English Language Learners Meta
English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. It only takes a minute to sign up.
tense of two similar sentences are different
in the Vikings main title song there are two similar sentences:
If I had a heart I could love you
If I had a voice I would sing
the first sentence can't be "If I had a heart I would love you"(like the second sentence)? what is the difference between using could and would here?
tense conditional-constructions
stangdon
jack.mathjack.math
What is the Vikings main title song? Please add a reference.
The singer is singing: "If I had a voice I would sing." Ha!
– Chowzen
The difference lies in having the mere ability to do something and choosing to do something that you are able to do.
If he had a heart, he would be able to love.
If he had a voice, he would choose to sing.
If I had the money, I could buy it. ability
If I had the money, I would buy it. intention
Having the ability to do something does not necessarily mean that you would actually do it.
If I had the money, I could buy it. I wish I had the money to buy it! I want it!
If I had the money, I could buy it. But it is a foolish extravagance and I would never buy something like that!
TᴚoɯɐuoTᴚoɯɐuo
118k77 gold badges9696 silver badges195195 bronze badges
The use of "could" implies that if the singer had a heart, loving the subject is something they would want to do but there may be other factors that get in the way - knowing Vikings, the looting & pillaging comes first and the lovin' comes second.
It may just be a way to have each line sound similar but by using could instead of would it gives a subtle indication that even if the singer could have their way and devote themselves to loving, that choice might not be theirs to make anyway.
david_cdavid_c
To me, the singer is implying that he/she does not have a heart. Therefore they cannot love the object of his affection.
In the second sentiment, they also imply that they do not have a voice, but if they did, they would sing.
The "if I had" phrase makes the would/could subject moot (Adj. 2. of little or no practical value, meaning, or relevance; purely academic). It doesn't matter what they would or could do, it's impossible.
The reasoning behind using one word in the first phrase and another in the second phrase is most likely poetic in nature, i.e. it sounds better than saying would or could in both phrases.
ChowzenChowzen
Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged tense conditional-constructions .
Why do these sentences, which have similar structures, use different tenses in their object clauses?
Conditionals , What are the differences?
What's the difference between these sentences?
Different kinds of conditional sentences which look similar and confusing
What's the difference between "I didn't sing the song" and "I had not sung the song"?
Third condition sentences using only "would" in lieu of "would have"
Would've/would, conditional sentences
CNN, conditionals in news sentences don't conform to any conditional types at all. What are they?
Difference between subjunctive and conditional
Conditional sentences usage
English Language Learners Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled