouver last month to champion ways machine learning can mitigate global warming. Despite energy, enthusiasm, and brilliant ...
It's official - data analytics is swiftly moving to the cloud. AtScale is facilitating this, and CEO Chris Lynch shares his insights the hows and whys, in light of the unveiling of AtScale's ...
DevOps and observability in the 2020s
What do the data tell us on the direction modern software development is going? Cloud, open source, machine learning -- it's all here, but blind spots remain. ...
MariaDB Platform X4 adds cloud-first, columnar storage
New MariaDB Platform X4 release supports hybrid operational/analytical "smart transactions," standardizes on cloud object storage to do it.
Rob Bearden takes over as Cloudera CEO
Cloudera is turning to a familiar face for its next leader.